Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. My mom and I have had so much fun together learning how to make and decorate cookies! We decided to bring joy from our kitchen to yours! Take a look at what we have done!

Please message us if you would like to order or have any questions at all! Thanks! Check Facebook and Instagram for Saturday hours!

Operating as usual

09/04/2021
Assorted cupcakes for the holiday weekend?!?!! Open Friday until 2 and Saturday 10-1!!! See you in the bakery! #cupcakes...
09/03/2021

Assorted cupcakes for the holiday weekend?!?!! Open Friday until 2 and Saturday 10-1!!! See you in the bakery! #cupcakes #shopsmall #bakery

Assorted cupcakes for the holiday weekend?!?!! Open Friday until 2 and Saturday 10-1!!! See you in the bakery! #cupcakes #shopsmall #bakery

Football is back! Grab some IU cookies while you watch the game tomorrow!!!! GO IU!!! 🏈🏟❤️
09/03/2021

Football is back! Grab some IU cookies while you watch the game tomorrow!!!! GO IU!!! 🏈🏟❤️

Football is back! Grab some IU cookies while you watch the game tomorrow!!!! GO IU!!! 🏈🏟❤️

September Cookie of the Month!Apple Butter!! 🍎🍎🍎 This is a perfectly soft, chewy cookie that has just the right amount o...
09/02/2021

September Cookie of the Month!
Apple Butter!! 🍎🍎🍎 This is a perfectly soft, chewy cookie that has just the right amount of sweet and tangy apple butter flavor. This one is going fast… and it’s just the first day of the month! Yum!!!! #cookies#shopsmall #bakery#appleseason#fallcookies#musttry

September Cookie of the Month!
Apple Butter!! 🍎🍎🍎 This is a perfectly soft, chewy cookie that has just the right amount of sweet and tangy apple butter flavor. This one is going fast… and it’s just the first day of the month! Yum!!!! #cookies#shopsmall #bakery#appleseason#fallcookies#musttry

Afternoon Snacks?!?!?
08/24/2021

Afternoon Snacks?!?!?

Afternoon Snacks?!?!?

08/13/2021
Scary 🦕 🦖🦕🦖🦕
08/11/2021

Scary 🦕 🦖🦕🦖🦕

Scary 🦕 🦖🦕🦖🦕

Today is #nationalsmoresday !!!! We have a s’mores snack mix today to celebrate!! #columbusindiana #shopsmall #smores
08/10/2021

Today is #nationalsmoresday !!!! We have a s’mores snack mix today to celebrate!! #columbusindiana #shopsmall #smores

Today is #nationalsmoresday !!!! We have a s’mores snack mix today to celebrate!! #columbusindiana #shopsmall #smores

Cookie of the month!!!  Blueberry White Chocolate!!! A sweet blueberry flavored cookie with fresh blueberries and creamy...
08/07/2021

Cookie of the month!!! Blueberry White Chocolate!!! A sweet blueberry flavored cookie with fresh blueberries and creamy white chocolate pieces!! 🫐🫐🫐#blueberrycookie #columbusindiana #shopsmall #bakery #cookiesofinstagram #cookies

Cookie of the month!!! Blueberry White Chocolate!!! A sweet blueberry flavored cookie with fresh blueberries and creamy white chocolate pieces!! 🫐🫐🫐#blueberrycookie #columbusindiana #shopsmall #bakery #cookiesofinstagram #cookies

You really don’t NEED a reason to enjoy one of our gourmet chocolate chip cookies… but you do NEED to celebrate National...
08/04/2021

You really don’t NEED a reason to enjoy one of our gourmet chocolate chip cookies… but you do NEED to celebrate National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day!!! Stop by and grab a cookie… or 12 😉🍪

You really don’t NEED a reason to enjoy one of our gourmet chocolate chip cookies… but you do NEED to celebrate National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day!!! Stop by and grab a cookie… or 12 😉🍪

This weeks special!!! Peach spice cake snack loaves!! And peach snickerdoodles are back by popular demand!!! Hurry in!
08/03/2021

This weeks special!!! Peach spice cake snack loaves!! And peach snickerdoodles are back by popular demand!!! Hurry in!

This weeks special!!! Peach spice cake snack loaves!! And peach snickerdoodles are back by popular demand!!! Hurry in!

It’s NATIONAL CHEESECAKE DAY!!!! stop by for a slice… or 2! We have a few options to pick from!! #columbusindiana #natio...
07/30/2021

It’s NATIONAL CHEESECAKE DAY!!!! stop by for a slice… or 2! We have a few options to pick from!! #columbusindiana #nationalcheessecakeday #shopsmall #bakerylife

It’s NATIONAL CHEESECAKE DAY!!!! stop by for a slice… or 2! We have a few options to pick from!! #columbusindiana #nationalcheessecakeday #shopsmall #bakerylife

It’s FRESH Georgia peach time!!!! These peach streusel topped muffins really hit the spot!! Keep an eye out for all of o...
07/14/2021

It’s FRESH Georgia peach time!!!! These peach streusel topped muffins really hit the spot!! Keep an eye out for all of our other peach treats… especially the snickerdoodles… if you remember from last year!!😋😋😋#peachseason #bakery #columbusindiana #shoplocal #shopsmall

It’s FRESH Georgia peach time!!!! These peach streusel topped muffins really hit the spot!! Keep an eye out for all of our other peach treats… especially the snickerdoodles… if you remember from last year!!😋😋😋#peachseason #bakery #columbusindiana #shoplocal #shopsmall

It’s National Sugar Cookie day!!! Buy one Get one FREE!!! Open today 10-2!
07/09/2021

It’s National Sugar Cookie day!!! Buy one Get one FREE!!! Open today 10-2!

It’s National Sugar Cookie day!!! Buy one Get one FREE!!! Open today 10-2!

BUY ONE GET ONE!!!!        Tomorrow, July 9th, is National Sugar Cookie day!!!! Sooooo… we are having a sugar cookie sal...
07/08/2021

BUY ONE GET ONE!!!! Tomorrow, July 9th, is National Sugar Cookie day!!!! Sooooo… we are having a sugar cookie sale!! Buy one Get one!!! (Cash only unless adding to another order) see you at the bakery!! #columbusindiana #shoplocal #nationalsugarcookieday #sugarcookies

BUY ONE GET ONE!!!! Tomorrow, July 9th, is National Sugar Cookie day!!!! Sooooo… we are having a sugar cookie sale!! Buy one Get one!!! (Cash only unless adding to another order) see you at the bakery!! #columbusindiana #shoplocal #nationalsugarcookieday #sugarcookies

💍❤️#columbusindiana #sugarcookies#weddingcookies
07/08/2021

💍❤️#columbusindiana #sugarcookies#weddingcookies

💍❤️#columbusindiana #sugarcookies#weddingcookies

Jeep Cookies! #columbusindiana #sugarcookies #jeep
07/08/2021

Jeep Cookies! #columbusindiana #sugarcookies #jeep

Jeep Cookies! #columbusindiana #sugarcookies #jeep

🎶 I like mine with lettuce and tomato Heinz 57 and french fried potatoes Big kosher pickle and a cold draft beer 🎵🎶🎵🎶 Fe...
07/06/2021

🎶 I like mine with lettuce and tomato Heinz 57 and french fried potatoes Big kosher pickle and a cold draft beer 🎵🎶🎵🎶 Feelin the summer vibes! Visit us today!!! #columbusindiana #summervibes #sugarcookies

🎶 I like mine with lettuce and tomato Heinz 57 and french fried potatoes Big kosher pickle and a cold draft beer 🎵🎶🎵🎶 Feelin the summer vibes! Visit us today!!! #columbusindiana #summervibes #sugarcookies

07/02/2021
4th of July fun!!! We have red velvet cake cookies, sugar cookies, firework funfetti cookies and a delicious fruit pizza...
06/29/2021

4th of July fun!!! We have red velvet cake cookies, sugar cookies, firework funfetti cookies and a delicious fruit pizza cookie!!! Open today and tomorrow only 10-4!!! #columbusindiana #sugarcookies #bakery #fourthofjuly #redwhiteandblue #yummy

4th of July fun!!! We have red velvet cake cookies, sugar cookies, firework funfetti cookies and a delicious fruit pizza cookie!!! Open today and tomorrow only 10-4!!! #columbusindiana #sugarcookies #bakery #fourthofjuly #redwhiteandblue #yummy

Cookie Cakes for Dad!!! We have a limited amount in the bakery today!!!!!
06/19/2021

Cookie Cakes for Dad!!! We have a limited amount in the bakery today!!!!!

Pick up some Father’s Day treats!!!
06/19/2021

Pick up some Father’s Day treats!!!

Pick up some Father’s Day treats!!!

Cupcakes in the bakery today and tomorrow!!                                                                         -Blu...
06/18/2021

Cupcakes in the bakery today and tomorrow!! -Blueberries and cream -Red Velvet cream cheese -Fresh strawberry

Cupcakes in the bakery today and tomorrow!! -Blueberries and cream -Red Velvet cream cheese -Fresh strawberry

#farhersdaygift #fathersdaycookies
06/16/2021

#farhersdaygift #fathersdaycookies

#farhersdaygift #fathersdaycookies

Father’s Day is almost here! Don’t forget to treat the special guy in your life!!!
06/14/2021

Father’s Day is almost here! Don’t forget to treat the special guy in your life!!!

Father’s Day is almost here! Don’t forget to treat the special guy in your life!!!

The sunshine is out! I don’t know about you but we are done with the rain for a bit! Happy Saturday!!!! ☀️☀️☀️☀️#sugarco...
06/12/2021

The sunshine is out! I don’t know about you but we are done with the rain for a bit! Happy Saturday!!!! ☀️☀️☀️☀️#sugarcookies #columbusindiana #wemakelifesweet #sunshine #weekend

The sunshine is out! I don’t know about you but we are done with the rain for a bit! Happy Saturday!!!! ☀️☀️☀️☀️#sugarcookies #columbusindiana #wemakelifesweet #sunshine #weekend

Birthday cookies 🎉🥳🎈🎂
06/11/2021

Birthday cookies 🎉🥳🎈🎂

Birthday cookies 🎉🥳🎈🎂

Cookie of the Month!!!! Kitchen Sink Cookie…. Serious has everything but the kitchen sink! Don’t knock it til you try it...
06/02/2021

Cookie of the Month!!!! Kitchen Sink Cookie…. Serious has everything but the kitchen sink! Don’t knock it til you try it….. it’s surprisingly good… the perfect balance of sweet and salty, soft and crunchy! A must try…

Cookie of the Month!!!! Kitchen Sink Cookie…. Serious has everything but the kitchen sink! Don’t knock it til you try it….. it’s surprisingly good… the perfect balance of sweet and salty, soft and crunchy! A must try…

05/31/2021
Cookie Cakes are my fav!!!!! 🥰
05/30/2021

Cookie Cakes are my fav!!!!! 🥰

Cookie Cakes are my fav!!!!! 🥰

Until I make the real thing…. 🥰
05/29/2021

Until I make the real thing…. 🥰

Until I make the real thing…. 🥰

Birthday Cookies!
05/27/2021

Birthday Cookies!

Birthday Cookies!

Boho vibes 😍
05/25/2021

Boho vibes 😍

Boho vibes 😍

IMPORTANT INFORMATION!!!!Our bakery phone number has changed!!! Please contact us at (812)552-5359❤️
05/20/2021

IMPORTANT INFORMATION!!!!
Our bakery phone number has changed!!! Please contact us at (812)552-5359❤️

IMPORTANT INFORMATION!!!!
Our bakery phone number has changed!!! Please contact us at (812)552-5359❤️

Address

1109 16th Street
Columbus, IN

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 4pm
Wednesday 10am - 4pm
Friday 10am - 2pm

Telephone

+18125525359

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.:

Videos

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Columbus

Show All

Comments

Thank you for the beautiful spring birthday cookies for my friend. Everyone kept commenting on how beautiful they were. Fortunately, they tasted great too!
Oh my word❣️ these little gems are tasty and truly made my day - thank you!
Thanks for the amazing cookies Michael Slevin and Connie Engel Slevin! And thank you Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. for making them! They are perfect 🍎🥼👩🏽‍⚕️🍪 Ashley Slevin Huth Amanda Slevin Daugert Michaela Slevin
These were so fun! And absolutely beautiful and delicious. Thank you for providing a bit of family fun tonight!