04/27/2026
Hi 👋🏻 I’m Nicole, the baker behind Fairy Godmother Baking Co.
Baking has always been a big passion of mine, and it all really started with me bringing dessert to every single family function. Over time, with so much encouragement from my family, those desserts turned into this little dream business.
I actually struggled for a while trying to choose the perfect name. Then on Christmas morning 2018, everything fell into place when my sister Megan asked me to be Godmother to her daughter and gifted me aprons that read “Fairy Godmother Baking Co.” It felt like pure magic, and that’s how it all began 🤍
What started as a tiny home operation has grown into weekly farmers markets filled with cinnamon roasted nuts, award winning cookies, small batch peanut butter, and fresh bread.
None of this would happen without my amazing team: my husband Josh handling markets, deliveries, and all the behind the scenes hustle. My dad Joe and cousin Rick who show up week after week to help us with the markets. We truly couldn’t do it without them. And of course my goddaughter Payton, the heart of our name and our peanut butter’s #1 fan 💫
If you spot us at the markets, please come say hi! We’re always so happy to meet you and share a sample ✨