The Eccentric Bagel

The Eccentric Bagel First Ever Bagel Shop on Shelter Island
🥯Artisan bagels, made from scratch daily! Catering available

08/22/2026

THE CRUNCH HAS ITS OWN ADDRESS. 💥

The new Eccentric Bagel Chips website is live.

Five flavors. Real artisan bagels. Baked, never fried. No seed oils. Shipped nationwide.

Come see the new home:
eccentricbagelchips.com

ECCENTRIC DOES A BODY GOOD. 🥯
08/22/2026

ECCENTRIC DOES A BODY GOOD. 🥯

Shelter Island, consider this your sign. 🥯✨Come hungry. Leave eccentric.
08/14/2026

Shelter Island, consider this your sign. 🥯✨
Come hungry. Leave eccentric.

We made The Upper Crust. 🥯✨So excited to be featured in the latest issue of Modern Luxury Hamptons.A few lines we especi...
08/12/2026

We made The Upper Crust. 🥯✨
So excited to be featured in the latest issue of Modern Luxury Hamptons.
A few lines we especially loved:
“Shelter Island’s bagel game got a serious upgrade with Eccentric Bagel.”
“Equal parts neighborhood hangout and destination-worthy breakfast stop...”
And maybe our favorite:
“It’s the kind of place you’ll find yourself detouring for all summer long.”
Thank you Modern Luxury Hamptons and Rachel Feinblatt for the incredible feature. 🤍
Come make the detour.

A little Sunday press love. 🥯The Eccentric Bagel was featured in High Kick’s Shelter Island guide, with a shoutout to ou...
08/09/2026

A little Sunday press love. 🥯

The Eccentric Bagel was featured in High Kick’s Shelter Island guide, with a shoutout to our artisan bagels, loaded breakfast sandwiches and Eccentric Bagel Chips.

And we definitely liked this description:

“Shelter Island’s dedicated artisan bagel destination.”

Come see us at 25 West Neck Road. ❤️

For anyone who hasn’t met us yet, hi, we’re Amy and Darryn, the husband-and-wife team behind The Eccentric Bagel. One of...
08/03/2026

For anyone who hasn’t met us yet, hi, we’re Amy and Darryn, the husband-and-wife team behind The Eccentric Bagel. One of us makes the bagels. The other keeps the chaos under control. And in case you were wondering where the “eccentric” part comes from, this photo should explain it. 😂🥯

07/23/2026

That face says it all. 🥯🤍

Our little nephew took one bite of an Eccentric Bagel, and the cream cheese chaos began.

IYKYK Limited edition, available in store only.
07/15/2026

IYKYK

Limited edition, available in store only.





We knew people loved our bagels. We just didn’t expect this. 🦌🥯We looked outside and found this unexpected visitor enjoy...
07/15/2026

We knew people loved our bagels. We just didn’t expect this. 🦌🥯

We looked outside and found this unexpected visitor enjoying one of our bagels.

No wildlife was fed. This little guy found his own breakfast.

07/05/2026

Even our bags know how to ride the waves. 🌊🏄🥯

Address

25 W Neck Road #1
Shelter Island, NY
11964

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 2pm
Tuesday 7am - 2pm
Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 3pm
Saturday 7am - 3pm
Sunday 7am - 2pm

Telephone

+16317495363

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Eccentric Bagel posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category