Clicky

Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. My mom and I have had so much fun together learning how to make and decorate cookies! We decided to bring joy from our kitchen to yours! Take a look at what we have done!

Please message us if you would like to order or have any questions at all! Thanks! HOURS!!!! Tuesday and Wednesday 10-4
Friday 10-2
Check Facebook and Instagram for Saturday hours!

Operating as usual

OPEN TODAY UNTIL 1!!Pupster dog and cat treats 50% off this week!!!! Stop by for a treat for you and your furry love! 🐱🐶...
03/19/2022

OPEN TODAY UNTIL 1!!
Pupster dog and cat treats 50% off this week!!!! Stop by for a treat for you and your furry love! 🐱🐶🐾♥️

Happy St. Patrick’s Day!! ☘️☘️☘️
03/17/2022

Happy St. Patrick’s Day!! ☘️☘️☘️

See you Saturday!!!
03/15/2022

See you Saturday!!!

March Cookie of the Month!Mint Chocolate Chip!!! Like the ice cream but in a melt in your mouth, cool mint and creamy ch...
03/09/2022

March Cookie of the Month!
Mint Chocolate Chip!!! Like the ice cream but in a melt in your mouth, cool mint and creamy chocolate cookie! #marchcookieofthemonth #columbusindiana #bakery #shopsmall #cookies

🍭🍬😍      #sugarcookies #columbusindiana #candycookies #shopsmall #birthdaycookies
03/08/2022

🍭🍬😍 #sugarcookies #columbusindiana #candycookies #shopsmall #birthdaycookies

So sorry for the inconvenience of our closure! Please don’t hesitate to fill out a form on our website, leave a message ...
02/16/2022

So sorry for the inconvenience of our closure! Please don’t hesitate to fill out a form on our website, leave a message here or at the bakery! We will return all messages starting February 23! Thank you for your understanding!

Stop by today from 10-1 and Monday 10-2 for a special Valentine’s Day treat!
02/12/2022

Stop by today from 10-1 and Monday 10-2 for a special Valentine’s Day treat!

02/12/2022
Perfect for your Valentine!! 😍🥰😘♥️#shopsmall #bakery #cookies #valentinescookies #galentinesday #columbusindiana
02/11/2022

Perfect for your Valentine!! 😍🥰😘♥️#shopsmall #bakery #cookies #valentinescookies #galentinesday #columbusindiana

A Super Bowl snack? A Valentine’s gift for your main squeeze? Either way, you or your loved one will enjoy this treat!!!...
02/09/2022

A Super Bowl snack? A Valentine’s gift for your main squeeze? Either way, you or your loved one will enjoy this treat!!! A football sugar cookie, South Bend Chocolate Company popcorn in a variety of flavors and half a dozen of our famous gourmet chocolate chip cookies!!! Stop by or call to order! #bakery #cookies #superbowl #valentinescookies #columbusindiana #shopsmall

♥️♥️♥️♥️
02/08/2022

♥️♥️♥️♥️

Stay warm and safe today!
02/04/2022

Stay warm and safe today!

Valentine’s Day dessert for one or Two! The small heart is a delicious chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream. Our g...
02/03/2022

Valentine’s Day dessert for one or Two! The small heart is a delicious chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream. Our gourmet chocolate chip cookie cake is rich, thick and ah-maz-ing!! It is meant to be shared….or not! 😍♥️💝#bakery #columbusin #columbusindiana #shopsmall #valentinescookies

February Cookie of the Month!   Strawberry Cheesecake with Royal icing! Strawberries and cream cheese make the perfect c...
02/02/2022

February Cookie of the Month! Strawberry Cheesecake with Royal icing! Strawberries and cream cheese make the perfect combo for this cut out Valentine’s cookie! #columbusindiana #bakery #valentinescookies #strawberrycookies #shopsmall

Valentine’s Day is right around the corner! Place your order soon for this super fun DIY conversation heart kit! #sugarc...
02/01/2022

Valentine’s Day is right around the corner! Place your order soon for this super fun DIY conversation heart kit! #sugarcookies #columbusindiana #valentinescookies

Look at this cute little cookie house Pam made! 😍😍😍 #cookiehouse #bakery #sugarcookies #columbusindiana #havingfun #cook...
01/28/2022

Look at this cute little cookie house Pam made! 😍😍😍 #cookiehouse #bakery #sugarcookies #columbusindiana #havingfun #cookiedecorating

This was so fun! We loved the way the cupcakes turned out! Thank you Hope for letting us be a part of your celebration! ...
01/16/2022

This was so fun! We loved the way the cupcakes turned out! Thank you Hope for letting us be a part of your celebration! 🐾🦴🐾🦴

January Cookie of the Month!!! Double Chocolate Chip 😋🍫♥️
01/07/2022

January Cookie of the Month!!!
Double Chocolate Chip 😋🍫♥️

01/07/2022
#columbusindiana #bakery #blessedandgrateful
01/01/2022

#columbusindiana #bakery #blessedandgrateful

Have a wonderful holiday and we will see you on January 7th!! Cookie Inquiry forms are still available to fill out while...
12/24/2021

Have a wonderful holiday and we will see you on January 7th!! Cookie Inquiry forms are still available to fill out while we are closed. We will be in touch soon! 🎄♥️💚♥️💚

Last minute Christmas cookies, hot chocolate bombs and gift sets available today until 4 and tomorrow 10-12! #columbusin...
12/22/2021

Last minute Christmas cookies, hot chocolate bombs and gift sets available today until 4 and tomorrow 10-12! #columbusindiana #bakery #christmas #cookies

Gingerbread DIY kit 😍
12/16/2021

Gingerbread DIY kit 😍

12/07/2021
Don’t forget…. We have a variety of stocking stuffers and teacher gifts!!! Call or stop by !! #christmascookies #chouque...
12/06/2021

Don’t forget…. We have a variety of stocking stuffers and teacher gifts!!! Call or stop by !! #christmascookies #chouquettes #shopsmall #columbusindiana #bakery

December Cookie of the Month! Ginger Molasses… dipped in white chocolate and topped with holly sprinkles! These are prob...
12/05/2021

December Cookie of the Month! Ginger Molasses… dipped in white chocolate and topped with holly sprinkles! These are probably my favorite cookie so far…so unique and delicious! Must try! #shopsmall #bakery #cookies #columbusindiana #musttrycookies

Can you believe Christmas is ONLY 3 weeks away?!?! Christmas cookie orders are ending soon! #christmascookies #bakery #s...
12/03/2021

Can you believe Christmas is ONLY 3 weeks away?!?! Christmas cookie orders are ending soon! #christmascookies #bakery #shopsmall #columbusindiana

We are open until 4 today! See you soon!
11/27/2021

We are open until 4 today! See you soon!

Today is the day! Stop by, drop your name in for this cute door prize and order your holiday cookies before we sell out!...
11/27/2021

Today is the day! Stop by, drop your name in for this cute door prize and order your holiday cookies before we sell out!!

Tomorrow is #smallbusinesssaturday !! Stop by and enter for our door prize and place your Christmas cookie order before we are booked for the season! While you are here.. stop next door and visit our friends @shabbysheepandewe for their holiday open house!!! Open 11-4! See you tomorrow!!!! #shopsmall #christmas #cookies

Tomorrow is #smallbusinesssaturday !! Stop by and enter for our door prize and place your Christmas cookie order before ...
11/27/2021

Tomorrow is #smallbusinesssaturday !! Stop by and enter for our door prize and place your Christmas cookie order before we are booked for the season! While you are here.. stop next door and visit our friends @shabbysheepandewe for their holiday open house!!! Open 11-4! See you tomorrow!!!! #shopsmall #christmas #cookies

Happy Thanksgiving!! Thankful for all of our customers that has made this year a success! We appreciate every one of you...
11/25/2021

Happy Thanksgiving!! Thankful for all of our customers that has made this year a success! We appreciate every one of you and your support! #columbusindiana #shopsmall #bakery

Address

1109 16th Street
Columbus, IN

Telephone

+18125525359

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.:

Videos

Category

Nearby bakeries


Other Bakeries in Columbus

Show All

Comments

Thank you for helping make my dogs first birthday extra special 💛
Thank you for the beautiful spring birthday cookies for my friend. Everyone kept commenting on how beautiful they were. Fortunately, they tasted great too!
Does #WFH have you down? You can get a $100 coupon from The Arc of Bartholomew County coupon book for our Wayfarer membership! This coupon book also has deals for these businesses: Boutique Elise Ames Mercantile The Savory Swine The Garden Grille & Bar Holiday Inn Express Hampton Inn Columbus/Edinburgh Viewpoint Books Clear Choice Chiropractic - Columbus Henry Chiropractic Center Blondie's Salon & Spa Posh Sloth Massage Bucceto's Pizza Pasta - Columbus Columbus Bar Henry Social Club Creative Eyes Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. Homeboyz Fried Chicken and Fish Minash Boutique Plant Financial Services LLC Columbus Rock Gym Sky Sport Fitness Jill Linn Photography Coach's Cutz kidscommons Pure Barre Sseko Designs Yes Cinema and Cafe Vivian Lou Ramen Alley Catie Rix Photography Family Chiropractic & Wellness Little Bo + Co Flavors of India Total Fitness of Columbus Flourish Columbus Dairy Queen Vasquez Photography HIT Baseball AND MORE!!! Link below #WorthIt https://www.thearcbc.org/store/p/always-ready-for-coupons-booklet
Oh my word❣️ these little gems are tasty and truly made my day - thank you!
Thanks for the amazing cookies Michael Slevin and Connie Engel Slevin! And thank you Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co. for making them! They are perfect 🍎🥼👩🏽‍⚕️🍪 Ashley Slevin Huth Amanda Slevin Daugert Michaela Slevin
These were so fun! And absolutely beautiful and delicious. Thank you for providing a bit of family fun tonight!