Sugar Bayer’s Cookie Co.

09/16/2026

🍒🍫 MIDWEEK SCOOP IS HERE! 🍫🍒

Today’s $5 treat is a BLACK FOREST SUNDAE! 🤎

Rich, fudgy brownies + cherry chocolate ice cream + chocolate syrup drizzle + whipped cream + a cherry on top. 🍒🍦

It’s basically a Black Forest cake that decided it wanted to be an ice cream sundae. 😋

🔥 ONLY $5 TODAY! 🔥
Wednesday, September 16 | 10 AM–8 PM

Don’t overthink this one.
Brownie. Cherry. Chocolate. $5.
You know what to do. 😉🍒

Come get your Midweek Scoop before this one disappears!

09/12/2026

This is so much fun!!! AND you can snag our b**r stein sugar cookies all weekend!!!

Oktoberfest Game Schedule for tomorrow! 🍻🌾🇩🇪

We will also have face painting with Erin for the kiddos from 5-7pm. Unfortunately due to a scheduling error we won’t have live music, but we’ll be playing festive music. See you tomorrow!

09/11/2026

All stocked up!! Don’t miss out on the Blackberry Sage.. it’s AMAZING!! Open today until 11-5!!! Lemonade Bros

09/09/2026

Today 11-8 only!!! September 9th 2026. Stop by and see us TODAY!!!

09/04/2026

Have a wonderful Holiday Weekend!!! See you Tuesday at 10!

09/02/2026

Enjoy our midweek scoop today!!! 10-8!!!

09/02/2026

🍂☀️ MIDWEEK SCOOP IS HERE!!! ☀️🍂

It may feel like summer outside, but we’re bringing a little fall to your cup! 🎃🍦

🔥 OPEN 10–8 TODAY! 🔥

🥤 $5 DIRTY SODA FLOAT
Vanilla ice cream + Dr Pepper + our dreamy brown-butter pumpkin cold foam on top! 🤤🎃

It’s basically a little “brrr” for these hot “ber” months! 😂🍂
Enjoy all the cozy fall flavors with a cold, fizzy twist! 🥤🍦

🍨 $6 FOUR-SCOOP ICE CREAM FLIGHTS!
Four flavors = four chances to find your new favorite! 😍

🔥 It’s fall… but it’s still hot!
🍂 Come cool down with a little taste of autumn!

FLOAT SPECIAL IS AVAILABLE WHILE SUPPLIES LAST — DON’T MISS OUT! 👀

📍 Stop in, grab your scoop, and let’s pretend it actually feels like fall outside! 😂🍁

ColumbusIndiana SugarBayersCookieCo

08/29/2026

THE RESULTS ARE IN!!! 🏆

🥁🥁🥁 CONGRATULATIONS, COLUMBUS EAST OLYMPIANS!!! 🧡🤎

You guys showed up BIG and proved you have some SERIOUS school spirit! 🙌 You bought A LOT of cookies, cast your votes, and officially took home the title of 🏆 MOST SPIRITED SCHOOL! 🏆

And because you showed up in such a BIG way… a portion of the cookie proceeds is headed to the Columbus East football program! 🎉🍪🏈

Now, we know last night’s game didn’t end the way the Olympians wanted, BUT one thing is absolutely undeniable… the support from your community was LOUD! 🧡🤎

And to our COLUMBUS NORTH BULLDOGS… 🐾💙🤍

CONGRATULATIONS ON THE RIVALRY WIN!!! 🏈🔥
What a game! You played an amazing one and earned that victory!

This rivalry brought out the BEST school spirit, and we loved every second of it! From the cookies to the cheers to the friendly competition, our community showed up in a BIG way. ❤️

North gets the WIN on the field…
East gets the WIN for MOST SPIRITED! 🏆

Thank you to EVERYONE who bought a cookie, cast a vote, supported their school, and helped make Rivalry Week so much fun!

Until next time… GO NORTH! 🐾💙🤍
GO EAST! 🧡🤎

🍪🏈 RIVALRY WEEK 2026 — THAT’S A WRAP! 🏈 Special thanks to Columbus East Football QB Club and CEHS cheer team for your orders! We were so happy to be a part of your team spirit!

08/27/2026

It’s Almost GAME DAY !!! Our voting ends Friday at 4! Stop by Today from 2-4 and tomorrow 11-4 for a cookie or float to cast your vote!!!!! 🧡🤎💙🤍 GO TEAM!!!