The Eccentric Bagel

Call Directions Website

The Eccentric Bagel First Ever Bagel Shop on Shelter Island
🥯Artisan bagels, made from scratch daily!
Catering available

🥯 NO BAGELS?! DON’T PANIC! 😎✈️Darryn’s making his way back from vacation, and we’re going BAGELESS until Thursday, Octob...
10/16/2026

🥯 NO BAGELS?! DON’T PANIC! 😎✈️
Darryn’s making his way back from vacation, and we’re going BAGELESS until Thursday, October 22nd! 🌴☀️
But don’t break up with us just yet! 💕
We’ve still got all your Eccentric favorites served on wraps, rolls, bread, croissants, and gluten-free bagels! 🥐🥪
Same delicious sandwiches. Same Eccentric attitude. Just a little less round for a few days! 😂
Bagels are taking a break. We aren’t! 💗

🥯🚫 IT’S OFFICIALLY BAGELLESS TIME!Our Bagel Man is going into hibernation! 😴 Darryn’s taking a little break, and apparen...
10/09/2026

🥯🚫 IT’S OFFICIALLY BAGELLESS TIME!

Our Bagel Man is going into hibernation! 😴 Darryn’s taking a little break, and apparently the bagels refuse to work without him.

📅 TUESDAY, OCTOBER 13
Bagels are taking a break, but WE’RE STILL OPEN! 🙌

All your favorite sandwiches will still be available on fresh rolls, breads, wraps, and buttery croissants. 🥐

📅 THURSDAY, OCTOBER 22
🥯 DARRYN & THE BAGELS ARE BACK! 🎉

Until then, come hungry. We’ve still got plenty of deliciousness waiting for you!

📸 Special thanks to Smadar Lieberman Meer for this hilarious photo of Darryn!

📍 The Eccentric Bagel | Shelter Island

NorthFork BreakfastSandwich SupportLocal

10/04/2026

We were told to make more dough. Apparently there was some confusion. 🎤🥯

So we decided to get into the music biz. What do you think… should we stick to bagels? 😂

10/01/2026

Big news, New York! 💛💙

Starting October 9, Eccentric Bagel Chips will be on the shelves at Pop Up Grocer, 205 Bleecker Street in the West Village.

Pop Up Grocer is where New York goes to discover new brands, so being picked for their shelves is a big deal for us. You'll find three of our flavors there: Everything, Garlic Herb Obsession and Cinnamon Raisin Brown Sugar Crunch.

Real bagels, baked not fried, and no seed oils.

Read the full story here 👉 eccentricbagelchips.com/blogs/news/eccentric-bagel-chips-pop-up-grocer-nyc

Stop by, grab a bag, and tag us when you spot us! 🥯

Pop Up Grocer

Summer may be winding down, but the bagels aren’t going anywhere. 🥯Our new season hours are here:Closed Monday
Tuesday–F...
09/08/2026

Summer may be winding down, but the bagels aren’t going anywhere. 🥯
Our new season hours are here:
Closed Monday
Tuesday–Friday: 7–2
Saturday: 8–2
Sunday: 8–1
See you on Shelter Island! 🧡

08/22/2026

THE CRUNCH HAS ITS OWN ADDRESS. 💥

The new Eccentric Bagel Chips website is live.

Five flavors. Real artisan bagels. Baked, never fried. No seed oils. Shipped nationwide.

Come see the new home:
eccentricbagelchips.com

ECCENTRIC DOES A BODY GOOD. 🥯
08/22/2026

ECCENTRIC DOES A BODY GOOD. 🥯

Shelter Island, consider this your sign. 🥯✨Come hungry. Leave eccentric.
08/14/2026

Shelter Island, consider this your sign. 🥯✨
Come hungry. Leave eccentric.

Address

25 W Neck Road #1
Shelter Island, NY
11964

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 2pm
Tuesday 7am - 2pm
Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 3pm
Saturday 7am - 3pm
Sunday 7am - 2pm

Telephone

+16317495363

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Eccentric Bagel posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category

Nearby bakeries