Dorothy’s Baking Company

Call Directions Website

Dorothy’s Baking Company To place an order, please email [email protected] or call 631-488-7332.

It’s pie season! 🥧🥧🥧Pictured here: apple crumb, mixed berry crumb, maple pecan and pumpkin. Get yours at Cromer’s all we...
11/13/2026

It’s pie season! 🥧🥧🥧

Pictured here: apple crumb, mixed berry crumb, maple pecan and pumpkin. Get yours at Cromer’s all weekend.

The newest addition to the lineup - Peanut Butter Pie! 🥜🥜🥜Peanut butter cookie crust, peanut butter mousse, whipped crea...
11/05/2026

The newest addition to the lineup - Peanut Butter Pie! 🥜🥜🥜
Peanut butter cookie crust, peanut butter mousse, whipped cream and roasted peanuts.

Find it at Cromer’s today and this weekend, along with on the Thanksgiving menu!

For Lisa & Jay 🤍💍 Confetti cake, strawberry jam, vanilla buttercream. Heart-shaped cake - gluten-free and dairy-free cho...
11/01/2026

For Lisa & Jay 🤍💍

Confetti cake, strawberry jam, vanilla buttercream.

Heart-shaped cake - gluten-free and dairy-free chocolate cake with dairy-free vanilla frosting.

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! 🎃💀👁️🍁 Lots to choose from at Cromer’s today!
10/31/2026

HAPPY HALLOWEEN! 🎃💀👁️🍁 Lots to choose from at Cromer’s today!

It’s hard to believe but Thanksgiving is just around the corner! Place your pie order today 🥧🍂🍁
10/27/2026

It’s hard to believe but Thanksgiving is just around the corner! Place your pie order today 🥧🍂🍁

It’s hard to believe but Thanksgiving is right around the corner! Place your pie order today 🥧🍂🍁
10/27/2026

It’s hard to believe but Thanksgiving is right around the corner! Place your pie order today 🥧🍂🍁

Head to Cromer’s today to grab some desserts before we go on vacation! We will be back the week of October 13. Thanks in...
10/04/2026

Head to Cromer’s today to grab some desserts before we go on vacation! We will be back the week of October 13. Thanks in advance for your understanding and continued support 🍰🥧🧁

For Olivia & Dan 💍🤍Red velvet cake, cream cheese filling, vanilla buttercream.
09/27/2026

For Olivia & Dan 💍🤍

Red velvet cake, cream cheese filling, vanilla buttercream.

Coral and peach palette knife flowers for a wedding at the American hotel last weekend 💍Devil’s food cake, vanilla bean ...
09/24/2026

Coral and peach palette knife flowers for a wedding at the American hotel last weekend 💍

Devil’s food cake, vanilla bean whipped cream and vanilla buttercream.

Address

Sag Harbor, NY
11963

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Dorothy’s Baking Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby bakeries