Myrtle's Pies

Myrtle's Pies Myrtle's Pie Shop is known for their variety of homemade pies. Call a day in advance to order a special whole pie or to reserve a slice or two!!
(546)

We have lots of whole & sliced pie available daily!! Pie, Pie and MORE pie!!!

Goid morning....Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.Cinnamon rolls with cream ch...
06/18/2026

Goid morning....

Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

Cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing
Or with bourbon brown sugar icing

carrot cake cookies
Ginger Snaps
lemon shortbread
red velvet cookies
sugar cookies

no sugar added Apple with Stevis
rhubarb
blueberry
Gooseberry
blueberry / Plum / Peach
99% gluten-free Apple
very berry
sweet cherry
apricot
Elderberry
Red raspberry
black raspberry
apple
strawberry rhubarb
Dutch Apple
Cherry

pecan

Michele's Strawberry Shortcake pie
fresh strawberry pretzel
coffee and Bailey's pie
brownie bottom salted caramel coffee cream
pina colada pie
orange creamsicle pie
Tiramisu pie
RumChata pie
cake batter pie
carrot cake cheesecake pie
cherry cheesecake pie
banana cream
banana overboard with banana bread on the bottom
key lime
red raspberry cream
salted caramel cashew
salted caramel.... normal
lavender lemon raspberry Plum chiffon blueberry lemon
Lemon meringue
French silk
French silk with malt powder
chocolate cream
chocolate chocolate chip cream
German chocolate cream
peanut butter Oreo
chocolate peanut butter
Alan's chocolate coconut
coconut with pasty crust
coconut with cookie crust

have a great day!

06/13/2026

75% off the full price pies tomorrow, June 14th.....the pieced together pies are $5.00...
Take and bake are full price...
See ya tomorrow

Hello, Tomorrow is Sunday June 14thWe do a number system at 8:00 a.m. so, grab a number and come back at 9:00 a.m. when ...
06/13/2026

Hello,
Tomorrow is Sunday June 14th

We do a number system at 8:00 a.m.
so, grab a number and come back at 9:00 a.m. when we open......

Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

Good morning open Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. we have a new pie today ...pina colada pie (pine...
06/11/2026

Good morning

open Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

we have a new pie today ...pina colada pie (pineapple coconut Malibu rum)

orange creamsicle
Blondie brownie bottom butterscotch schnapps
tiramisu pie
white chocolate mint silk
fresh strawberry pretzel
blueberry lemon
Lemon meringue
lemon lavender overboard
salted caramel
Red raspberry cream
key lime
banana cream
coconut cream with pastry crust
coconut cream with cookie crust
Alan's chocolate coconut
peanut butter Oreo
chocolate peanut butter French silk chocolate cream
chocolate chocolate chip cream
French silk
French silk with malt

Dutch Apple
blueberry
rhubarb
Cherry
very berry
Peach
apricot
Gooseberry
red raspberry
black raspberry
apple
strawberry rhubarb

muffins....
cranberry orange or
apple walnut Raisin Bran

red velvet cookies
Ginger Snaps
sugar cookies
lemon shortbread

cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing

have a great day!

Good morning...These are the additional pies that are behind the other creampies
06/07/2026

Good morning...

These are the additional pies that are behind the other creampies

Hello.....Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. Sundays .....tomorrow June 7th we...
06/06/2026

Hello.....

Normal store hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

Sundays .....tomorrow June 7th we are open at 9:00 a.m.

we go in order by a number system ...
grab a number at 8:00 a.m.
come back at 9:00 a.m.

there are several pies that are behind the cream pie pictures at least 20 more pies!

we take 75% off of the full price

if the pie is pieced together ...it is $5 as marked on the box...

See you in the morning!

06/05/2026

Good morning

we're open early today
it's 9:00

we also have cranberry orange muffins and lemon shortbread cookies to add to our list

Good morning hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. and discount pies on Sunday at 9:00 a.m. Ci...
06/04/2026

Good morning

hours are Thursday Friday Saturday from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
and discount pies on Sunday at 9:00 a.m.

Cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing

Sugar cookies

Apple walnut raisin bran muffins

2 new pies .....
Apple overboard
(Apples, apple cookies, apple pudding, apple chiffon)
Cherry overboard
(Cherries, Cherry cookies, Cherry pudding, Cherry chiffon)

red raspberry cream
carrot cake cheesecake pie
buttermilk pie
butter pecan pie
butterscotch overboard
sour cream raisin with brown sugar meringue
coffee and Bailey's pie
brownie bottom salted caramel coffee cream
fresh strawberry pretzel
fresh strawberry oatmeal
lemon meringue
lavender lemon raspberry Plum chiffon salted caramel
RumChata pie
key lime
banana cream
coconut cream with pastry crust
coconut cream with cookie crust
Alan's chocolate coconut
peanut butter Oreo
chocolate peanut butter pie
French silk
French silk with malt
chocolate cream
Chocolate chocolate chip cream

99% gluten free Apple

Dutch Apple
blueberry
Peach
Apple
cherry
strawberry rhubarb
rhubarb
red raspberry

have a great day!

Hello....Tomorrow is Sunday, May 31stDiscount pies 75% off regular priceOrPieced together for $5Grab a number at 8 a.m....
05/30/2026

Hello....

Tomorrow is Sunday, May 31st

Discount pies
75% off regular price
Or
Pieced together for $5

Grab a number at 8 a.m. to hold your place in line
Come back at 9 a.m. when we open

They go quickly!
Open until 10 or sold out

Good morning carrot cake cookies sugar cookies cinnamon rolls with bourbon brown sugar icing cinnamon rolls with cream c...
05/28/2026

Good morning

carrot cake cookies
sugar cookies

cinnamon rolls with bourbon brown sugar icing
cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing

fresh strawberry oatmeal
chocolate cream
chocolate chocolate chip cream
Blondie brownie bottom butterscotch schnapped
caramel apple pecan chiffon
butter pecan
Carrot cake cheesecake pie
banana cream
key lime
RumChata pie
salted caramel
lavender lemon raspberry Plum chiffon lemon meringue
French silk
malted French silk
caramel pecan French silk
Chocolate peanut butter
Peanut butter Oreo
Coconut cream with cookie crust
coconut cream with pastry crust

Dutch Apple
Peach
Apple
cherry
red raspberry
rhubarb
strawberry rhubarb

have a great day!

Address

927 N Main Street
Princeton, IL
61356

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Myrtle's Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Myrtle's Pies:

Shortcuts

Share