Moore's Pie Shop

05/22/2026

We will be open Saturday at the shop from 10 - 2 pm. If you need FULL size 10" pies, please stop by our shop at 115 W Elm St. (you can order ahead of time online at MooresPies.com). We will have a large selection of our personal 6 inch pies at the Kokomo Farmers Market from 9 - Noon and the Carmel Farmers Markets from 8 - 11:30 am. Fresh Strawberry and Key Lime pies are back on the menu! Stop by and see us for some delicious treats for your holiday weekend cook outs 🥰🥧🤤

05/20/2026

Key Lime Pie is back! Order yours ahead of time online at MooresPies.com or stop by the shop.

Today, we will also be at the West Lafayette Farmers Market from 3:30 pm to 7:00 pm with an array of small pie flavors along with our in house made NY cheesecake slices with strawberry or cherry topping. We look forward to seeing everyone there!

05/09/2026

Do we have an imposter among us? 👀

Make no mistake: Cheesecake is considered a pie!

That’s right! And you can get a slice of this decadent dessert for Mom at 3 separate locations today for $8/slice 🤩

Carmel Farmers Markets 8am - 11:30am
Kokomo Farmers Market 9am - 12pm
And the Pie Shop 10am - 2pm

05/07/2026

Mother's Day is this Sunday! Stop by the shop to gather some goodies for your weekend plans 🥰 We have Fresh Strawberry Pie, Key Lime Pie, and scratch made Cheesecake Slices available in addition to our regular menu. This Saturday, we will be at the Carmel Farmers Markets from 8 - 11:30 am, the Kokomo Farmers Market from 9 - noon, and at the Shop from 10 - 2 pm (guarantee your pie by ordering ahead online at MooresPies.com and picking up at the shop). We look forward to seeing everyone tomorrow and Saturday 😍

05/06/2026

Our new farmers market menu will be as follows.

Sweet Pies:
Apple, Apple Crumble, Cherry, Cherry Crumble, Blueberry, Blackberry, Peach, Strawberry, Strawberry Rhubarb, Chocolate Creme, Peanut Butter Creme, Chocolate Butter Creme, Coconut Creme, Banana Creme, Lemon Meringue, Sugar Cream, and Pecan.

Take and Bake Pies:
Chicken Pot Pie, Cottage Pie, Philly Cheesesteak Pot Pie, Cheesy Chicken & Broccoli Pot Pie.

New Special!
Cheesecake by the slice with your choice of topping: Caramel Drizzle, Cherry Pie Filling, Strawberry Pie Filling.

We look forward to this market season!

05/06/2026

We will be at the West Lafayette Farmers Market today from 3:30 - 7 pm. We will be bringing small pies, take and bake savory pies, and debuting our new Cheesecake slices with your choice of topping: Caramel, Cherry Pie filling, or Strawberry Pie filling. Stop by for some great sweet or savory options!

05/01/2026

Looking forward to seeing everyone again this year!

The 2026 Summer Market begins THIS SATURDAY, MAY 2nd and we're bringing 84 vendors to Carter Green this year!

We hope you'll join us every Saturday from 8:00 AM - 11:30 AM through the end of September! 🍓🥯🥦

Visit our website for a full vendor list, market map, and parking details, and stay tuned to the social profiles for market updates!

https://www.carmelfarmersmarket.com/sm-home

We can't wait to see you! ☀️

05/01/2026

We will be closed for a brief period today from 11:30 am - 1 pm in order to attend an event. Tomorrow morning, you can catch us at the Kokomo Farmers Market from 9 am - Noon and the Carmel Farmers Markets from 8 - 11:30 am. We will have a large selection of our small 6 inch pies (both sweet pies and savory take and bakes). We will also be serving Ham & Cheese and Spinach & Feta Quiche by the slice! See everyone there 😄

Send a message to learn more

04/24/2026

04/21/2026

We thought everyone should know Boston Creme Pie is a cake, NOT a pie. Cheesecake is a pie, NOT a cake. Remember this. It may show up in trivia or something.

04/18/2026

We have 2 10” and 2 6” Fresh Strawberry Pies left for Saturday 🍓 Come pick one up before they are bought up! We are open until 3pm