Oatmeal Cream Pie Company

Home
United States
Midlothian, VA
Oatmeal Cream Pie Company

I’m an artist in (& out of) kitchen and I’ve perfected a nostalgic treat, the oatmeal cream pie (affectionately nicknamed around here, the OCP)!

Each pie is home-baked with love using only the best available ingredients. OCPs... bliss in every bite.

05/28/2026

Edit - ALL SOLD. thank you so much!
🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS!!

🎉 SCHOOL’S ALMOST OUT & THE OCPs ARE ALMOST GONE 🎉

On my LAST baking day before I close up shop for summer break I have several extra bags available for pickup now:
☀️🍪
- (2) chocolate chip $14.75ea.
- (2) salted key lime $15ea. SOLD
- 1 mixed bag (half key lime & half butterscotch chip) $15 Sold
- 1 mixed bag (half original with STRAWBERRY cream & half chocolate chip) $15 Sold

05/26/2026

🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS!

Thursday is my LAST baking day before I close up shop for the summer ☀️🍪 Which means this is one of your last chances to get your hands on some OCPs before they disappear until fall! Grab some for teacher gifts, end-of-school treats, fun lunchbox snacks!! I have 3 half-dozen bags available for pickup anytime after 3:15 today:
- chocolate chip $14.75 sold
- butterscotch chip $14.95 sold
- mixed bag (4 choc chip + 2 butterscotch chip) $14.75

🍪 Comment below or message me to claim yours! 🍪

05/22/2026

UPDATE - I am now fully booked next week but will post extras if I end up with extra dough and time! 😊 Thank you all so much.

☀️ Friendly warning: Next Thursday is my LAST baking day before I shut this operation down for my annual summer break to focus on my family. ☀️

Translation: if you don’t order now, your next chance at dessert happiness is September. Godspeed. 🫡

I still have a little more availability for Tuesday + Thursday, and SALTED KEY LIME is making an appearance 🍋‍🟩 ✨ with limited quantities of other flavors available too!

Get those orders in now — I will book up. ❤️

05/13/2026

Edit - SOLD
🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS! Need a mid-week treat? 🍪 I have just 1 extra half-dozen bag of oatmeal chocolate chip up for grabs. $14.75 and available now. Comment below or shoot me a message to snag it! 🍪

05/08/2026

Edit - all SOLD!

🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS! Mother’s Day is Sunday.. ahem, ahem. 🍓 Because I wanted strawberry OCPs for my own Sunday celebration, I made extras! I am particularly obsessed with the strawberry chocolate chip. 🤤
I have several extra bags available right now. $15 each. Please only claim if you can pick up today.
- (1) original/strawberry cream
- (1) oatmeal chocolate chip/strawberry cream - sold.
- (2) mixed variety bags - contains 2 each of original (strawberry cream), chocolate chip (strawberry cream), butterscotch chip (original cream) - both SOLD

Shoot me a message or comment below with what bag(s) you’d like and I’ll send you an invoice. They’re ready for pick up when you are! 🎉

05/06/2026

Edit - SOLD.
🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS! *Please only claim if you can pick up today!* I have a couple extra half-dozen bags available right now!
Perfect for:
💁🏻‍♀️that teacher you definitely meant to plan for
💁🏻‍♀️the nurse who deserves better than a last-minute gift card
💁🏻‍♀️the team mom who somehow runs everything
💁🏻‍♀️you, hiding in your car for 5 minutes of peace

- (1) Originals $13.75 SOLD
- (1) Mixed Variety (1/2 chocolate chip & 1/2 butterscotch) $14.95

Comment below or shoot me a message to claim. If you’re 1st to call dibs, I’ll send you an invoice!

05/01/2026

TGIF 🎉 Come out to support Wishing Well Park and enjoy an evening filled with live music, a bake sale (OCPs and more!), and a delicious food truck lineup.

Grab a treat, stay for the fun, and help make a difference 💫

04/23/2026

Edit - all SOLD.
🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS - including SALTED KEY LIME!! 🍋‍🟩

Who needs a last-minute treat for whatever the weekend brings you? ☀️ I have the following extra oatmeal cream pies, available for pickup TODAY anytime after 2:30. Comment or message me to claim…
- half-dozen bag butterscotch chip $14.95
- half-dozen mixed variety bag (2 salted key lime/ 3 chocolate chip/ 1 butterscotch chip) $15 *SOLD*
- 15-pack mixed variety box (5 salted key lime/ 5 chocolate chip/ 5 butterscotch chip) $37.50 *SOLD*

Comment, message or text to claim some! 🍪

04/14/2026

Edit - SOLD.
🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS!! Perfect for this beautiful day… porch snack, after-school treat, or a little “just because” moment. ☀️

I have just 1 extra half-dozen mixed bag available - 1/2 chocolate chip & 1/2 salted key lime. $15 Available for pickup now.

Comment below to claim them! ☀️

04/13/2026

EDIT - sold out for tomorrow!!

Tomorrow’s forecast calls for…
🍋‍🟩 Salted Key Lime Oatmeal Cream Pies 🍋‍🟩

Bright, citrusy key lime cream filling. Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies. A little sprinkle of flaky salt on top because we believe in ✨balance✨.

It’s giving sunshine.
It’s giving patio weather.
It’s giving “I deserve two.”

☀️ If Spring doesn’t scream key lime season, I don’t know what does. ☀️

💚 Link to order in the comments. If online ordering shows not available, I am sold out. Available for pickup tomorrow after 3:00.

04/10/2026

Edit - all SOLD.

🧑‍🍳 BAKING EXTRAS!! I’ve been absent for a bit while I enjoyed some Spring Break island time but I’m back and I made a few extra bags today!

Perfect for kicking off the weekend, an after-school treat, or a little “happy Friday” moment for yourself 😄

I have the following half-dozen bags available for pick up anytime after 2:00 today-
- original $13.75 (sold)
- oatmeal chocolate chip $14.75
- butterscotch chip $14.95

Comment below or shoot me a message to claim your weekend-ready bag!! 🎉

Address

Midlothian, VA
23113

Website

https://shop.bakesy.app/b/oatmeal-cream-pie-company

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Oatmeal Cream Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Midlothian?