The Cookie Hustler

The Cookie Hustler Artisanal Cookies & Treats
Licensed Cottage Food Bakery
GA Shipping available Visit The Cookie Hustler for a delicious treat. Get your fix today!

Welcome to The Cookie Hustler, where we craft massive, decadent NYC-style cookies, along with our signature cake jars, and irresistible cookie bars. Our claim to fame is our colossal, New York-inspired cookies—crispy on the outside, thick, gooey, and loaded with chunks of chocolate and fillings on the inside. Every cookie is a substantial, satisfying experience designed to make you feel like you j

ust stepped into a Manhattan bakery. If you're looking for a layered treat, our cake jars are perfect for a portable indulgence, combining moist cake and rich frosting in a reusable jar. For those who prefer cookie layers, our hearty cookie bars pack pure comfort into every thick slice. Available for local pickup, markets, events or in-state delivery.

Dear Mother Nature,Respectfully, this is not what we ordered.Tomorrow's forecast for Market at the Mill is showing thund...
06/17/2026

Dear Mother Nature,

Respectfully, this is not what we ordered.

Tomorrow's forecast for Market at the Mill is showing thunderstorms most of the day, so we're watching the weather closely and waiting for updates from market organizers.

We'll let everyone know as soon as a decision is made. Until then, I'll be over here refreshing the radar like it's my full-time job.

Please keep your fingers crossed for cookies instead of thunderstorms. 🍪⚡

This week's 'BOOKIE COOKIE' comes from The Cookie Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum.  Every baker has that one cookbook.Mine ...
06/15/2026

This week's 'BOOKIE COOKIE' comes from The Cookie Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum.

Every baker has that one cookbook.

Mine is The Cookie Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum, and I've had it for so long that the pages are worn, splattered, and filled with memories. Truth be told, I "borrowed" it from my mom years ago and somehow never managed to return it. At this point, I think the statute of limitations has expired. 😆

When I first started baking, this book taught me so much. Not just recipes, but the fundamentals. Why ingredients matter. Why technique matters. Why sometimes the difference between good and amazing is just a few extra minutes of patience. Rose is a literal genius.

This week's 'Chocolate Peanut Butter Sammie' comes straight from those well-loved pages. Rich chocolate cookies sandwiched around a creamy peanut butter filling and drizzled in chocolate. This is one of those recipes that's been part of my baking journey for years.

Funny how a beat-up old cookbook can teach you skills that stay with you for a lifetime.

*********

You'll find these and other delights at the Downtown Villa Rica Market at the Mill, Thursday from 4-7p.

🚨 MARKET AT THE MILL MENU DROP 🚨Thursday is coming! YES there is sugar involved.  Here's what I'll have at Market at the...
06/15/2026

🚨 MARKET AT THE MILL MENU DROP 🚨

Thursday is coming! YES there is sugar involved.

Here's what I'll have at Market at the Mill this week:

🍪 **Browned Butter Chocolate Chip**
Rich browned butter cookie dough loaded with chocolate chips. Simple, classic, and the cookie that reminds everyone why chocolate chip became famous in the first place.

🍌 **Banana Pudding**
Soft vanilla cookie packed with banana flavor, vanilla wafers, and all the nostalgic goodness of your favorite Southern dessert.

🤍 **White Chocolate Macadamia**
Buttery brown sugar cookie loaded with creamy white chocolate and crunchy toasted macadamia nuts. Fancy enough to feel grown-up, delicious enough to make you forget your responsibilities.

🔥 **Raspberry Crème Brûlée**
Sweet raspberry flavor paired with creamy vanilla notes and a caramelized sugar topping. This one's a little extra. We support that, and you will too!

🍫 **Cosmic Brownie**
A thick, brownie-like chocolate cookie topped with silky chocolate ganache and sprinkled with colorful candy-coated chips. Rich, fudgy, nostalgic, and guaranteed to bring back lunchbox memories.

🍋 **Lemon White Chocolate Bliss**
A thick, soft lemon cookie packed with fresh lemon zest, lemon juice, white chocolate and topped with a confectioner's drizzle. Sweet, bright, and refreshing, it's like summer decided to become a cookie.

❄️ **Snowdrift (DQ Inspired)**
A dreamy cookies-and-cream creation inspired by a certain frozen treat we all know and love. Cool, creamy vibes without the brain freeze.

🌽 **Cornbread Minis with Honey Buttercream Dip**
Adorably sweet cornbread mini bites served with a creamy honey buttercream dip. Southern comfort in snack form.

🥣 **Biscoff Cereal Crunch (Puppy Chow)**
Crunchy cereal coated in Biscoff goodness and powdered sugar. Highly addictive. Consider yourself warned.

🔥 **Mini of the week - S'mores Cookies**
Tiny graham cracker cookies loaded with chocolate and marshmallow goodness. Buy your container once and bring it back for discounted refills. Because saving money and eating cookies is the kind of math we like around here.

💌 **Bookie Cookie of the week**
Chocolate Peanut Butter Sammies from The Cookie Bible
Soft chocolate cookies sandwiching a creamy peanut butter filling and drizzled in chocolate. The ultimate power move.

🌈 **Rainbow Krispie Treats**
Friends, you know you love them. My back-up singer, Charlotte, makes them and she is ON POINT. Colorful, chewy, marshmallow-packed treats that make both kids and adults suspiciously happy.

🌰 **Gluten-Sensitive Almond Thumbprints**
Buttery almond cookies filled with sweet strawberry preserves. A delicious option for those avoiding gluten ingredients. (NOT Gluten Free. We are jam-packed with gluten in this place. These are sanitized equipment. Still, no guarantee!)

⏰ Market at the Mill
Come early for the best selection because cookies have a habit of disappearing. Almost like people enjoy them or something. We'll be here on Thursday in Downtown Villa Rica from 4pm until 7pm.

🤡As always, quantities are limited. FOMO is real 🥸

Someone called me 'Cookie Queen' yesterday.  I prefer "Princess of the Cookie Realm" 👑🍪It's an entirely reasonable title...
06/12/2026

Someone called me 'Cookie Queen' yesterday. I prefer
"Princess of the Cookie Realm" 👑🍪

It's an entirely reasonable title. Some people inherit kingdoms. Some conquer them. Some build an empire out of butter, sugar, and the collective inability of humans to walk past a good cookie without convincing themselves it's "for later."

From this day forth, I'll address myself as Princess of the Cookie Realm when it fits the conversation. It certainly has more flair than "head baker" and considerably more authority than most actual monarchs.

Long may my cookie pies be gooey, my markets be crowded and my inventory sell out before the weather decides to become personally offensive, because certain people (and you know who you are City of Villa Rica) absolutely know that I panic if there's rain in the forecast. 🤣

06/05/2026

Thank you everyone for coming out to the VR Market at the Mill yesterday!

We had a great time...I hope you did too!

06/03/2026
This week's cookbook-inspired treat comes from one of my favorite books, Whiskey in a Teacup by Reese Witherspoon. 🤎Insp...
06/03/2026

This week's cookbook-inspired treat comes from one of my favorite books, Whiskey in a Teacup by Reese Witherspoon. 🤎

Inspired by Reese's love of Southern comfort desserts, I created a Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie Trifle that's layered with everything a proper dessert should have: rich chocolate, creamy peanut butter, peanut butter cups and absolutely no regrets.

Layer after layer of fudgy brownies, silky peanut butter filling, chocolate goodness, and buttercream come together in a dessert that's equal parts comforting and indulgent.

It's the kind of dessert you'd deem appropriate bring to a family gathering and then secretly hope nobody notices when you sneak back for seconds.

Available this week in limited quantity at the Market at the Mill in downtown Villa Rica on Thursday from 4-7PM.

There are Biscoff desserts... and then there are Biscoff experiences. 🤎🍪Our Biscoff Mini Cookie Cake starts with a thick...
06/03/2026

There are Biscoff desserts... and then there are Biscoff experiences. 🤎🍪

Our Biscoff Mini Cookie Cake starts with a thick, buttery cookie cake stuffed with creamy Biscoff spread. Then we swirl on tiny clouds of Biscoff buttercream, drizzle it with even more cookie butter goodness, and crown the whole thing with a Biscoff cookie because moderation was never invited to this party.

Sweet, spiced, caramelized, and completely over-the-top in the best possible way.

If your grocery cart mysteriously finds its way to the Biscoff aisle every single time, this one was made with you in mind.

The Cookie Hustler: proudly enabling cookie-related poor decisions since day one. 🤎

These are available in limited quantity at the Market at the Mill in downtown VR on Thursday from 4-7. Be there or be square.

Meet the Cookie Dough Cookie. 🍪✨We start with a rich brown butter chocolate chip cookie base, then pile it high with flu...
06/03/2026

Meet the Cookie Dough Cookie. 🍪✨

We start with a rich brown butter chocolate chip cookie base, then pile it high with fluffy cookie dough buttercream. Because stopping there would have shown entirely too much restraint.

Each cookie is finished with chunks of our shop-made edible cookie dough and a sprinkle of mini chocolate chips for the perfect bite every time.

Soft, buttery, loaded with chocolate, and unapologetically over the top.

If cookie dough is your weakness, consider this your warning. 💛

Find this and more at the Market at the Mill in downtown Villa Rica on Thursday from 4-7PM.

Caramel Cornflake Brownie.  Yep.  It's a brownie with cornflakes on top.  Sounds weird but....is it really?If a fudgy br...
06/02/2026

Caramel Cornflake Brownie. Yep. It's a brownie with cornflakes on top. Sounds weird but....is it really?

If a fudgy brownie and your favorite childhood cereal had a delicious little rebellion, this would be the result.

Rich, chocolatey brownies topped with a buttery, crunchy cornflake layer that brings the perfect sweet-and-salty bite. Soft, chewy, crispy, gooey... basically all the textures showed up to the party.

These are the kind of treats that make you cut "just a small piece" and somehow end up coming back three more times. Science has yet to explain it.

Limited quantities this week at The Cookie Hustler, because self-control is hard enough without a whole pan sitting around.

📍 Find them at Market at the Mill, Thursday 4-7
🍫 Grab one before the other brownie lovers beat you to it

Address

Villa Rica, GA

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Hustler posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cookie Hustler:

Share

Category