Captain Kelly’s Kitchen: Custom & Gourmet Cookies

Directions Contact the business

Captain Kelly’s Kitchen: Custom & Gourmet Cookies My name is Kelly Kane and I have a passion for baking and I love to share that passion with people.

I specialize in custom decorated cookies, gourmet drop cookies and cookie cakes. I am currently serving Columbus Ohio and its surrounding areas.

Nothing gets more classic than Black and White. .
10/16/2026

Nothing gets more classic than Black and White.

.

👼🏻October 15th is Pregnancy and Infant Loss Day. 👼🏻If you've been following me for a while, you know the story. 13 year...
10/15/2026

👼🏻October 15th is Pregnancy and Infant Loss Day. 👼🏻

If you've been following me for a while, you know the story. 13 years ago, I was pregnant with Identical Twin boys. It took us a while to get pregnant but we finally got pregnant, only to find out there were 2 of them!!!

Around the 21 week mark, they got diagnosed with TTTS (Twin to Twin Transfusion Syndrome). After a failed attempt at fixing the issue followed by a week long stay in L+D, I had to deliver them at 24 weeks 5 days gestational age.

Nathan Daniel (Bottom pic) and Colin Martin (top pic) both weighed in just over 1 lb each. Colin lived 2 days and Nathan lived 26 days.

To say that was the hardest time in my life is an understatement. Throughout my grief process, I met so many other women who have gone through a child loss one way or another.

So if you are going through or have been through miscarriages, stillbirths or infant loss, all my love goes out to you today and always. You are not alone. Everyone's journey through those hard times is different and no ones heartbreak is bigger or less than someone else's. Your journey, your grief, is just that.... yours.

*If you want to read my entire story about what I went through and get to know my angel babies a bit better and about my first experience as a mom, feel free to hop on over to my blog! www.twotinyangels.blogspot.com

I’m OBSESSED with this Halloween cookie option I will have at my Farmstand on the 28th! My 10 year old absolutely LOVES ...
10/14/2026

I’m OBSESSED with this Halloween cookie option I will have at my Farmstand on the 28th!

My 10 year old absolutely LOVES Sour Patch Kids, so when I saw this packaging from Miss Cookie Packaging, I knew it was going right in my cart!

But seriously! Adorable right? I will have these in Orange, Red, Blue and Green.

*obviously this is an AI generated background but I assure you the cookie is ALL me! I will never AI my baked goods but to save me time from staging a background, this was the easiest option.

Pasta meets jelly cats meets 1st Birthday. You cant get customization like this at the store!
10/13/2026

Pasta meets jelly cats meets 1st Birthday.

You cant get customization like this at the store!

Thanks for another great Farmstand Friday! If you weren’t able to make it out today but are still in need of of sweets ...
10/10/2026

Thanks for another great Farmstand Friday!

If you weren’t able to make it out today but are still in need of of sweets for the weekend, here is what I have left:

🍪 16 Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cookies -$3/each

🍪12 Chocolate Toffee -$3/each

🍪 2 browned butter Chocolate Chip -$3/each

🍪 5 Breast cancer Ribbon decorated cookies -$5/each

🍪 3 packs of Chocolate brownie decorated pumpkins. 4 cookies in a pack. -$15/each

Pick up can be scheduled for tomorrow (Saturday) or Monday! Comment or PM me if you want any of them!

1:00 Stock Update! 🍂5 breast cancer ribbon cookies🍂 2 dunkers🍂 5 packs of chocolate brownie decorated pumpkins. (Comes w...
10/09/2026

1:00 Stock Update!

🍂5 breast cancer ribbon cookies
🍂 2 dunkers
🍂 5 packs of chocolate brownie decorated pumpkins. (Comes with 4 cookies)
🍂 Chocolate chip (restocked once so what’s out is all I have left)
🍂 PB Butterfinger
🍂 Chocolate Toffee (restocked once so what’s out is all I have left)
🍂 Reese’s stuffed chocolate cookie (restocked once so what’s out is all I have left)
🍂 2 Oatmeal Cream pies

Pumpkin Spice is Sold Out

*if you can’t make it till later or even tomorrow and want to guarantee you get something, just message me and I can shop for you and you can Venmo me to hold it for you.

📍5732 Jennybrook Lane, Hilliard

10/09/2026

Farmstand is open!

📍5732 Jennybrook Lane, Hilliard

🌟FALL COOKIE FARMSTAND MENU🌟I have a great line up for tomorrows Farmstand. Once again it is heavy on the gourmet drop...
10/08/2026

🌟FALL COOKIE FARMSTAND MENU🌟

I have a great line up for tomorrows Farmstand. Once again it is heavy on the gourmet drop cookies this time but I am definitely sprinkling in some decorated in there.

Here is a price list just in case you want to prepare.

🍂Oatmeal Cream Pies - $5/each
🍂 Reese’s cup filled Chocolate Cookie - $5/each

$3/each drop cookies include
🍪 chocolate chip,
🍪chocolate toffee,
🍪pumpkin spice with cream cheese chips 🍪Peanut Butter Butterfinger

💕 Breast Cancer Ribbon Cookies - $5/each
🍂 cookies and Cream Dunkers with C&C Buttercream - $10
🎃 Stack of 4 chocolate Brownie pumpkins - $15/each.

📍5732 Jennybrook Lane, Hilliard
⏰ 9:30am - 7 pm or sell out
💰 Accepts Venmo, PayPal or ring the bell to pay with cash.

This is run by the honor system so when you come, grab a bag, pick out your goodies, add up the total and then choose your method of payment.

I will be home all day so if you have any questions feel free to ring the bell and ask!

‼️And then SAVE THE DATE‼️

WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 28th - this will be my BIG 🎃 Halloween Farmstand with so many decorated cookies and drop cookies to fill your treat bag with. I have some fun ideas planned so keep an eye 👁️ out!

See you tomorrow!!!!

Cookie Farmstand this Friday, October 9th!Bringing in the Halloween colors this time with a Reese’s stuffed chocolate co...
10/06/2026

Cookie Farmstand this Friday, October 9th!

Bringing in the Halloween colors this time with a Reese’s stuffed chocolate cookie with Reese’s pieces on top!

💛🧡🤎

Opens at 9:30am
Closes 7:30 or sellout.

📍5732 Jennybrook Lane, Hilliard

When I start getting orders for pumpkin themed shower and birthday cookies, you know fall is here! 🍂…and you know what? ...
10/03/2026

When I start getting orders for pumpkin themed shower and birthday cookies, you know fall is here! 🍂

…and you know what?

I’m totally here for it! Fall is my favorite season. Give me all the fall weather, fall clothes and fall flavors any day.


Address

Hilliard, OH
43026

Opening Hours

9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Captain Kelly’s Kitchen: Custom & Gourmet Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Captain Kelly’s Kitchen: Custom & Gourmet Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category