Missy Mae Bakery

Missy Mae Bakery Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Missy Mae Bakery, Bakery, Mount Gilead, OH.

📍 Mount Gilead, OH
Serving Morrow County & surrounding areas

🍪 Custom Cutout Cookies • Drop Cookies • Cookie Classes • Seasonal Surprises

💻 Custom Quotes here ⬇️
https://missymaebakery.square.site

✝️ Cookier for Christ • Psalms 46:10

05/27/2026

POV: your 9 to 5 ends and your second shift begins 😅🍪

This week is a whole lotta:
💻 banking by day
🍪 baking by night
📦 labeling cookies at questionable hours
☕ surviving on caffeine & chaos

Which can only mean…

Farmers market season is HERE, baby! ☀️

One of my favorite things about baking in a small town is seeing familiar faces everywhere ❤️At markets.At school events...
05/25/2026

One of my favorite things about baking in a small town is seeing familiar faces everywhere ❤️

At markets.
At school events.
At birthday parties.
At the grocery store.

Somewhere along the way, Missy Mae became more than just cookies to me. It’s market mornings, small town conversations & getting to be a tiny part of your celebrations 🫶

This summer, I’m leaning even more into seasonal treats, rotating flavors, local events & baking from the heart.

Thank you for being here, friends!

I love custom orders but I am SO excited to just bake & test out new recipes this summer! 👩🏻‍🍳😍
05/22/2026

I love custom orders but I am SO excited to just bake & test out new recipes this summer! 👩🏻‍🍳😍

You guys! I’m so excited for this year’s farmers market season 🥹☀️Early mornings, coffee walks around the square, local ...
05/20/2026

You guys! I’m so excited for this year’s farmers market season 🥹☀️

Early mornings, coffee walks around the square, local vendors, kids running around, seeing familiar faces every other Saturday - THIS is the small town living that I LOVE ❤️

The Mount Gilead- Farmers Market kickoff is NEXT WEEKEND and I’m already planning all the “sweet” details!

I’ll have fan favorites 🍪, rotating flavors 🍓, decorated cutouts & maybe a few market-exclusive goodies mixed in this summer 👀

I can’t wait for this season to start 🫶

This beautiful set was created for a mama-to-be who is so special to us: Mason’s very first babysitter 🩷During COVID, Ca...
05/18/2026

This beautiful set was created for a mama-to-be who is so special to us: Mason’s very first babysitter 🩷

During COVID, Carey & I were both working from home full time, daycares were closed, and Mason was rolling under my desk while I was on conference calls 🫠 We needed help!

“Sosie” (as Mason called her 🥰) to the rescue!

Watching Sosie become a mom now is such a full circle moment. Congrats to Sophia & Brendan on the very best adventure in life. What a gift from God 💕

EDIT: sorry, changed my mind! We’re on our way to an early Mother’s Day dinner & I’m going to gift these to the mamas wh...
05/10/2026

EDIT: sorry, changed my mind! We’re on our way to an early Mother’s Day dinner & I’m going to gift these to the mamas who are working at the restaurant instead 🩷

***************

Need a last minute Mothers Day gift?! I got you!

🪿 Mother Goose gift set - 1 left!
🥤 Mom Fuel gift set - 3 left!

$12 each! Shoot me a message to claim!

Porch pick up in Mount Gilead!

05/10/2026
This week threw me for a LOOP so I didn’t get to bake every thing I originally had planned for today’s Mother’s Day Mark...
05/09/2026

This week threw me for a LOOP so I didn’t get to bake every thing I originally had planned for today’s Mother’s Day Market at Cote Winery.

BUT - I’m here, I have drop cookies (including a new s’mores recipe!) and the most adorable gifts for Mom (or your bestie! Or yourself … because we don’t judge 😉).

Come spend the day with us at Cote Winery from 12p-6p 💐🍷

Wine slushies are back for the season, there are tons of great local vendors, and the weather is absolutely gorgeous! ☀️

See you soon, friends ❤️

Thank you to everyone who prayed, shared, checked in, and cared this week. My cousin was found safe last night and our f...
05/08/2026

Thank you to everyone who prayed, shared, checked in, and cared this week. My cousin was found safe last night and our family is incredibly grateful 🩷

It’s been an emotional few days, and I’m still playing a bit of catch up behind the scenes over here at Missy Mae, but I just wanted to say thank you. Your kindness means more than you know.

Hug your people extra tight today 🩷

Teacher Appreciation Week is here ✏️ & I’ll be working on a special drop just for the teachers at my son’s school later ...
05/04/2026

Teacher Appreciation Week is here ✏️ & I’ll be working on a special drop just for the teachers at my son’s school later this week.

Teachers do SO much & they definitely deserve it!

If you’ve got a teacher, aide, bus driver, or school staff member you love, don’t forget to show them a little extra appreciation this week too 🫶

❤️🤍💙🤩🇺🇸
05/03/2026

❤️🤍💙🤩🇺🇸

Address

Mount Gilead, OH

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Missy Mae Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Missy Mae Bakery:

Share

Category