08/04/2026
I get asked all the time if I can add more cheese or more jalapeƱos to my JalapeƱo Cheddar loaf.
The short answer? Yes, I could.
The better answer is why I donāt.
Iāve spent nearly two years tweaking this loaf. I have pages of notes. If one batch of jalapeƱos is wetter than the last, I adjust. If I cube the cheese instead of shredding it, I adjust. If itās 90° with 80% humidity outside, I adjust. If itās January and the dough is fermenting differently, I adjust. Every single variable matters, and greatly changes the outcome.
My recipe is already 20% cheese and 12% fresh jalapeƱos based on the flour weight. Thatās 32% inclusions in a loaf of bread.
Fresh peppers add water. Cheese changes the dough. Too much of either starts affecting fermentation, gluten development, oven spring, and the crumb. More isnāt always better.
Could I keep piling more into it? Sure.
But then Iād be making a loaf thatās about stuffing as much filling into it as possible instead of making exceptional artisan bread.
Another thing thatās important to understand is that I canāt control exactly where every piece of cheese and every jalapeƱo ends up. I use the best techniques I know to distribute everything as evenly as possible, but once the dough is folded, shaped, fermented, and baked, every handmade loaf is unique. Some slices will have more, some will have less. Thatās simply the nature of artisan bread.
I completely understand if your favorite kind of loaf is one thatās absolutely packed with cheese and jalapeƱos. There are bakers who make that style, and if thatās what you love, thatās okay.
My philosophy is simple: bread first.
Iāll always prioritize the bread before the inclusions. I want great oven spring, a beautiful crumb, balanced flavor, and a loaf thatās just as enjoyable to eat as it is beautiful to look at.
Every recipe on my menu has been tested, adjusted, and refined over hundreds of bakes. Some of those recipes are part of my bakeryās identity, and they arenāt going to change simply because they donāt match every individual preference. Thatās one of the things that makes every artisan bakery different.
As always, you know I have an open-door policy. I genuinely want to hear from you. If you loved your bread, tell everyone. If you didnāt, tell me. I canāt improve what I donāt know, and I truly appreciate your feedback.
Iāll always listen, and Iāll always consider your suggestions. But every change I make has to answer one question:
Does it make the bread better?
If the answer is no, I wonāt make that change.
Because my promise to you is simple:
Bread first. Always.