Missy Mae Bakery

Missy Mae Bakery Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Missy Mae Bakery, Bakery, Mount Gilead, OH.

📍 Mount Gilead, OH
Serving Morrow County & surrounding areas

🍪 Custom Cutout Cookies • Drop Cookies • Cookie Classes • Seasonal Surprises

💻 Custom Quotes here ⬇️
https://missymaebakery.square.site

✝️ Cookier for Christ • Psalms 46:10

Pumpkin has officially entered the chat. 😂🎃We gave fall a little test run at the last market & you guys made it pretty c...
09/02/2026

Pumpkin has officially entered the chat. 😂🎃

We gave fall a little test run at the last market & you guys made it pretty clear you were ready for the gourds!

So this Saturday, I’m bringing more Pumpkin Snickerdoodles & Pumpkin Bars back to the table!

-Plus- Pumpkin Spice Pancake Mix makes its seasonal return!

[pro tip: add some white chocolate chips to the batter & scoop into muffin tins for the best breakfast treat!]

See you Saturday at the Mount Gilead- Farmers Market! 🩷🍪

Can’t wait!!
09/01/2026

Can’t wait!!

I’m dreaming up some fall Market Boxes and I wanna know what •YOU• would put in one!Your choices:🍪 Chocolate Chip🥜 Bucke...
08/31/2026

I’m dreaming up some fall Market Boxes and I wanna know what •YOU• would put in one!

Your choices:

🍪 Chocolate Chip
🥜 Buckeye
🎃 Pumpkin Snickerdoodle
🤎 Cinnamon Roll
🍎 Apple Crisp

You can only pick THREE.

What’s going in your box? ⬇️

The message every baker hopes to get after pickup. 🥹🩷This never gets old. Thank you for trusting me with your special mo...
08/26/2026

The message every baker hopes to get after pickup. 🥹🩷

This never gets old. Thank you for trusting me with your special moments! 🍪

I guess you guys were ready for pumpkin, too! 😂🎃Thank you to everyone who stopped by Saturday, grabbed some cookies, tri...
08/25/2026

I guess you guys were ready for pumpkin, too! 😂🎃

Thank you to everyone who stopped by Saturday, grabbed some cookies, tried something new, or just came over to say hi!

The Pumpkin Bars and new Pumpkin Snickerdoodles got so much love! I’m so thankful for another beautiful morning on the Square. 🩷🍪

Good morning from the Square! ☀️🍪🎃I’m all set up at the Mount Gilead- Farmers Market and the Peek at Pumpkin Market Boxe...
08/22/2026

Good morning from the Square! ☀️🍪🎃

I’m all set up at the Mount Gilead- Farmers Market and the Peek at Pumpkin Market Boxes are ready!

Come say hi & grab yours before they’re gone. 🥰

Tomorrow! 👀🎃🍪Peek at Pumpkin Market Boxes: 🍪 Chocolate Chip 🥜 Buckeye 🎃 Pumpkin Snickerdoodle [new!]~ Plus ~...
08/21/2026

Tomorrow! 👀🎃🍪

Peek at Pumpkin Market Boxes:
🍪 Chocolate Chip
🥜 Buckeye
🎃 Pumpkin Snickerdoodle [new!]

~ Plus ~ Pumpkin Bars! 🙌

Quantities are limited, so come early if you’ve got your eye on one!

See you tomorrow morning at the Mount Gilead- Farmers Market! 🩷

Just a cool Hot Wheels-inspired set for a car obsessed little guy! 🏎️🔥 Happy 4th birthday, LJ! 🎈
08/19/2026

Just a cool Hot Wheels-inspired set for a car obsessed little guy! 🏎️🔥

Happy 4th birthday, LJ! 🎈

Just a little Peek at Pumpkin 👀🎃The Missy Mae Market Boxes are getting their first little taste of fall!🍪 Chocolate Chip...
08/18/2026

Just a little Peek at Pumpkin 👀🎃

The Missy Mae Market Boxes are getting their first little taste of fall!

🍪 Chocolate Chip
🥜 Buckeye
🎃 NEW Pumpkin Snickerdoodle

6 cookies • $20

PLUS the Pumpkin Bars are officially making their return! 🙌

Quantities are limited & you guys have been showing these Market Boxes some serious love lately. If you’ve got your eye on one, I wouldn’t wait until the end of the market.

Come find me Saturday morning at the Mount Gilead- Farmers Market and grab yours!

My full time job has been a little *extra* full time lately 😅 and that means my response time for bakery messages & emai...
08/17/2026

My full time job has been a little *extra* full time lately 😅 and that means my response time for bakery messages & emails has gotten a little longer than usual.

I’m all caught up now 🙌 but going forward, please know it may take me a few days to get back to you. I promise I’m not ignoring you - I’m just juggling all the hats over here! 😂

Thank you for being patient with me and continuing to support this little bakery. 🩷

Now back to market prep because pumpkin might be making an appearance this week.
👀🎃

Ps. If you haven’t received a response from me - please check your spam folder or shoot me a message 😘

Address

Mount Gilead, OH

Telephone

+14196183250

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Missy Mae Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Missy Mae Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category