Sweet Magic Bakery

Home
United States
Tallahassee, FL
Sweet Magic Bakery

A cottage bakery specializing in custom decorated sugar cookies & other baked goods. A cottage licensed bakery serving the "Big Bend" area of Florida.

Serving Tallahassee, Panama City and the surrounding areas of North Florida.

04/01/2026

Sweet Magic Bakery is officially closed as of 3/31/26.
Thank you for three wonderful years!

03/31/2026

Happy Birthday Sophia & Taylor! We were so happy to make this vintage style cake to help you celebrate!

This is our last creation as a business so it’s bittersweet to make this post. Thank you to everyone who supported us through the years! Wishing you all the sweet magic of life! ✨

PS-Sabrina will continue her hobby baking and revive her page if you want to follow along. 🥰

03/22/2026

Bright flowers and butterflies for one of the last orders we will create as a business. Happy “Fifty-ish” Birthday Lorena!

03/03/2026

✨✨ BIG NEWS ✨✨

Please take a moment to read and drop a line below if you have any fun memories with us over the last three years! We are fighting back some tears and could use the ❤️.

02/13/2026

For those who follow us and have noticed our recent closure, our volunteer baker and decorator, Sabrina, has been facing significant medical challenges. Baking/decorating has always been a creative outlet for her throughout her battle with lupus and other health conditions. She is incredibly strong and resilient, but the past month has been especially difficult.

Sabrina has set up a GoFundMe page (linked in comments below) to help cover expenses during her recovery from two back-to-back surgeries. Any donation, big or small, would mean so much. If you’re unable to donate, sharing the page or sending kind thoughts and well-wishes is equally appreciated and we’ll be sure to pass them along.

Sweet Magic Bakery will be back to its usual magic as soon as Sabrina is able, and we thank you for your support and understanding during this time.

02/09/2026

Update: Due to unforeseen circumstances, Sweet Magic Bakery will remain closed through February 15. We appreciate your patience and understanding during this time and will respond to messages and inquiries once we reopen. Thank you so much for your continued support

02/05/2026

We will be closed from Feb. 5-10. This will not impact any existing orders or workshops scheduled for next week. We will reply to custom order inquiries upon reopening.

02/03/2026

Celebrating Yanelli’s nursing school graduation and all the hard work that led her to this moment. Her family is so proud of this incredible accomplishment, and we were honored to help her celebrate with this sweet custom cookie set.

02/02/2026

This Lord of the Rings-inspired baby shower set celebrates baby Asher as he makes his journey into “The Shire”. Congratulations to Caprice and Leland as they begin this great adventure!

02/01/2026

From dragons and rainbows to castles and crowns, this cookie set is filled with sweet magic! Happy 5th birthday Dean!

Address

Tallahassee, FL
32301

Website

https://www.sweetmagicbakeryfl.com/, https://www.etsy.com/shop/SweetMagicBakery

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sweet Magic Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sweet Magic Bakery:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Tallahassee?