Michelle’s Custom Cookies

Michelle’s Custom Cookies Cottage baker in Johnstown, OH specializing in custom sugar cookies
Need cookies for an event, holiday, or just because? I can make a cookie for that 🩷

June cookies of the month 🙂 🌊
06/15/2026

June cookies of the month 🙂 🌊

A non-traditional grad set! Loved all the colors on this one! Congrats!! 🥳 🌸🌼🪻
06/14/2026

A non-traditional grad set! Loved all the colors on this one! Congrats!! 🥳 🌸🌼🪻

Grad season continues! Congrats to Cameron heading to Ashland in the fall!
06/14/2026

Grad season continues! Congrats to Cameron heading to Ashland in the fall!

Congrats to Taylor and Josh! May you have a lifetime of happiness and love ❤️
06/14/2026

Congrats to Taylor and Josh!
May you have a lifetime of happiness and love ❤️

Congrats to Tyler on his graduation from Licking Heights!! 🎓🎓🥳
06/07/2026

Congrats to Tyler on his graduation from Licking Heights!! 🎓🎓🥳

More cookies to celebrate Kate! Headed to University of Miami 🧡💚
06/06/2026

More cookies to celebrate Kate! Headed to University of Miami 🧡💚

Congratulations to Kate finishing up her high school career 🎓💙
06/06/2026

Congratulations to Kate finishing up her high school career 🎓💙

Congrats to Erik on his high school graduation and best of luck on his next journey 🙂 ⚡️🎓
06/05/2026

Congrats to Erik on his high school graduation and best of luck on his next journey 🙂 ⚡️🎓

Happy National Donut day!!! Obviously you all love elf “donuts”…. What is your favorite place to grab a donut? I haven’t...
06/05/2026

Happy National Donut day!!!
Obviously you all love elf “donuts”…. What is your favorite place to grab a donut?
I haven’t met many donuts I didn’t like…. But my favorite are Resch’s or Rolls by the Pound

Congratulations again to Audrey!
05/30/2026

Congratulations again to Audrey!

Address

Johnstown, OH
43031

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Michelle’s Custom Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Michelle’s Custom Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category