What are the opening hours?

Tuesday 10am - 4pm Wednesday 10am - 8pm Friday 10am - 4pm

Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

Home
United States
Columbus, IN
Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

Call Directions Website Contact the business

HOURS!!!! Tuesday and Wednesday 10-4
Friday 10-2
Check Facebook and Instagram for Saturday hours!

10/28/2026

🎃💀👻 Lots of Halloween cookies waiting for all you boys and ghouls!!! Open today until 4 and Friday 10-4!!!

10/24/2026

🎃🍂 NEW TREATS ALERT!! 🍂🎃

We’ve got some fun new goodies waiting for you at Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.! 😍🍪

🐾 NEW soft fall dog treats — because your furry friends deserve a little fall fun, too! 🐶🍎

🍏 Apple C***r Floats — the perfect fall sip-meets-scoop treat!

👻 Halloween decorated sugar cookies — spooky, sweet, and almost too cute to eat!

🎃 DIY Halloween Cookie Kits — get creative and decorate your own spooky sweets!

🍪 AND MORE!! You never know what sweet surprises you’ll find when you stop by!

🧡 We’re OPEN Saturday, October 24th, from 10 AM–2 PM!

Come see what’s new, grab a treat for yourself (and your pup 🐾), and get into the fall spirit with us!

📍 Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.
🍂 Stop in before your favorites disappear!

10/21/2026

🍎🍂 MIDWEEK SCOOP IS HERE! 🍂🍎

🕙 Open today 10–4!

Say hello to your new fall favorite… THE APPLE C***R FLOAT! 🍏🍦

We’re starting with creamy vanilla ice cream… OR mix things up with a scoop of our Caramel Apple Pie ice cream! 😍 Then we pour on the apple c***r, top it with whipped cream and a cinnamon sugar sprinkle…

🍎 BUT WAIT… THERE’S MORE! 🍎

We finish this fall masterpiece with one of our signature baked apple c***r donuts right on top! 🍩🍦

Apple c***r, ice cream, and a donut all in one delicious treat? YES, PLEASE! 🙌

⚠️ ONLY HERE WHILE SUPPLIES LAST! ⚠️

🍂 Don’t wait and miss out on this one! Hurry in today from 10–4 and get your fall fix at Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.! ❤️

09/30/2026

So very sorry! We will see you Friday!!!

09/30/2026

🍦✨ ICE CREAM HAPPY HOUR(S)! ✨🍦

Because what’s better than ice cream? Ice cream at a SPECIAL PRICE! 😍

Join us for our Midweek Scoop Special TODAY ONLY from 4–8 PM! 🎉

Grab your crew, bring your sweet tooth, and come celebrate the middle of the week with a little scoop of happiness! 🍨💕

Happy hour just got a whole lot sweeter! 🍦

⏰ TODAY • 4–8 PM
📍 Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

Address

1109 16th Street
Columbus, IN

Opening Hours

Tuesday	10am - 4pm
Wednesday	10am - 8pm
Friday	10am - 4pm

Telephone

+18125525359

Website

http://www.sugarbayerscookie.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.