Supreme Bakery

Supreme Bakery Providing fresh desserts to our local community since ‘63 Everything is baked from scratch using the finest ingredients.

Located in West Orange, Supreme Bakery is a family owned and operated bakery offering a full line of delicious, quality baked goods. Specializing in beautifully crafted cakes, we pride ourselves on our attention to detail, fantastic products and great service. Our full line of artisanal bakery products includes cupcakes, danishes, donuts, breads, pies, cookies and more. All of our baking is done o

n our premises and is under the close supervision of owner and certified Master Baker Richard Stolz. Supreme Bakery’s decadent and delicious cakes are great for weddings, birthdays, bridal showers, anniversaries, graduations and more. Choose from our rich cakes and fillings and creamy frostings, and add your own personalized message for a special treat, perfect for any occasion. Supreme Bakery has been providing the freshest and finest bakery products to the residents of West Orange and surrounding areas since 1969.

Whether its a backyard barbecue, a picnic for two, or just viewing out the window.Make it SPARKLE with themed holiday de...
07/04/2024

Whether its a backyard barbecue, a picnic for two, or just viewing out the window.
Make it SPARKLE with themed holiday desserts from us!

Cookies, cakes, cupcakes and more available now in store

Make your backyard party SPARK 🎆Enjoy treats perfect for a firework watching picnic or a family barbecue! Delicious and ...
07/02/2024

Make your backyard party SPARK 🎆

Enjoy treats perfect for a firework watching picnic or a family barbecue! Delicious and a conversation sparker

Available now and made to order!

Who’s running the barbecue’s this year?! Make your back yard celebration POP 🎉 with delicious additions that are sure sp...
06/27/2024

Who’s running the barbecue’s this year?!

Make your back yard celebration POP 🎉 with delicious additions that are sure spark up the party 🎆

From fluffy cakes, to hot pies and more. Bring on that sparkle ✨

Gift them the best party for their years of hard work. Plan ahead! Order now to customize any cake, cupcake cake, cookie...
06/18/2024

Gift them the best party for their years of hard work.

Plan ahead! Order now to customize any cake, cupcake cake, cookies and more to be specially made to fit every school and party theme

Congrats to the !!

Dads deserve celebration too! Commemorate Dad for all his hard work with something sweet and made with love. Swipe to se...
06/14/2024

Dads deserve celebration too!

Commemorate Dad for all his hard work with something sweet and made with love. Swipe to see our ready made Fathers Day cakes in store

NEW for a limited time : Blueberry Ring CakeEnjoy a beautifully refreshing cake with fresh berries and a vanilla glaze o...
06/03/2024

NEW for a limited time : Blueberry Ring Cake

Enjoy a beautifully refreshing cake with fresh berries and a vanilla glaze on top.

The perfect house gift or after dinner dessert!

Let’s support our community!This Saturday 6/1 from 10am-12pm, the PTA of Hazel Avenue School in West Orange (45 Hazel Av...
05/28/2024

Let’s support our community!

This Saturday 6/1 from 10am-12pm, the PTA of Hazel Avenue School in West Orange (45 Hazel Ave) is holding an in-person pay-what-you-can plant sale, all homegrown and donated by community gardeners, to fund their new pantry and greenhouse.

We will be there providing free breakfast for everyone that can stop by and show their support.

We look forward to seeing you there!

05/28/2024

Enjoy our limited edition traditional Argentinian dessert: Alfajores 🤍

A soft melt-in-your-mouth cookie, embracing a luscious dollop of creamy dulce de leche caramel. Rolled in shredded coconut and coated in decadent powdered sugar

Available in store now for a limited time

High school, College or Pre K. Celebrate their success with a Custom Cake from us!
05/27/2024

High school, College or Pre K. Celebrate their success with a Custom Cake from us!

Celebrate their Graduation in style with custom cupcakes and cakes perfect for every type of partyCongrats 2024 grads!! ...
05/27/2024

Celebrate their Graduation in style with custom cupcakes and cakes perfect for every type of party

Congrats 2024 grads!! 🎉

Experience a Refreshing Summer with our Limited Edition Lavender Lemonade 🍋Enjoy an Electric taste of Calming Lavender ⚡...
05/21/2024

Experience a Refreshing Summer with our Limited Edition Lavender Lemonade 🍋

Enjoy an Electric taste of Calming Lavender ⚡️😌

Celebrate Your Graduate’s Big Day with Sweetness! 🎓✨ Customize your Grad treats in every way possible. Put a photo of yo...
05/13/2024

Celebrate Your Graduate’s Big Day with Sweetness! 🎓✨

Customize your Grad treats in every way possible.

Put a photo of your Graduate on the cake with our edible toppers. Not looking for a cake?
Opt for decorated cookies or custom cupcakes.

Order now and make their graduation unforgettable!
Call or email to order

For Moms of every kindShow how big your Heart is with our 8” Heart Shaped Cake! Available in a variety of flavors, we ha...
05/10/2024

For Moms of every kind

Show how big your Heart is with our 8” Heart Shaped Cake!
Available in a variety of flavors, we have just what you need to show Mom you care 💗

Give Mom a beautiful bouquet. A cupcake bouquet that is 💐Celebrate her and all that she does with something you know she...
05/10/2024

Give Mom a beautiful bouquet. A cupcake bouquet that is 💐

Celebrate her and all that she does with something you know she’ll love 💗

Celebrating Nurses everywhere this   dayKnow of someone earning their title? Congratulate them with a specialty cake cus...
05/07/2024

Celebrating Nurses everywhere this day

Know of someone earning their title? Congratulate them with a specialty cake custom made by us!

Whether they are graduating from highschool, college, a program or pre school. A graduation cake is the perfect way to enjoy a slice of achievement

College Grads!! Your time to shine is right around the corner. Parents!! Celebrate your child’s major achievement with a...
05/06/2024

College Grads!! Your time to shine is right around the corner.
Parents!! Celebrate your child’s major achievement with a cake made specially for them

Customized designs, size and colors to perfectly suit your special occasion

Say thanks to your child’s caregiver, teacher, bus driver and faculty for doing such a wonderful job caring and educatin...
05/06/2024

Say thanks to your child’s caregiver, teacher, bus driver and faculty for doing such a wonderful job caring and educating our little ones by giving a gift you know they’ll enjoy.

Teachers don’t want apples they want coffee!

All Teachers will get free coffee on us this week with a show of faculty identification. Any size and flavor.

Sending a personal gift? Opt for a Supreme bakery gift card so they can get all the coffee & desserts they deserve

Say thanks to your child’s caregiver, teacher, bus driver and faculty for doing such a wonderful job caring and educatin...
05/06/2024

Say thanks to your child’s caregiver, teacher, bus driver and faculty for doing such a wonderful job caring and educating our little ones by giving a gift you know they’ll enjoy.

Teachers don’t want apples they want coffee!
Opt for a Supreme bakery gift card so they can get all the desserts they deserve

All Teachers will get free coffee on us this week with a show of faculty identification. Any size and flavor.

Celebrate in style this   with an assortment of holiday themed desserts!! Cookies available in cactus, fiesta, taco, som...
05/04/2024

Celebrate in style this with an assortment of holiday themed desserts!!

Cookies available in cactus, fiesta, taco, sombrero and more!

Party in style this    🎉🍸🌮These margarita and taco cupcakes are the perfect addition to any fiesta this weekend! Availab...
05/03/2024

Party in style this 🎉🍸🌮

These margarita and taco cupcakes are the perfect addition to any fiesta this weekend!

Available for a limited time only

🎉

Best drink hands down!! This lavender lemonade is absolutely delicious and perfectly refreshing for the warm weather. Ge...
05/01/2024

Best drink hands down!! This lavender lemonade is absolutely delicious and perfectly refreshing for the warm weather.

Get an electric taste of calming lavender in our new Spring Lemonade ⚡️🍋

Available now for a limited time

All fun and all sweets this week. Swipe to see the special of the week! Show us this post or do the Supreme chant for an...
04/11/2024

All fun and all sweets this week. Swipe to see the special of the week!

Show us this post or do the Supreme chant for an immediate discount off your order

See you then!

📍 40 main st, West Orange Nj 07052

Celebrate the eclipse in totality with our limited time Solar Eclipse cake!  Don’t stay in the dark. Enjoy 15% off all o...
04/07/2024

Celebrate the eclipse in totality with our limited time Solar Eclipse cake! Don’t stay in the dark. Enjoy 15% off all online orders with code ECLIPSE tomorrow only

Our Open Face Apple Torte is a Pie like no other! 🥧 Available for pre order or in store for a limited time - April 18th!...
04/04/2024

Our Open Face Apple Torte is a Pie like no other! 🥧

Available for pre order or in store for a limited time - April 18th!

Make room on the table for all of our limited edition Passover Goodies 😋

Make this Easter Egg-citing with lots of fun egg themed desserts! Egg shaped cakes, cupcakes, Easter bread and Easter th...
03/31/2024

Make this Easter Egg-citing with lots of fun egg themed desserts!

Egg shaped cakes, cupcakes, Easter bread and Easter themed items available all throughout the store today!

🐰

In celebration of Women’s History Month, we partnered with  to host a networking event for women entrepreneurs. The high...
03/27/2024

In celebration of Women’s History Month, we partnered with to host a networking event for women entrepreneurs.

The highlight was a panel of women entrepreneurs, including , owner of First Mountain Preschool, and two Downtown WO business owners, Brandi B, owner of , and Alisa Kuppe, of , who also graciously provided a wine tasting! Rounding out the panel were WO residents Monique Dominique, who recently launched the luxury magazine .citylifestyle , and , who owns two Express Employment Professionals franchises.

We enjoyed lively conversation around Supreme Bakery’s “community table” and participants walked away with a wealth of information, inspiration, and actionable insights.

🫶🏽 Thank you to additional sponsors: , the European Wax of Montclair, , , , photography, and gift shop.

Getting ready for tonight’s event, our Women in Business Entrepreneurial Panel & Mixer! Seats are fully sold out! Woohoo...
03/25/2024

Getting ready for tonight’s event, our Women in Business Entrepreneurial Panel & Mixer!

Seats are fully sold out! Woohoo 🙌🏼

Check our previous post for info on the speakers and the schedule for tonight

Cant wait to see you all there!

All guests at tonight Women’s history month Entrepreneurial mixer will receive a voucher for a FREE Coffee from Us!Any f...
03/25/2024

All guests at tonight Women’s history month Entrepreneurial mixer will receive a voucher for a FREE Coffee from Us!

Any flavor any size! Try your favorites or try something new!
Cappuccino, Latte, All American, Iced Coffee, and more!

Event starts at 6pm sharp! There is street parking available in front and a parking lot in the back of our store. See you there!

📍40 main st west orange nj 07052

Deets on our Woman’s history month: Woman in business panelThanks everyone who will be joining us tonight’s panelRsvp is...
03/23/2024

Deets on our Woman’s history month: Woman in business panel

Thanks everyone who will be joining us tonight’s panel
Rsvp is now closed and we look forward to seeing you all tonight!

Easter is finally coming around Make the most out of your family memories this year and opt for some beautiful spring th...
03/19/2024

Easter is finally coming around

Make the most out of your family memories this year and opt for some beautiful spring themed desserts.

From our easter bunny cakes to cupcakes, special cake filled eggs, easter bread and more!

Available to preorder now

Address

40 Main Street
West Orange, NJ
07052

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 7pm
Tuesday 6am - 7pm
Wednesday 6am - 7pm
Thursday 6am - 7pm
Friday 6am - 7pm
Saturday 6am - 7pm
Sunday 7am - 6pm

Telephone

+19737361732

Website

https://order.toasttab.com/online/supreme-bakery2-40-main-street/item-secure-your-spot_aa

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Supreme Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Supreme Bakery:

Videos

Share

Category


Other Cupcake Shops in West Orange

Show All