That Batch. Bakery

03/05/2026

Our St. Paddy’s preorder is open! Place your orders before March 9, and before things sell out!

We have a couple special offerings like soda bread which we only offer once a year

Hello! My name is Margaret and I'm the owner and baker at That Batch Bakery which bakes out of Stoughton, WI. We specialize in our infamous brookie - shaped like a cookie but looks and tastes like a brownie. We stuff, bake, and top all brookies with more flavors and themes than you can count! We als...

02/27/2026

happy friday!! enjoy our latest addiction - asmr edition

volume waaaay up for this one!

it’s got chew, it’s got crisp, it’s a new product I’m testing coming this market season 😍

01/11/2026

Last day to preorder! Closes tomorrow, get your treats now, you never know what’ll be in the next one

Hello! My name is Margaret and I'm the owner and baker at That Batch Bakery which bakes out of Stoughton, WI. We specialize in our infamous brookie - shaped like a cookie but looks and tastes like a brownie. We stuff, bake, and top all brookies with more flavors and themes than you can count! We als...

01/08/2026

Link in our stories too but the preorder for next week is live! Make sure to get your order in before Monday when it closes

We thank everyone for your support and orders during this off-season from the farmer’s markets. It means a lot to have been able to grow this past market season and still continue to grow and offer you all treats throughout the year! So much growth just in two years a far.

When we have more interest fo Madison pick-ups we will expand past just Stoughton preorders. Let us know if that’s something you want!

Hello! My name is Margaret and I'm the owner and baker at That Batch Bakery which bakes out of Stoughton, WI. We specialize in our infamous brookie - shaped like a cookie but looks and tastes like a brownie. We stuff, bake, and top all brookies with more flavors and themes than you can count! We als...

12/15/2025

Get some amazing Christmas gifts before it’s too late!! We can attest to how deliciously addicting everything is 😂😍 perfect stocking stuffers too

12/15/2025

Don’t miss your opportunity to snag one of our last 2025 limited edition brookie ornaments! This year’s brookie is the Cosmic Brookie. Our original favorite. Won’t be available after this year! Collect them all with us each year 🎄DM us to buy one of the last ones!!

12/10/2025

Our first preorder with Hotplate is live!! Make sure to place your Christmas orders with us soon, limited quantities of everything available and limited time, preorders with Stoughton and Madison pick-up dates-times open until 12/14, 12pm!

All details and menu on the website, but basic info below!

Madison pick-up: Monday, Dec 22, 4-6pm
Edgewood High School parking lot, same as the Monroe Street Farmers Market

Stoughton pick-up: Tuesday, Dec 23, 4-6pm
Stoughton City Hall Parking Lot, same as the Stoughton Community Farmers' Market

Addresses on event pages

Stoughton pre-order link: https://www.hotplate.com/thatbatchbakery?referralType=reminder

Madison pre-order link: https://www.hotplate.com/thatbatchbakery?referralType=reminder

Make sure to sign up as a customer on our profile to stay notified of future preorders for 2026!

Thank you everyone for your support with this new adventure in our off-season from farmer’s markets!

Hello! My name is Margaret and I'm the owner and baker at That Batch Bakery which bakes out of Stoughton, WI. We specialize in our infamous brookie - shaped like a cookie but looks and tastes like a brownie. We stuff, bake, and top all brookies with more flavors and themes than you can count! We als...

11/29/2025

SHOP SMALL 💕 Come see us today at Shop Small Stoughton from 9am - 5pm, Chorus Public House on Main St in Stoughton. Lotssss of delicious treats for now or later and perfect gifts!

11/21/2025

The holidays are upon us! We would love to see you all and share some holiday sweets. Swipe to see our menu!

Where we’ll be,

Shop Small Stoughton
Saturday, November 29, 9am-5pm
Chorus Public House 154 W Main St, Stoughton, WI

Victorian Holiday Weekend Market
Saturday, December 6, 9am-5pm
Chorus Public House 154 W Main St, Stoughton, WI

**We will also be doing a Christmas pre-order stay tuned for details and sign up for our Hotplate page link in bio!**

All items freeze well! Stock up at the markets before we sell out, LIMITED QUANTITIES

Holiday snack mix:
•Homemade puppy chow
•Homemade chocolate covered peppermint bark pretzels

Assorted cookie boxes:
Medium & Large box sizes
•Almond Linzer Sandwich Cookies (Extra choc gingerbread sandwich cookies will be substituted for allergy concerns)
•Pizelles
•Mini crème wafer sandwich cookies
•Grandma’s famous fudge
•Chocolate gingerbread sandwich cookies
•Billionaire shortbread bars (brownie, shortbread, caramel, chocolate layers)
•Peanut butter blossom cookies (Festive chocolate chip cookies will be substituted for allergy concerns)

SEE YOU ALL IN A WEEK!

11/16/2025

We will be back at both of these markets! List of things we’re bringing up soon. Working on this year’s cookie boxes 🥰

09/08/2025

/ a moment for these jumbo pumpkin cream cheese muffies on the grid \

What is a muffie? Typically it’s the muffin top! Larger, wider, muffin top that’s more shallow than a muffin.

Why muffies and not a full muffin? imo they’re easier to eat. It’s a much larger surface space and since it’s more shallow you get everything in every single bite. No debating on eating the muffin top or bottom first anymore!

Come to the dark side, you’ll never look back 😉

These jumbo muffins + other fall flavors should be available just about every market until the end of the season! Hello Fall 🥰