The Rolling Pin Custom Cake Shop

The Rolling Pin Custom Cake Shop Specializing in homemade one of a kind custom cakes. Everything is baked fresh per order. Please allow 2 weeks' notice for custom orders.

Call, text, or message and place your order today! All of my baked goods are made to order. Please call at least 2 weeks prior to your event to get on my schedule. As a sole proprietor there are times I am booked solid. Parties can request to be put on my calendar 6 months out and weddings 1 year out.

*****edit SOLD OUT***Ok guys the slice it Sunday fridge is filled and we are open early!!!I have:Slices of birthday cake...
08/30/2026

*****edit SOLD OUT***

Ok guys the slice it Sunday fridge is filled and we are open early!!!

I have:
Slices of birthday cake (4)
Slices of red velvet (4)
Slices of white wedding cake (2.50)
Slices of chocolate cake (2.50)
1 dozen Mini cupcakes (6)
Cake parfaits in the following flavors(3)
Lemon blueberry
Strawberry cheesecake
Banana cream
Oreo
Peanut butter candy
Chocolate covered strawberry

Prices are in the parentheses. Cameras are on so please be honest.
Cash box is located on the wall, venmo and PayPal information is on the front door. We will stay open till everything is sold out. I will keep you all updated on what's left as the day goes on in the comments here.

Hey guess what this little cup will hold come Sunday at our slice it Sunday sale???Any guesses!!I'm so excited 😊 and hun...
08/28/2026

Hey guess what this little cup will hold come Sunday at our slice it Sunday sale???

Any guesses!!

I'm so excited 😊 and hungry 🤤 lol

Well now that summer is winding down (insert sad face here) I am finally able to do some cookie carts and slice it Sunda...
08/26/2026

Well now that summer is winding down (insert sad face here) I am finally able to do some cookie carts and slice it Sundays again.

Soooooooo slice it Sunday, this Sunday (8/30) starting at NOON.

What cakes should I make?

***Cute Ollie pic so I don't get lost in your feeds, plus he is just a legend so why not...

So many goodies left!!Come and get em guys.
08/13/2026

So many goodies left!!
Come and get em guys.

*****EDIT******COOKIE CART POP UP STARTING AT 5:00PMI was looking forward to market but I'm not chancing this weather. ...
08/12/2026

*****EDIT******

COOKIE CART POP UP STARTING AT 5:00PM

I was looking forward to market but I'm not chancing this weather. I am offering a cookie cart pop up sale starting at 5pm tonight.

I have:
2pk jumbo chocolate chip cookies (4)
2pk lemon squares (4)
2pk cosmic brownies (4)
2pk strawberry pie bars (4)
3pk chocolate whoopie pies (4)
Dozen chocolate chip cookies (10)
Dozen trail mix cookies (10)
Mini cakes (3.50) chocolate PB, sea salted caramel, strawberry crunch, and classic birthday cake

Original post**

Well I was excited for market. Made some goodies but it is down pouring and weather for newfane has me worried. Do you guys think I should just take my items and have a little pop up cookie cart tonight at the bakery or chance the nasty weather? Honestly it's the hail and wind gusts that have me a little nervous.

08/03/2026

Remember that contest I posted a while back. Well I have the winner. There were so many comments and likes and shares that the post reached over 55k people.

Thank you so much for sharing guys but there can only be one winner and that winner is

Elizabeth Desabrais

She has over 50 likes on her breast feeding award cake. Her husband was so sweet for reaching out to me to order this for her to celebrate the milestone of feeding their child for 2 years.

I have known Liz for over 10 years. She wears many hats including wife, mother, firefighter, EMT, vet tech and a friend. I couldn't think of a better person, which I didn't, you all did the voting!

Congrats Liz. $100 gift card is coming your way. Just in time to think about a 1st birthday you have coming up in a few months

We look forward to working with you and Justin on another cake real soon.

Congrats Liz!!

07/27/2026

Heads up cake fam, no market this week for us. We have had a death within the Fire Hall. The funeral is Wednesday so we will use this time to surround our fire hall family with love and support.

Thank you all for your understanding .

We will hopefully see everyone on 8/5/26.

Limited left over goodies from market last night. The price is listed on the shelf for all the items. Chocolate Covere...
07/23/2026

Limited left over goodies from market last night. The price is listed on the shelf for all the items.

Chocolate Covered Pretzels are $1.60
Vanilla cake pops, jumbo M&M cookies , brownies, brookies, and smores on a stick are $2
And dot cakes and strawberry pie bars are $3.

When its sold out its sold out. Money box for cash, venmo and paypal options are available as well.

Farmers market goodies!!Chocolate Covered Pretzels Vanilla cake popsStrawberry pie barsLemon squaresBrowniesM&M cookiesB...
07/22/2026

Farmers market goodies!!

Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Vanilla cake pops
Strawberry pie bars
Lemon squares
Brownies
M&M cookies
Brookies
Whoopie pies
Jumbo chocolate chip cookies
Smores on a stick
Dot cakes

Tallow balms
Fresh cut flowers
And zuchini and squash

07/22/2026

Farmers market tonight in Newfane from 4:30pm till 7pm. I'll post what I have available and pics of everything once I'm set up.

Address

9333 Ridge Road
Middleport, NY
14105

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Rolling Pin Custom Cake Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category