Ahlemeyer Bakery

Ahlemeyer Bakery We are a small family bakery that has been in Columbus over 35 years! Ahlemeyer Bakery is a family owned and operated bakery in Columbus, Indiana.
(4)

We sell a variety of pies, cookies, brownies, sweet rolls, breads and other baked goods. We even carry the Indiana state pie- Sugar Cream! Our goal is quality, baking fresh products every day. Because of this we can run out quickly, so please feel free to call and place an order if there is something specific you are looking for. Our number is 812-372-7437. Great for holidays, birthdays, special gatherings, or for no occasion at all!

05/26/2026

Thank you to EVERYONE who made Memorial Day weekend great at the bakery!!

Due to the holiday, we will remain closed today so we can recoup and will reopen tomorrow at noon

See everyone then!!

Happy Memorial Day Saturday!!!We are OPEN and stocked with all our traditional items AND specials for the holiday!Waterm...
05/23/2026

Happy Memorial Day Saturday!!!

We are OPEN and stocked with all our traditional items AND specials for the holiday!

Watermelon Key Lime
Key Lime
Fresh Strawberry
Assorted Cupcakes

Open until 2pm!

Cupcakes everywhere!!!Special today is good old fashioned cupcakes! Each box is different…..chocolate, butter cake, funf...
05/22/2026

Cupcakes everywhere!!!

Special today is good old fashioned cupcakes! Each box is different…..chocolate, butter cake, funfetti cakes with a mix of chocolate and traditional frosting and sprinkles!!

Everyone loves a cupcake!! Come and see us for all your Memorial Day needs!!

$7/3 cupcakes

HAPPY FRIDAY!!Memorial Day is this weekend and we hope everyone is excited to (maybe) have a day off work!! Enjoy that d...
05/22/2026

HAPPY FRIDAY!!

Memorial Day is this weekend and we hope everyone is excited to (maybe) have a day off work!! Enjoy that day with baked goodies from Ahlemeyer!!

Our feature pie this weekend is Watermelon Key Lime!! We also have fresh Strawberry Pies…..check out how red the goo turned out this batch because the berries are so red!!

We will be having a cake special in about an hour so keep an eye out!

Tomorrow is THE DAY to come see us at the bakery!!The weather is shaping up to be 🤞nice-ish on Monday for Memorial Day s...
05/22/2026

Tomorrow is THE DAY to come see us at the bakery!!

The weather is shaping up to be 🤞nice-ish on Monday for Memorial Day so come stock up for your gatherings!!

Memorial Day special pie is Watermelon Key Lime!!
Zingy lime, sweet watermelon, and creamy fresh whipped cream in our yummy graham cracker crust

We will have these as whole pies AND slices this weekend in addition to traditional key lime, payday pie, and fresh strawberry pies!

Friday hours 10am-6pm
Saturday hours 10am-2pm

Happy Wednesday!!We have some AWESOME slice options this week!Sugar CreamWatermelon Key LimeFresh StrawberryStrawberry R...
05/20/2026

Happy Wednesday!!

We have some AWESOME slice options this week!
Sugar Cream
Watermelon Key Lime
Fresh Strawberry
Strawberry Rhubarb

We also have the following as whole pies in store or by order!!
Payday Pie
Watermelon Key Lime
Fresh Strawberry

We also have cinnamon rolls with traditional white icing! Pan of 9 rolls $15

Rain or shine, the bakery is OPEN on Saturdays! We have limited stock of all of our FRESHLY BAKED goodies!! Pies, browni...
05/16/2026

Rain or shine, the bakery is OPEN on Saturdays!

We have limited stock of all of our FRESHLY BAKED goodies!! Pies, brownies, cookies…..oh my!!

Come and see us until 2pm or sellout!
*We still have our Three Musketeers cake and Payday Pie available!

It’s Candy Bar Day at the bakery!!!!!!Our Gooey Mini this week is Three Musketeers!! Decadent chocolate cake filled with...
05/15/2026

It’s Candy Bar Day at the bakery!!!!!!

Our Gooey Mini this week is Three Musketeers!! Decadent chocolate cake filled with homemade chocolate nougat and topped with chocolate ganache

Our pie feature is PayDay Pie!
Our traditional crust filled with homemade peanut nougat and topped with roasted peanuts and milk caramel

We also have Fresh Strawberry Pies topped with mounds of fresh French vanilla whipped cream!!

Open all day until 6pm and tomorrow 10am-2pm

05/15/2026

We are OPEN even though our sign is inside, we will stick it out when the rain stops!

Happy National Apple Pie Day!!We've got Apple! We've got Apple Crumb!We've got slices of Apple Crumb *and* slices of App...
05/13/2026

Happy National Apple Pie Day!!

We've got Apple! We've got Apple Crumb!

We've got slices of Apple Crumb *and* slices of Apple Raspberry Crumb!

See ya soon!! ❤️🍏🥧

Update on our FRESH STRAWBERRY PIESNow that we are carrying these, we wanted to give an update as to their availability ...
05/12/2026

Update on our FRESH STRAWBERRY PIES

Now that we are carrying these, we wanted to give an update as to their availability in store.

Due to the nature of this pie (fresh berries), we will NOT be holding this pie in store any day except Fridays. They are available BY ORDER any day of the week!

TLDR: Fresh strawberry pies available by order any time but only Friday in store

Address

2034 17th Street
Columbus, IN
47201

Opening Hours

Tuesday 2pm - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Telephone

+18123727437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Ahlemeyer Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category