Selah Cookie Co.

Selah Cookie Co. Ottumwa based custom sugar decorated cookies, drop cookies, and sugar cookie decorating classes.

After a long little social media nap, Selah Cookie Co. is back in the kitchen 😅🍪These cozy cuties were made for the wond...
01/30/2026

After a long little social media nap, Selah Cookie Co. is back in the kitchen 😅🍪

These cozy cuties were made for the wonderful ladies of CATS — Cranking Adorable Treasured Socks 🧦💖 A whole group of creative women who meet up with their crank knitting machines and turn yarn into warm, beautiful socks every month. Honestly, goals.

So naturally this set had to be full of cats, yarn, and maximum cozy energy 🐈🧶✨ Each cookie is hand decorated with lots of love and just a tiny bit of “don’t drop the icing bag” adrenaline.

So grateful I get to make sweet treats for such a fun and talented group of ladies 💕
And if you’re still here after my accidental social media disappearance… you’re the real MVP 🥹🍪

🧡 Hope everyone has had a good Thanksgiving! Stay safe and warm this weekend!
11/27/2025

🧡 Hope everyone has had a good Thanksgiving! Stay safe and warm this weekend!

Join us tomorrow at Life Church for our Fall Festival! We’ll have yard games, a bake sale (you’ll find some things I’ve ...
10/11/2025

Join us tomorrow at Life Church for our Fall Festival! We’ll have yard games, a bake sale (you’ll find some things I’ve made there!), cocoa, cider, pumpkin painting, photo ops, and so much more!

Did you know that July 9 is National Sugar Cookie Day?! Now you do! Thank you all for supporting me and letting me be pa...
07/09/2025

Did you know that July 9 is National Sugar Cookie Day?! Now you do! Thank you all for supporting me and letting me be part of your lives 🥰

Happy 4th of July, friends! I hope you all have a safe and fun holiday! ❤️🤍💙
07/04/2025

Happy 4th of July, friends! I hope you all have a safe and fun holiday! ❤️🤍💙

I think I’m gonna need a bigger car…! 😅 I’m almost ready for the Ottumwa Community Market tomorrow! I’ll be there 8-2 wi...
06/27/2025

I think I’m gonna need a bigger car…! 😅 I’m almost ready for the Ottumwa Community Market tomorrow! I’ll be there 8-2 with sugar cookies, drop cookies, some rhubarb sweet rolls, and some rhubarb crisps. Come by and say hello!

🤶🏻 Who else is over this heat and ready for some jingle bells and holiday baking? 🖐🏻🖐🏻🖐🏻
06/26/2025

🤶🏻 Who else is over this heat and ready for some jingle bells and holiday baking? 🖐🏻🖐🏻🖐🏻

🐈 I hope you’ve all had an a-meow-zing weekend despite the heat!🍪 I’ll be in the kitchen this week, baking up lots of yu...
06/22/2025

🐈 I hope you’ve all had an a-meow-zing weekend despite the heat!
🍪 I’ll be in the kitchen this week, baking up lots of yummy things to bring to the Ottumwa Community Market this Saturday. I hope to see you there!

Hey cookie fans 🍪💕 I dropped off my application this morning for the Ottumwa Community Market! 🎉 I’ll be there Saturday,...
06/18/2025

Hey cookie fans 🍪💕 I dropped off my application this morning for the Ottumwa Community Market! 🎉 I’ll be there Saturday, June 28 from 8–2 at St. Paul Lutheran Church ⛪️ Rain or shine! ☔️☀️

Some of what I’m planning to bring:
🍓 Rhubarb rolls with strawberry icing
🌴 Dubai bar drop cookies
🎨 Paint-your-own sugar cookies

What else should I bake for you? Drop your ideas below and come say hi! 🥰👩‍🍳

✨Groovy cookie vibes coming in HOT!✨I’m planning an upcoming decorating class and would love your input! 🎨Which color sc...
06/15/2025

✨Groovy cookie vibes coming in HOT!✨
I’m planning an upcoming decorating class and would love your input! 🎨

Which color scheme would be the most fun to decorate? And would you prefer to come Thursday, July 3 or Saturday, July 5?

🕔 Class will run from 5–6:30pm
💰 $30 per person
👯‍♀️ Space is limited to 6 people per class — but I’m open to adding more dates/times if there’s enough genuine interest!

Drop your picks below — I can’t wait to decorate with you! 🌼🚌☮️😊✌️

👀 Me in June, fully buried in Father’s Day prep, market hustle, a groovy cookie class, and red-white-&-blue vibes 🇺🇸… bu...
06/12/2025

👀 Me in June, fully buried in Father’s Day prep, market hustle, a groovy cookie class, and red-white-&-blue vibes 🇺🇸… but Spooky Season cookies be lookin’ kinda cute already 🎃👻💀

✌🏻 While cutting out Father’s Day cookies, I also cut out some cookies to make samples for an upcoming class!🧡 Does Satu...
06/09/2025

✌🏻 While cutting out Father’s Day cookies, I also cut out some cookies to make samples for an upcoming class!
🧡 Does Saturday, July 5 sound like a good day for class?
🩷 If so, what timeframe?
💛 If not July 5, what date might work better?
😎 I’m open to all input!

Address

Ottumwa, IA
52501

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 2:15pm
Tuesday 9am - 2:15pm
Wednesday 9am - 2:15pm
Thursday 9am - 2:15pm
Friday 9am - 2:15pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Selah Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category