Clicky

Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery

Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery We are a small family bakery that has been in Columbus over 30 years! Everything is made from scrat Ahlemeyer Bakery is a family owned and operated bakery in Columbus, Indiana.

We sell a variety of pies, cookies, brownies, sweet rolls, breads and other baked goods (most of our items are vegan or able to be made vegan). We even carry the Indiana state pie- Sugar Cream! Our goal is quality, baking fresh products every day. Because of this we can run out quickly, so please feel free to call and place an order if there is something specific you are looking for. Our number is 812-372-7437. Great for holidays, birthdays, special gatherings, or for no occasion at all!

Operating as usual

We're still accepting orders for Easter weekend! Give us a call at 812-372-PIES (7437), or message us here on Facebook o...
04/08/2022

We're still accepting orders for Easter weekend! Give us a call at 812-372-PIES (7437), or message us here on Facebook or Instagram! β€οΈπŸ§‘πŸ’›πŸ’šπŸ’™πŸ’œ ✌️

No April Fool's here, our Easter menu is up!  This special menu will be available by order in addition to our regular me...
04/01/2022

No April Fool's here, our Easter menu is up! This special menu will be available by order in addition to our regular menu, starting April 6th and continuing through April 16th (and in limited quantities on the shelf for walk-in purchases)! The deadline to place an order for Easter weekend is April 9th, so call or message us as soon as possible!

We accept orders via phone at 812-372-PIES (7437) during our business hours, or via message through Facebook or Instagram messenger. We are also available on DoorDash during open business hours!

Hop on in for some delicious homemade, vegan candy!

#shoplocal #ColumbusIN #columbusindianabakery #columbusinbakery #veganbakery #vegancandy #eastercandy #eastermenu #vegan #ahlemeyerfarmsbakery #ahlemeyerbakery #veganeaster

03/10/2022

No sur-pies to some of you, Pi day is about 3.14159 days away (πŸ˜‚)!!

Unfortunately we are closed ON pi day (Monday 3/14), but we will be open today until 6, Friday from 10 to 6, and Saturday from 10 to 2 (and almost anything you buy today will hold up great untill pi day! And definitely anything bought Friday or Saturday will be great. If you are worried though, please just ask us and we will let you know how best to store your item to keep it in peak shape until Monday!)!

Thank you for celebrating pi(e) day with us! βœŒοΈπŸ’—πŸ₯§

It's pie of the month day here Ahlemeyer bakery! Anyone think they can "crack the nut" this month?
03/09/2022

It's pie of the month day here Ahlemeyer bakery! Anyone think they can "crack the nut" this month?

03/04/2022

Have you heard? Our neighbors at Ye Olde Fish House are having a special event this evening!

Since we share a parking lot, it will be very busy/chaotic from about 3:30 until we close at 6. We will still be open for walk in's and #DoorDash during this time though!

If you are coming for the event, we'd love for you to stop in and check us out (even if just for the free smells)! 😊

Happy Friday!!

***Valentine's Menu Update***Exciting news!  We will officially have chocolate covered strawberries!  We have added them...
02/07/2022

***Valentine's Menu Update***

Exciting news! We will officially have chocolate covered strawberries! We have added them to our Valentine's menu. We will have a very limited number on the shelf for walk-in's, so if you know you'll be coming in we highly recommend placing an order! , You can pre-order them (or anything from our Valentine's menu) by sending us a message here through facebook or instagram, or give us a call Wednesday (10-2) or Thursday (10-6) at 812-372-7437. Have a sweet week!

It looks like conditions are still fairly treacherous so we are going to go ahead and be closed today as well. We will s...
02/04/2022

It looks like conditions are still fairly treacherous so we are going to go ahead and be closed today as well. We will surely be able to open Saturday, so we look forward to seeing you then! We hope you are staying safe and warm! πŸ’•β€οΈβœŒοΈ

ROAD CONDITION UPDATE

Roads are still VERY slick and snow covered this morning. If you must commute this morning, travel with caution and give yourself extra time.

It is still continuing to snow and snow has drifted from last night leaving county and state roads covered.

Photo below is 46 East.

As long as the county is still under a red travel advisory we will remain closed. It's looking like that will be until a...
02/04/2022

As long as the county is still under a red travel advisory we will remain closed. It's looking like that will be until at least noon tomorrow... We will update again in the morning on whether we feel we can safely open at noon, or if we will have to take another full snow day.

We hope everyone is staying safe and warm out there!!

Winter Storm Update: Thursday 5:00 p.m.

Bartholomew County remains under a Winter Storm Warning through 1:00 a.m. Friday. Updated snow amounts for Bartholomew County are now approximately the four (4) to seven (7) inch range between now and Friday morning. We have finally transitioned to all snow in the county.

Winds are also beginning to increase across the area. We can still expect 35 to 40 mph winds tapering off around 1:00 to 3:00 a.m. This will increase our visibility issues, especially after dark, and blowing and drifting snow. It will be a wet and heavy snow with this storm . Keep in mind that as temperatures drop, the current wet roadway will have the possibility to freeze and create ice issues on the roadways

Highway crews are continue to work to clear roadways but are fighting heavy snowfall in areas along with the blowing and drifting snow. It’s anticipated that they will take a break around the late evening timeframe for rest and sleep before returning approximately 3:00 to 4:00 a.m. to begin again.

Many questions have come about regarding the release or downgrade of the current travel status from a Warning (Red) level. We are not anticipating the current level changing before mid-morning or later on Friday. We will have to evaluate the conditions at that time as well as take into consideration the expected sub-zero temperatures Friday night and additional refreezing of roadways.

The county’s travel status has been upgraded to a Warning Level (Red).

Warning

The highest level of local travel advisory, means that travel may be restricted to emergency management workers only. During a "warning" local travel advisory, individuals are directed to:
(A) refrain from all travel;
(B) comply with necessary emergency measures;
(C) cooperate with public officials and disaster services forces in executing emergency operations plans; and
(D) obey and comply with the lawful directions of properly identified officers.

Closings:
County buildings are closed for Friday, February 4, with employees working remotely if possible.
City buildings, including City Hall, are closed Friday, February 4.
We have spoken with BCSC this afternoon about current conditions and expected travel status. We will share any information that they release if/when we receive it about potential closings for Friday, February 4.

We continue to monitor and will continue to update as needed. Please use caution and stay home if you absolutely do not need to be out. We anticipate conditions outside and on our roadways to deteriorate as the evening continues and through the night. This prolonged event will require multiple rounds from highway crews to get roadways completely clear. We will continue to monitor and evaluate the travel status changing it only when warranted by improved conditions

Our menu for Valentine's week is here!  These will be available by order next week (2/9- 2/12).  We will have these on t...
02/03/2022

Our menu for Valentine's week is here! These will be available by order next week (2/9- 2/12). We will have these on the shelf Friday 2/11 and Saturday 2/12, too, but quantities on the shelf will be limited! (All items are vegan, and the truffles are gluten free, too!)

You can pre-order these by giving us a call during our business hours at 812-372-7437, or sending us a message through our Facebook or Instagram.

#columbusindianabakery #veganbakery #vegantreats #valentines2022 #shoplocal

02/03/2022

We will be closed today (Thursday 2/3) due to the severe weather conditions. Please stay home and stay safe out there, and we hope to see you Friday! πŸ’—

02/01/2022
Today is pie of the month day here at Ahlemeyer Bakery! Any guesses on what the flavor is?  We will reveal the answer th...
01/12/2022

Today is pie of the month day here at Ahlemeyer Bakery! Any guesses on what the flavor is? We will reveal the answer this evening after we have them all delivered! 🍊

Send us a message for more information on pie of the month club, or to get signed up! We offer 3 month, 6 month, or full year subscriptions (with or without delivery).

Have a sweet day! ❀️✌️πŸ₯§

#veganbakery #columbusindiana #pie #freshbaked #bakery #shoplocal #madefromscratch #ahlemeyerfarmsbakery

After having a week off for a little recuperation, we're back in action and ready to bake 2022 our best year ever!! We w...
01/10/2022

After having a week off for a little recuperation, we're back in action and ready to bake 2022 our best year ever!!

We will be kicking the week off Wednesday with our first pie of the month for the year (the flavor is a surprise we will reveal Wednesday)! If you're interested in our pie of the month club send us a message, we're happy to answer any questions and can even get you signed up online!

We've missed you! Looking forward to getting back to baking our best and seeing your smiling faces! πŸ’—πŸ˜ŠπŸ₯§

#freshbaked #localbakery #veganbakery #columbusindiana #pie

First we want to say thank you to everyone for such an amazing holiday season!! All of you were so understanding, patien...
12/27/2021

First we want to say thank you to everyone for such an amazing holiday season!! All of you were so understanding, patient, and flexible as we navigated our way through the season with only 3 employees! Also, thank you too them for being total rockstars! They dedicated SO much of their time and lives, working tons of overtime, to get all of the orders out the door on time AND get extras out on the shelf!! It was one of our best years yet, and we couldn't have done it without any of them! ❀️

That being said, we are going to take the first week of January (1/3-1/8) off as a little rest and refresh for our staff!

New Year's week we will have special hours to accommodate for the holiday, and when we come back the week of the 10th we will have new hours that are hopefully easier to remember- Wednesday 10-2, Thursday and Friday 10-6, and Saturday 10-2.

Thank you again and we look forward to baking for you!! ❀️πŸ₯§πŸͺ✌️

***Reminder: we have special holiday hours this week!***We are closed today (Tuesday), but will be open Wednesday and Th...
12/21/2021

***Reminder: we have special holiday hours this week!***

We are closed today (Tuesday), but will be open Wednesday and Thursday 10-6. Friday we will be open for order pickup from 10-1:00PM, and we will set out any extra pies (sometimes we miscount or orders don't get picked up) from 1-2:00. On Friday we will have the pre-paid order table out back again, for drive through pickup if you paid ahead on your order!

We are no longer accepting orders for this week, but we will have lots of extras on the shelf Wednesday!! We will have some extra, but less on Thursday, and Friday will bet the most sparse selection. So if you didn't get an order placed, Wednesday is your best bet for picking up what you're looking for!

Thank you, and stay warm and enjoy this beautiful solstice!! ❄️❀️πŸ₯§πŸͺ

Looking for a unique gift idea?We will have small and large holiday-themed candy trays on the shelf Friday and Saturday ...
12/16/2021

Looking for a unique gift idea?

We will have small and large holiday-themed candy trays on the shelf Friday and Saturday this week, and possibly some next week (we are no longer accepting orders for these, they are limited quantity).

For a gift that keeps on giving, considering signing someone up for our special pie of the month club!! We offer 3, 6, or full year subscriptions, and delivery is available, too! It has been a blast in our inaugural year... We've had so much positive feedback, and almost 100% subscription renewal!! Some flavors we surprised members with in 2021 were pina colada pie, cherry pecan pie, PB chocolate banana pie, cranberry meringue, and the blueberry Rhubarb which was so popular we started carrying it regularly in the store! For 2022 we will repeat some of the most popular varieties, but debut some brand new flavors as well! Pick up is the second Wednesday of every month (and we send a reminder text the Monday before).

If you have any questions, feel free to send us a message here and we'll happily answer! We can sign you up for the pie of the month club in store or over the phone at 812-372-PIES (7437).

πŸ₯§β€οΈπŸͺπŸŽ„

#veganbakery #holidaybaking #shoplocal #uniquegifts #Columbusindiana #bakery #Indianabakery #vegan

'Twas the week before ChristmasAnd though nearly at limit,Ahlemeyer is still accepting ordersSo hurry and call- this min...
12/14/2021

'Twas the week before Christmas
And though nearly at limit,
Ahlemeyer is still accepting orders
So hurry and call- this minute! 😁😁

**************************

We are trying something a little different with our hours this Christmas Eve (12/24), keeping it orders only from 10- 1, then we will set out any extra goodies and open for walk-ins from 1-2.

Attached you can also find our holiday menu- we will accept orders for these items only for 12/22, 12/23, and 12/24. We are planning to have some of our regular menu items that are absent from the holiday menu (candies, sweet breads, other cookies) on the shelf this week, so you still have a chance to grab your favorites and freeze them for the holiday! We are hoping to continue accepting orders through this Friday (12/17), but if we exceed capacity before then we may have to stop early again! You can place an order by giving us a call at 812-372-PIES(7437) during our business hours (Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday 10-6 or Saturday 10-2).

Thank you for being patient and understanding with us as we navigate this busy holiday season! βœŒοΈπŸ’—πŸ₯§

#locallybaked #vegan #bakery #ahlemeyerfarmsbakery #veganpies #holidaybaking

December is here and we're quickly heading into the next round of winter holidays! We are going to try doing our hours a...
12/02/2021

December is here and we're quickly heading into the next round of winter holidays!

We are going to try doing our hours a little different this Christmas Eve (12/24), keeping it orders only from 10- 1, then we will set out any extra goodies and open for walk-ins from 1-2.

Attached you can also find our holiday menu- we will accept orders for these items only for 12/22, 12/23, and 12/24. We are planning to have some of our regular menu items that are absent from the holiday menu (candies, sweet breads, other cookies) on the shelf in the weeks leading up, so you still have a chance to grab your favorites and freeze them for the holiday! We are hoping to accept orders until 12/17, but if we exceed capacity before then we may have to stop early again! You can place an order by giving us a call at 812-372-PIES(7437) during our business hours (Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday 10-6 or Saturday 10-2).

Thank you for being patient and flexible with us as we navigate this busy holiday season! βœŒοΈπŸ’—πŸ₯§

#locallybaked #vegan #bakery #ahlemeyerfarmsbakery #veganpies #holidaybaking

11/24/2021

***BREAKING NEWS***

WE WILL BE OPEN UNTIL 2:30 TO SELL EXTRA PIES THAT WEREN'T PICKED UP!! We have apple, cherry, and lots of pumpkins amongst others! Hope to see you in time!

***A few Thanksgiving updates and tips!***1) We are starting today with very few extra pies on the shelf. We are hoping ...
11/22/2021

***A few Thanksgiving updates and tips!***

1) We are starting today with very few extra pies on the shelf. We are hoping to have more on the shelf Tuesday morning, so if you don't see what you want on the shelf today try back again tomorrow! We will keep our phone system and Facebook updated as we sell out and restock, so stay tuned!

2) Exciting news!! Our delivery team the Bartholomew County Extension Homemakers has been amazing enough to agree to setting up a tent behind the bakery on Tuesday and Wednesday for a pre-paid order drive thru!!!!!!
SO if you prepaid for your order, you can pull around back to the canopy to pick up your order on Tuesday and Wednesday- you don't even have to come inside! Be sure to give them a tip to show your appreciation (the proceeds go towards their scholarship fund)!!

3) We had our first overnight shift last night to get started on our 1,000 pies that are on order Tuesday and Wednesday!!!! So please bare with us as well try to get through baking and managing the phone today (we are no longer accepting orders until December be 1, by the way)!

4) One more tip: if you have an order, we advise you *not* come first thing when we open. We WILL hold your order all day, and walk-ins who are trying to get pies off the shelf WILL be lined up when we open so your best bet is to give it a little cushion before you come in. You'll be glad you did! 😁

Thank you, and happy baking! πŸ’—πŸ₯§βœŒοΈ

Address

2034 17th St
Columbus, IN
47201

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 2pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Telephone

+18123727437

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery:

Videos

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Columbus

Show All

Comments

If Long's opened up I would think you could also, just saying!
With the Dude Easter goodies🐰πŸ₯§
Delicious pies and sticky buns!
We have had a line to the door since we opened! We have been baking around the clock since Sunday, and extra pies are becoming available on a rolling basis! We hope you are able to get your favorite!
So much good stuff!!
Haven't had the opportunity to visit this pie shop for several years but, they have the most fantastic "sugar cream pie"!!!
Amazing job on the pies for Nicole and David's wedding last weekend!
Your 'Apple Strudel' was DELICIOUS and a BIG hIt at the Germanfest last night at the Villas of Stonecrest! Thanks so much.
You know you love Ahlemeyer pie when it's all you can think about after surgery. Best pie ever because they are truly made with love. Love you Kiel women!
My brother, Glenn Petri, brought a cherry custard pie from your bakery to Waterloo, IL. Just like Grandma used to bake. We've already told him he has to bring another one the next time he visits.