Fingerhut Bakery

Fingerhut Bakery We are a Family owned bakery since 1946, currently run by brothers Doug and Greg Fingerhut. Stop by to get delicious donuts, cookies, and specialty cakes!
(368)

Butter Cream challenge!!! Do you think you can eat all of this Butter Cream?
06/17/2026

Butter Cream challenge!!! Do you think you can eat all of this Butter Cream?

06/16/2026
06/15/2026

Unfortunately some dough was harmed in the making of this film

Apple Fritter vs Pretzel. Who wins?
06/13/2026

Apple Fritter vs Pretzel. Who wins?

We want to give a huge shoutout to Melinda and Stephanie!We had a massive influx of cake orders this weekend, and these ...
06/13/2026

We want to give a huge shoutout to Melinda and Stephanie!

We had a massive influx of cake orders this weekend, and these two rose to the challenge. Their hard work, dedication, and attention to detail are a big part of what makes Fingerhut Bakery a community favorite.

Every cake that leaves our bakery is made with care, and this weekend was no exception. Everyone receiving one of their cakes will be able to see the love, pride, and craftsmanship that went into it.

Thank you, Melinda and Stephanie, for all of your hard work. We appreciate everything you do for Fingerhut Bakery and our customers! ❤️

Todays mystery donut is Banana!Left - Bananas Foster (Vanilla Bean Buttercream)Middle - Glazed BananaRight - Glazed Bana...
06/12/2026

Todays mystery donut is Banana!
Left - Bananas Foster (Vanilla Bean Buttercream)
Middle - Glazed Banana
Right - Glazed Banana with Brown Sugar Top

Everyone favorite donut 🍩
06/11/2026

Everyone favorite donut 🍩

Love at first sight 😍 🍩
06/10/2026

Love at first sight 😍 🍩

06/09/2026

Protein Puffs!
4 puffs = 10 grams of protein.
4 puffs for $3.
At both North Judson and Knox locations.

Address

119 Lane St
North Judson, IN
46366

Opening Hours

Monday 5am - 5pm
Tuesday 5am - 5pm
Wednesday 5am - 5pm
Thursday 5am - 5pm
Friday 5am - 5pm
Saturday 6am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fingerhut Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fingerhut Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share