Clicky

Cakes By Coley

Cakes By Coley NEW Page as of Jan 2022! Same old Coley! Amazing Custom Creations for Every Occasion- est. 2009. Cakes By Coley has moved back to Staten Island!

Still offering delivery all over the tri-state area. Since 2009, we have remained one of the top custom dessert specialists throughout NY. Just ask our customers- our cakes are just as delicious to eat as they are beautiful to look at. Contact us today for your custom cake price quote and ordering information!

Operating as usual

3D Grooms Cake for a man who loves his YETI coolers!                       
07/08/2022

3D Grooms Cake for a man who loves his YETI coolers!

 

Wine theme 40th Birthday Cake!                      
06/14/2022

Wine theme 40th Birthday Cake!

 

Pastel Ice Cream Cake for a "Sweet One"                      
06/14/2022

Pastel Ice Cream Cake for a "Sweet One"
 

Mr. One-Derful 1st Birthday Cake for Matteo
06/14/2022

Mr. One-Derful 1st Birthday Cake for Matteo

🎵🎶Choooo choooo 🚂 Soul Train Birthday Cake 🎵🎶                       
06/14/2022

🎵🎶Choooo choooo 🚂 Soul Train Birthday Cake 🎵🎶

 

It's not Monday but it sure was difficult getting up for work today... So I felt this was the appropriate cake to post  ...
05/31/2022

It's not Monday but it sure was difficult getting up for work today... So I felt this was the appropriate cake to post

 

Another one from some years back..                      
05/25/2022

Another one from some years back..

 

💲💨
05/25/2022

💲💨

Made this cake probably closer to 10 years ago but it never gets old                      
05/25/2022

Made this cake probably closer to 10 years ago but it never gets old

 

Hungry Caterpillar 🐛
05/25/2022

Hungry Caterpillar 🐛

In Memoriam Cake 🙏
05/25/2022

In Memoriam Cake 🙏

Tequila themed 30th Birthday Cake with lots of hand painted detail 😰                      
04/04/2022

Tequila themed 30th Birthday Cake with lots of hand painted detail 😰

 

Colorful Pop-It Cake for JaMir. All handmade and edible!
04/04/2022

Colorful Pop-It Cake for JaMir. All handmade and edible!

Tasting Boxes are now available! Choose 6 flavors you would like to sample. $25, for pickup only from our Staten Island ...
04/04/2022

Tasting Boxes are now available! Choose 6 flavors you would like to sample. $25, for pickup only from our Staten Island location! Contact Us today to order yours!

2 tier Mermaid Cake for Skylar                      
03/25/2022

2 tier Mermaid Cake for Skylar

 

2 tier White Cake with Burgundy Flowers 😍
03/25/2022

2 tier White Cake with Burgundy Flowers 😍

2 tier Circus Cake for a 1st Birthday
03/25/2022

2 tier Circus Cake for a 1st Birthday

Winter's One-derland ❄️
03/18/2022

Winter's One-derland ❄️

Beautiful Mermaid Cake for Tori's 5th Birthday                       
03/18/2022

Beautiful Mermaid Cake for Tori's 5th Birthday
 

When someone requests their grandma on her birthday cake holding a pot of pasta, you oblige!
03/18/2022

When someone requests their grandma on her birthday cake holding a pot of pasta, you oblige!

Pink Rosettes and Butterflies for Maya 💕
03/18/2022

Pink Rosettes and Butterflies for Maya 💕

Basketball Cake for Geo!
03/18/2022

Basketball Cake for Geo!

4 tier Under The Sea Sweet 16 Cake
03/18/2022

4 tier Under The Sea Sweet 16 Cake

Vanilla and Strawberry 🤤
03/14/2022

Vanilla and Strawberry 🤤

Anniversary Cake with Rose Gold Chocolate Strawberries                       
03/05/2022

Anniversary Cake with Rose Gold Chocolate Strawberries

 

Purple Ombre Rosette Cake 🦋                      
03/05/2022

Purple Ombre Rosette Cake 🦋

 

Cream, Burgundy & Gold Engagement Cake                      
03/05/2022

Cream, Burgundy & Gold Engagement Cake
 

Khalil's Amazing Under-the-Sea Cake                      
03/05/2022

Khalil's Amazing Under-the-Sea Cake

 

Mermaid theme Baby Shower Cake with glittery and gold details                      
03/05/2022

Mermaid theme Baby Shower Cake with glittery and gold details

 

What's The Scoop? Gender Reveal Cake                       
03/05/2022

What's The Scoop? Gender Reveal Cake

 

"Belle" inspired cake with a handmade tiara                      
03/02/2022

"Belle" inspired cake with a handmade tiara

 

Sweet buttercream florals for a Sweet 16 Cake                       
03/02/2022

Sweet buttercream florals for a Sweet 16 Cake

 

This was our take on a Pink Cake Box design for a baseball themed Baby Shower                      
03/02/2022

This was our take on a Pink Cake Box design for a baseball themed Baby Shower

 

"Love you more than meatloaf" cake 😆 Everything was handmade from sugar/ gumpaste/ icing/ fondant, even the ketchup was ...
03/02/2022

"Love you more than meatloaf" cake 😆 Everything was handmade from sugar/ gumpaste/ icing/ fondant, even the ketchup was a sweet sugar concoction

 

Wonderland Inspired 🐱☕⏱️🍶🍪
03/02/2022

Wonderland Inspired 🐱☕⏱️🍶🍪

White, Gold & Black for a 60th Birthday
03/02/2022

White, Gold & Black for a 60th Birthday

03/01/2022

Hello! It's me, Nicole A.K.A. Coley. I am still here!
Unfortunately, someone hacked my old Facebook account and though I tried so hard to fix it, I no longer have access to my Cakes by Coley Business Page. I lost so many photos and posts and friends.
This will be the account that I will be using going forward, and I am hoping I am able to get back all 30K of my Followers from my old business Page, plus more!
Please like and share!
Thanks for your support through all these years!

Address

New York, NY

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cakes By Coley posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cakes By Coley:

Category

Nearby bakeries


x

Other Bakeries in New York (show all)

Jackie's Cake Boutique Custom Cakes Baked with Love by Nicole A Cherry On Top Specialty Cakes Gimme Sum Suga Brooklyn Bread Guy, Inc Marinas bakery I Crave Sweets Camay's Cakes Buono Bakery Menosh Gourmet & Bakery Cutest Cookies Royal Crown Bakery Cafe at Sam's Bakery Paneantico Bakery Cafe Inc Beansie Cakes