Bakeries in Shelter Island, NY

Home
United States
Shelter Island

Town in Suffolk County, New York

Browse bakeries, bagel shops, cupcakes, donuts and crêperies in Shelter Island.

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Shelter Island, NY?

Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

The Eccentric Bagel

A

The Eccentric Bagel

25 W Neck Road #1, Shelter Island 11964

Bagel Shop

Call Directions

B

Kyle's

27 N Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Directions

My Friend Jacki's Cupcakes

C

My Friend Jacki's Cupcakes

Shelter Island 11964

Call Directions

Kyle's Eatery & Emporium

D

Kyle's Eatery & Emporium

27 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Call Directions

Bakeries and bagels

Show all categories

Nearby bakeries