Michelle’s Custom Cookies

Michelle’s Custom Cookies Cottage baker in Johnstown, OH specializing in custom sugar cookies
Need cookies for an event, holiday, or just because? I can make a cookie for that 🩷

Congratulations again to Audrey!
05/30/2026

Congratulations again to Audrey!

Added a few more band jackets to my collection… Congrats Audrey as you finish up high school and continue your adventure...
05/30/2026

Added a few more band jackets to my collection… Congrats Audrey as you finish up high school and continue your adventure at BGSU ❤️🧡🤎

Another Johnstown grad headed off to Heidelberg in the fall 📚⚽️
05/30/2026

Another Johnstown grad headed off to Heidelberg in the fall 📚⚽️

Congrats to Braeden heading to MVNU in the fall⚾️📚
05/30/2026

Congrats to Braeden heading to MVNU in the fall⚾️📚

Nothing says graduation season like making 10 pounds of royal icing in one day. 🎓📚
05/30/2026

Nothing says graduation season like making 10 pounds of royal icing in one day. 🎓📚

I borrowed this from a cookie page I’m on… so true!! I apologize if I’ve had a recent conversation with you about humidi...
05/27/2026

I borrowed this from a cookie page I’m on… so true!! I apologize if I’ve had a recent conversation with you about humidity and icing.
Hope everyone is staying dry out there!!

Isabella is headed to Bluffton to study marketing analytics and run cross country! Go 🦫 Beavers! 💜💜
05/24/2026

Isabella is headed to Bluffton to study marketing analytics and run cross country!
Go 🦫 Beavers! 💜💜

Graduation cookies for my niece today, Congrats Isabella!!!💜🖤🩶
05/24/2026

Graduation cookies for my niece today, Congrats Isabella!!!💜🖤🩶

Congrats to Wesley heading to University of Dayton in the fall!! 💙❤️💙❤️
05/23/2026

Congrats to Wesley heading to University of Dayton in the fall!! 💙❤️💙❤️

Congrats to Jacey finishing up her high school chapter and heading to OU to major in journalism 💚🐾
05/23/2026

Congrats to Jacey finishing up her high school chapter and heading to OU to major in journalism 💚🐾

Address

Johnstown, OH
43031

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Michelle’s Custom Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Michelle’s Custom Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category