Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes We are your Local Dessert/Bakery/Candy Shoppe that Specializes in a Variety of Italian style Cheesecakes, Baked Goods, Candies, Nostalgic Toys, Gifts and More!
(2)

Step into Guilty Pleasures and Step back into your Childhood. Marvelous Surprises Await You... We are Your Local Dessert/Bakery/Candy/Cafe and Gift Shoppe! Each week we will feature a different variety of flavors. If you see something you MUST TRY, place an order in advance (3 days notice). If you have a flavor request and don't see it on the menu, feel free to contact us. We ❤️ Creating New Flavors! Step Inside Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes and Step Back into your Childhood! We Now Have Gifts Cards Available! https://squareup.com/gift/ML8E705VSGAFH/order?fbclid=IwAR1FMy7Hx70bYuLTVucXYkIt9FOIS5E_aKOSGY6Kv0gAISrm2288r2hQAYY

10/19/2026

👻☕ IF THESE WALLS COULD TALK… THIS WEDNESDAY, WE’RE LISTENING!
Our historic home at 1 Depot Street has plenty of stories and this week, Guilty Pleasures Cafe becomes the setting for Paranormal Tea Time’s first-ever LIVE, on-location podcast! 🕯️💜
Joining the conversation is Chris DiCesare, featured in Netflix’s True Haunting, for an evening exploring his experiences, the paranormal, and the history and ghost stories surrounding our cafe. 👀
Plus, get a taste of what’s coming when Witchingtonville After Dark: Darkness Returns takes over Washingtonville this Saturday, October 24! 🌙
📅 Wednesday, October 21 ⏰ 8:30 PM ET 📺 Watch Paranormal Tea Time LIVE on Facebook or YouTube 📍 Broadcasting from Guilty Pleasures Cafe, Washingtonville, NY
Grab your tea, join the live chat, and see where the conversation takes us… 👻☕
Tag someone who loves a good ghost story, share this reel, and follow us for more updates!

10/18/2026

🍂☕ CHILLY MORNINGS. HOT COFFEE. BREAKFAST WORTH GETTING UP FOR.
Sunday mornings at Guilty Pleasures Cafe start with that first sip of coffee… and a delicious reason to stay awhile. 🤎
🌀 It’s Cinnamon Bun Sunday! Soft, pillowy swirls of cinnamon goodness topped with luscious icing. Grab your fork, claim your favorite bite, and get here early they sell out quickly!
🥓🥚🧀 Craving a genuine NYC Bacon, Egg & Cheese? Choose a bagel, roll, or buttery croissant and sink your teeth into savory, cheesy breakfast perfection.
🍎 Our Morning Orchard Breakfast brings the fall flavor: ham, egg, melted cheddar, and apple butter stacked on an apple cinnamon raisin bagel. Sweet meets savory in every bite!
🍩 Our award-winning Apple C***r Donuts are baked daily! That cinnamon-sugar bite practically begs for a sip of hot coffee.
🍫 Meet your newest temptation: Rocky Road Cannolis! Crispy shells, rich chocolate ricotta filling, marshmallow goodness, crunchy almonds, and chocolate drizzle. A marriage between two of our favorites—and love at first bite!
☕ Complete your Sunday spread with Irving Farm coffee, a signature espresso drink, or steaming hot apple c***r. Feeling adventurous? Explore our October drink specials, from the Samoa Cookie Butter Latte to Harvest Spiced Dirty Chai & Maple! 🍁
Come in from the fall chill. Bring your appetite and your favorite person. Breakfast now, a few treats to take home… that’s a Sunday well spent. 🤎
📍 Guilty Pleasures Cafe 1 Depot Street, Washingtonville
👇 Tag your Sunday breakfast date—and tell us what you’re ordering first!
***rDonuts SundayBreakfast ShopLocal

🥐 YOU ASKED, WE ANSWERED! ☕✨Say hello to our OLD-FASHIONED CHEESE DANISH—now made right here in the shop at Guilty Pleas...
10/16/2026

🥐 YOU ASKED, WE ANSWERED! ☕✨
Say hello to our OLD-FASHIONED CHEESE DANISH—now made right here in the shop at Guilty Pleasures Cafe! Golden pastry with a creamy cheese center… your coffee just found its new best friend. 🤎

✨ AVAILABLE STARTING TODAY! ✨
Pair yours with an Irving Farm drip coffee or one of our signature espresso drinks for a delicious little break in your day. ☕💛

We are only 8 Days Away from Witchingtonville After Dark!

Guilty Pleasures will be a Hub of Activities that Night.
Steps away from the Festivies join us for
Whispers Through the Veil An Interactive Spirit Communication Experience where Full Moon Paranormal and Christopher DiCesare will be using the Tools of the Middle Ages to communicate with the spirit world! TICKETS ARE ALMOST COMPLETELY SOLD OUT. ACT NOW!

Join us for Mystics, Magic & Many Marvelous Surprises that Await You on Saturday October 24th!

📍 Historic 1 Depot Street, Washingtonville, NY
👇 TAG a cheese Danish lover or Halloween Ju**ie who needs to know!



BIG THINGS ARE HAPPENING AT GUILTY PLEASURES CAFE! ✨Your favorite spot for coffee, breakfast, lunch & something sweet is...
10/15/2026

BIG THINGS ARE HAPPENING AT GUILTY PLEASURES CAFE! ✨

Your favorite spot for coffee, breakfast, lunch & something sweet is becoming your next favorite night out! ☕🍰 From Creative Workshops and Mahjong to Mystical Experiences and Relaxing Holistic Evenings, Live Music & Pop Up Markets there’s so much to look forward to… and MANY MORE EVENTS TO COME! 🙌

🌿 SCENT • SOUND • REFLEXOLOGY
An Evening of Sensory Restoration
With Rose from Root Revivals & Claudia
📅 November 4 & December 2
🕖 7–8:15 PM | $40 per evening
Botanical aromas, soothing sounds and foot reflexology—a little time just for YOU.

🌙 THE SPACE BETWEEN
An Evening of Deep Rest & Renewal
With Wild Hearts Healing Arts Center
📅 Saturday, November 7
🕖 7–8:15 PM | $40
Unwind with Yoga Nidra, a sound bath and Reiki.

Mahj and Munch
Mahjong Beginners Workshop and Open Play
Wednesdays in October

Whispers through the Veil: An Interactive Spirit Communication with Full Moon Paranormal
Saturday October 24th 3 Events
TICKETS LIMITED

Witchingtonville After Dark: Darkness Returns
Mystics, Magic and a little Medieval Mayhem Await you at After Dark and Guilty Pleasures Cafe!

🎟️ Scan each event’s QR code to register!

🎉 YOUR NEXT GATHERING COULD HAPPEN HERE!
Planning a party? Have a workshop you’d love to teach? Message us to book your celebration or bring your creative idea to our beautiful historic event space!

📍Historic 1 Depot Street, Washingtonville, NY

👉 FOLLOW US for new event announcements!
💬 TAG your coffee date, creative friend or someone who deserves a relaxing night out!

Marvelous Surprises Await You… ✨

Sometimes getting up before the Crack of Dawn Has its Benefits!The Sights of a Beautiful SunriseAnd the Smells of Warm C...
10/11/2026

Sometimes getting up before the Crack of Dawn Has its Benefits!
The Sights of a Beautiful Sunrise
And the Smells of Warm Cinnamon Buns coming out of the Oven.
Come step out of the Fall Gloom and Enter a World of Pure Imagination...

We are Open Sunday 730-3pm

Historic 1 Depot Street in Washingtonville

Spend this Loong Weekend at Guilty Pleasures!🏆🍎 AWARD WINNING… WITH A NEW TWIST! 🧁Our Apple C***r Donuts took 1st Place ...
10/10/2026

Spend this Loong Weekend at Guilty Pleasures!

🏆🍎 AWARD WINNING… WITH A NEW TWIST! 🧁
Our Apple C***r Donuts took 1st Place in the 2025 Chronogram Readers’ Choice Awards and every cinnamon-sugar bite deserves a little celebration! 🙌

Meet our NEW Apple C***r Donut Cupcakes: Apple C***r Cupcakes, Apple C***r Buttercream, and a mini C***r Donut perched on top. Why choose between a Donut and a Cupcake when you can have BOTH? 😍

And Warming up in the Bullpen is Kayla's Cinnamon Buns!
Come Early on Sunday and get them Warm & Fresh out of the Oven! But Dont Delay, they Sell Out Pretty Quickly!

Grab your favorite coffee, bring your sweet tooth, and come taste what the buzz is about!

📍 Guilty Pleasures Cafe Historic 1 Depot Street, Washingtonville

Tag the friend who’s helping you taste-test both! 👇
Marvelous Surprises Await You…

***rDonuts ***rDonutCupcakes

TICKETS ARE DISAPPEARING QUICKLY!Step beyond the ordinary and experienceWhispers Through the Veil An Interactive Spirit ...
10/09/2026

TICKETS ARE DISAPPEARING QUICKLY!
Step beyond the ordinary and experience
Whispers Through the Veil An Interactive Spirit Communication Experience, an interactive spirit-communication experience featuring Full Moon Paranormal and Chris DiCesare, as seen in Netflix’s True Haunting.
For one unforgettable night, Guilty Pleasures Cafe will be transformed into a mysterious Dark Ages retreat filled with mystics, seers, snakes—and marvelous surprises lurking beyond the veil. 🔮🐍

📅 Saturday, October 24
🕯️ Sessions: 5:30 PM, 7:00 PM and 8:30 PM
📍 Historic 1 Depot Street, Washingtonville
🎟️ $25 per person | Ages 15+ | Limited tickets

Follow Guilty Pleasures Cafe and the Witchingtonville After Dark event page for continuing announcements and sinister surprises.

Tag the friend brave enough to join you in the darkness—and secure your tickets before they vanish! 🌕🖤

Tickets:
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/whispers-through-the-veil-an-interactive-spirit-communication-experience-tickets-2001789132181

Address

1 Depot Street
Washingtonville, NY
10992

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7:30am - 6pm
Thursday 7:30am - 6pm
Friday 7:30am - 6pm
Saturday 7:30am - 6pm
Sunday 7:30am - 3pm

Telephone

+18456140898

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes:

Shortcuts

Share

Category