Cutest Cookies

Cutest Cookies Cutest Cookies in SI, NY, custom cookie party favors made in a nut free bakery. We also offer children’s birthday parties and cookie decorating classes
(378)

Cutest Cookies in Staten Island, New York specializes in cookie design for all types of special events and celebrations! Cutest Cookies believes that your guests deserve the best, so why not give them a delicious and adorable treat? We make wonderful butter cookies fresh in our bakery. We use no preservatives or anything that contains peanuts. We only use the finest ingredients and can decorate co

okies to fit any theme. We are dedicated to helping our customers make their special occasion events even more memorable. You can chose from our many designs or request a custom one! They are perfect for holiday celebrations, graduations, birthdays, corporate gifts, thank yous, or well wishes. Place your order right away and we will make your cookies one or two days before your event. We encourage a two week pre-order. Each cookie is packaged in a cellophane bag and securely tied with matching ribbons to lock in freshness. We can’t wait to help you make your event perfect!

Dance Recital Bouquets are now available to order. All bouquets include 6 cookies, $30 each. Choose from Roses or Tutu &...
05/15/2026

Dance Recital Bouquets are now available to order. All bouquets include 6 cookies, $30 each. Choose from Roses or Tutu & Ballet shoes. The colors are able to be changed. Call Cutest Cookies to place your order or send private message. Advance notice is needed. All cookies are made fresh to order. All cookies are 100% Nut Free. 1300 Hylan Blvd. 718-966-2883

Cutest Cookies, custom cookie favors. We are open Monday to Friday 9:30-4:00. Hours vary on the weekends. Please call . ...
05/15/2026

Cutest Cookies, custom cookie favors. We are open Monday to Friday 9:30-4:00. Hours vary on the weekends. Please call . Check out our website for more designs and prices . Our 100% Nut Free bakery is located at 1300 Hylan Blvd 10305, right next to Cafe Luna. 718-966-2883. Plenty of parking in the front & rear of our store. Cutestcookies.com

Graduation Bouquets are also available to order. All bouquets include 6 cookies, $30 each. Call Cutest Cookies to place ...
05/11/2026

Graduation Bouquets are also available to order. All bouquets include 6 cookies, $30 each. Call Cutest Cookies to place your order or send private message. Advance notice is needed. Custom colors are available. All cookies are made fresh to order. All cookies are 100% Nut Free. 1300 Hylan Blvd. 718-966-2883

Cutest Cookies is now booking class trips for the remainder of the 2026 school year. Dates available for Spring, Mother’...
04/23/2026

Cutest Cookies is now booking class trips for the remainder of the 2026 school year. Dates available for Spring, Mother’s Day, Summer theme, Graduation. Please call the store or message me with dates that you are looking for. We can accommodate class trips at our bakery or with a larger group we can come to your school. We are a DOE approved vendor, PETS approved staff and everything we use is 100% Nut Free. We are located at 1300 Hylan Blvd. Plenty of room in our rear parking lot to accommodate school buses . 718-966-2883

Cutest Cookies Mother’s Day Cookie Gift Boxes Now Available to Order !🌼Box 3 is a 3 piece MOM set, $16 each, choose from...
04/18/2026

Cutest Cookies Mother’s Day Cookie Gift Boxes Now Available to Order !

🌼Box 3 is a 3 piece MOM set, $16 each, choose from white or pink flowers.

🌺To order please call Cutest Cookies at 718-966-2883 or stop by our shop located at 1300 Hylan Blvd 10305. You may also send a private message. Please include your name, phone number and date of pick up. The last day to pick up is Friday 5/8. We will be open 9:30-4:00

Cutest Cookies Mother’s Day Cookie Gift Boxes Now Available to Order !🌸Box 1 is a 3 piece flower pot, name can be change...
04/18/2026

Cutest Cookies Mother’s Day Cookie Gift Boxes Now Available to Order !

🌸Box 1 is a 3 piece flower pot, name can be changed , $14 each.

🌷Box 2 is a 6 piece tulip set, $25 each.

🌼Box 3 is a 3 piece MOM set, $16 each, choose from white or pink flowers.

🌺To order please call Cutest Cookies at 718-966-2883 or stop by our shop located at 1300 Hylan Blvd 10305. You may also send a private message. Please include your name, phone number and date of pick up. The last day to pick up is Friday 5/8. We will be open 9:30-4:00

Cutest Cookies Teacher Appreciation Cookie Gifts! Teacher Appreciation Week is May 4th-8th. Apple Gift Bag $13 each, inc...
04/18/2026

Cutest Cookies Teacher Appreciation Cookie Gifts! Teacher Appreciation Week is May 4th-8th. Apple Gift Bag $13 each, includes 6 small cookies, Cookie Cards $2.75 each, 3 piece Flower Box $14, Smart Cookie Box $6 each & 4 piece Pencil Box $16 each . To order please call us at 718-966-2883, send private message or come to our shop located at 1300 Hylan BIvd 10305 right next to Cafe Luna

A sweet “YES” deserves the cutest cookies 💍Celebrate your engagement with handcrafted treats from Cutest Cookies, made w...
04/14/2026

A sweet “YES” deserves the cutest cookies 💍

Celebrate your engagement with handcrafted treats from Cutest Cookies, made with love for your most special moments 💕

Cutest Cookies, custom cookie favors. We are open Monday to Friday 9:30-4:00. Hours vary on the weekends. Please call . Check out our website for more designs and prices . Our 100% Nut Free bakery is located at 1300 Hylan Blvd 10305, right next to Cafe Luna. 718-966-2883. Plenty of parking in the front & rear of our store. Cutestcookies.com

**NEW CLASS ADDED **Kids Cookie Decorating Mario Galaxy Themed. Tuesday, April 7th at 11:00 and Friday, April 10th at 11...
04/07/2026

**NEW CLASS ADDED **Kids Cookie Decorating Mario Galaxy Themed. Tuesday, April 7th at 11:00 and Friday, April 10th at 11:00. The cost is $20 per child to decorate 5 cookies. Class is about one hour. Good for ages 5 years old and up. Children must be able to work independently. Classes must be paid in advance. If you have any questions please call bakery at 718-966-2883, send private message or email [email protected]

Stop by our shop to see a large variety of our Communion Cookies. We are open Monday to Friday 9:30-4:00 and this Saturd...
04/06/2026

Stop by our shop to see a large variety of our Communion Cookies. We are open Monday to Friday 9:30-4:00 and this Saturday 4/18 we will be open 11:00-4:00. Check out our website for more designs and prices. Our 100% Nut Free bakery is located at 1300 Hylan Blvd 10305, right next to Cafe Luna. Plenty of parking in the front & rear of our store. Cutestcookies.com

Address

1300 Hylan Boulevard
Staten Island, NY
10305

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cutest Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cutest Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category