Sweets by Sarah Smith, LLC

10/04/2026

First Florida cookie set is officially in the books! 💙🧡🍪 These Sharkdog cookies were such a fun way to celebrate Jax turning ONE!

Sweets by Sarah is baking here in Sanford, and I’d love to create something sweet for your next celebration! 🥳 Birthdays, baby showers, weddings, graduations, holidays—or just because you want a delicious cookie!

Who has an upcoming event that could use custom cookies? 🙋‍♀️ Message me with your date, theme, and quantity, and let’s bring your ideas to life!

A share or tag means so much as I grow my cookie business here in Central Florida! 🫶

09/29/2026

09/27/2026

🎃 Halloween cookie preorders are LIVE! 👻

I’m so excited to share this year’s treats from Sweets by Sarah! Choose from a personalized ghost cookie, a build-your-own skeleton cookie set, or a sweet little pack of three mini ghosts. The photos show each option! 🍪

These would be so fun for Halloween baskets, classroom surprises, or a little treat for yourself. To see the details and place your preorder, fill out the form here:

👉 https://forms.gle/AghYR33FxpgkHFn19

Which one is your favorite? I’m a little obsessed with the skeleton! 💀🧡

08/25/2026

🍪✨ THE COOKIES ARE COMING BACK! ✨🍪

Something sweet is coming to Orlando… 👀💕

After a little break and a big move from Ohio to Florida, Sweets by Sarah is officially making a comeback!

I’m so excited to start taking custom cookie orders again and introduce my cookies to my new Central Florida neighbors! 🥰

📅 Orders open September 1!

02/22/2026

A fun cookie set from this week!

🕷️🧔🏽‍♂️

Starting to take cookie orders again - if you are needing cookies for a special event, birthdays, or just to eat I’m happy to help!

Shoot me a message!

02/05/2026

01/24/2026

Don’t forget to order your cookies!! 😃

01/02/2026

Bringing back the cookie orders for 2026!!

I have some availability for January - March currently ... will be offering Valentine's Day options as well.

Also, graduation season will be quickly approaching - if you are needing cookies for parties, please feel free to contact me now to start planning.

I am also offering the HUGE gourmet cookies - they are about 4.5 ounces each!! Flavors include …
1. Cookie Butter - made with Biscoff cookies, cookie butter, and white chocolate chips.
2. Cookies n Cream - made with chocolate chips, crushed Oreos, cookies n cream candy bar pieces, and stuffed with an Oreo.
3. Dad Bod - chocolate chips, mini M&Ms, and stuffed with Nutella.
4. Banana Pudding - banana pudding flavored dough with white chocolate chips, crushed Nilla waffers - stuffed with marshmallow fluff and a waffer. Topped with white chocolate and crushed waffers.
5. Strawberry Shortcake - strawberry flavored base with white chocolate chips and crushed golden Oreos. Stuffed with a golden Oreo and topped with strawberry crunch topping.
6. S’mores - chocolate bar pieces, chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, crushed graham crackers. Stuffed with marshmallow fluff, graham cracker, and chocolate bar piece.

Please complete google form for orders:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/18t6YeFY4-p3BPww-aCVxIesKLLvMNWP6okdwQ5hyoNk/preview

11/12/2025

✨ Thanksgiving & Holiday Treats Are Here! ✨🎄

I’m excited to announce that I’ll be offering customizable pumpkin pie slices for Thanksgiving! 🥧 Each slice is $4 and comes beautifully packaged—perfect for gifts, dinner tables, or sweet little thank-yous.

👉 I’ll be posting the Google Form tomorrow for preorders, so stay tuned!

Plus… the holiday fun doesn’t stop there!
🎅 Personalized Elf cookies are making a comeback,
👩‍🏫 along with teacher gift options and
🍪 DIY cookie kits for the kiddos (or kids at heart)!

And yes—if you’re looking for custom Christmas cookie orders, I’ll be taking those too! ❤️

Keep an eye out tomorrow for the order form and get your holiday treats reserved early!

09/20/2025

I have been MIA with life, career, kids, all the things!

buuut …

Thinking of doing Halloween cookies this year 👻💀 who would be interested?

I’m thinking of the skeletons (planning to put them in the coffin boxes - second picture 😍), personalized ghost, some sort of Hocus Pocus (either these cups or the sister’s heads), a Halloween DIY kit, and the mini boos!

Let me know if you or someone maybe interested! Pick up would be week of Halloween 🎃