What are the opening hours?

Friday 2pm - 7:30pm Saturday 12pm - 7:30pm Sunday 12pm - 5:30pm

Sticky Fingers Delectables

Home
United States
Bethel, NY
Sticky Fingers Delectables

Directions Website

Welcome to Sticky Fingers Delectables 2026!! We are thrilled that you are coming to see us!

10/17/2026

People keep coming into the shop to say, "We've heard all about your soups from our friends ... What's cookin' today?"

This weekend (to help you cope with the suddenly Novemberish change in weather) I've hit the lentils, hard! We have three fabulous lentil stews in stock (plus all the other meat-based soups on our menu). Each stew is utterly distinctive and unique in its own way.

Umbrian Lentil Stew: This stew is something of the 'house stew' at Sticky Fingers Delectables. First we develop a thick broth using caramelized onions and celery with tomatoes. The copious use of fresh rosemary is what pushes this stew over the top. Get a couple sides of Beach Lake Dinner rolls and butter 'em up then sit down to one of Sullivan County's best soups ...

Laughing Buddha Mulligatawny Stew: This South Asian recipe begins its evolution as a fragrant pureed mash of onions, garlic, curry, and ginger. Red lentils are added to the mash in a big heavy pot with hot coconut oil at its base. The mash covers and sticks to the lentils before they even begin to take on liquid. Each little lentil now becomes a 'flavor ambassador' of the original mash. Then bite-sized cubes of butternut squash get tossed into the stew, which adds to its 'beefiness.' The result is absolutely fabulous--come and see!

Lemony Lebanese Lentil Stew: This intensely aromatic stew is the densest of all three stews we are making this weekend at Sticky Fingers. For the latest batch I was unable to locate any fresh chard in neighborhood vegetable stands so I substituted fresh spinach and mustard greens instead. Do you like Middle Eastern food? Well, then, Friends .... Next stop: Sticky Fingers!

Shop is open today for soups and ice creams 12:00 - 7:00 pm
Sunday, October 18th: 12:00 - 6:30 pm

10/12/2026

Dear Friends! In spite of the rainy weather yesterday, things were pretty busy at Sticky Fingers Delectables--so busy, in fact, that I've had to come in to try and replenish some of our soups which were almost completely sold out by business close on Sunday. So today we have Butternut Squash Soup and our Rosemary Umbrian Lentil Stew for purchase. Listen: with a buttery Beach Lake Bakery dinner roll (or two!), a perfect dinner awaits you later today without you having to lift a finger or mess up some pots and pans! Sticky Fingers is open today until 6:30 PM or even a smidgen later if foot traffic warrants. Ice cream is, of course, as always ALWAYS in stock. Thank you and Be Well!

10/11/2026

Hello Friends! It has come to my attention that our White Chicken Chili was prepared this week with some incompletely cooked beans ... which might cause someone consuming the soup some rumbling & tumbling "down under." Please bring any White Chicken Chili you purchased back in for an exchange or refund or give me (James) a call at 845.475.8900 if that isn't possible. Our sincere apologies for any inconvenience. We are open both Sunday and Monday starting at noon. Thank you!

10/10/2026

Over at Sticky Fingers Delectables we've been busy preparing scrumptious soups and stews for you this long weekend--please see the above Weekender Menu! Our White Chicken Chili (with sumptuous white cheese sauce) was made on Friday morning and the Turkish Cabbage Roll Stew (a hot customer fave) Friday evening last. I'm in the shop early Saturday getting our goopy Butternut Squash Soup ready--it generally sells off faster than any other kind of vegetarian or vegan soup that we make. Don't hesitate if you have had it before and love it--beetle on over Saturday to scoop some up before it sells out. And for dessert? Of course we have lots and lots of delicious ice cream.

We'll be open all three days of the long weekend:
Saturday from 12:00 - 7:30 PM
Sunday from 12:00 - 7:30 PM
Monday from 1:00 - 6:00 PM.

10/03/2026

Last week a customer came in and pointed out that I hadn't made any chicken-based soup or stew yet this season. So today, I've cooked up a big batch of a customer all-time fave: Nova Scotian Chicken Mulligatawny! Many of you who have tasted it in the past swear it is one of the best soups you have ever had. It is (I grant you) pretty ravishing: the tender poached chicken nuggets, the creamy curry sauce, the delightfully tart, bite-sized cubes of Golden Delicious apples, the fragrant basmati rice all go together so well. My goodness, it's so good I have sometimes had it for breakfast! -- Never had it? Well then, Folks, it's time. It's truly, truly TIME.

Bustle on over for our other soups, too--perfect for freezing or a delicious lunch or dinner. And, of course, we still have LOTS of ice creams for dessert. See you soon, and thank you!

09/27/2026

What-oh-what's for your lunch (or dinner) this wind-swept day? Sticky Fingers Delectables may just have the answer. The past few days we have been fairly swamped with people returning for MORE of our delicious "Vegan Pumpkin Curried Lentil Stew." This morning I got up early to whip up another 18 quart batch of it. Many of you know its powers: it'll raise your spirits and drive away all symptoms of drearyness or boredom! Hurry on over today before 6:30 PM or it will sell out under your very nose. On the shelves we also have French Canadian Split Pea Soup (with pork), Butternut Squash Soup (vegan), Curried Corn Chowder (vegan), and our #1 rated soup: Classic Beef Chili. Plus about 20 ice creams for dessert ...

09/26/2026

Behold, our Weekender Menu! Please note that some of these soups sell out extremely quickly; I will attempt to restock them as quickly as possible. We are open 12 pm - 7:30 pm today (Saturday), and 12 pm - 5:30 pm on Sunday. (In the event of seriously inclement weather, please call ahead). See you soon!

09/19/2026

What's Cookin' Tonight, Bethel? Over at Sticky Fingers Delectables, the SoupySoup Season has begun, and to kick things off I've made up four scrumptious soups that will grace any dinner or lunch. Please see below! More soups and stews to come as the weather cools down PLUS Sullivan County's very best ice creams and sorbets, too. See you soon!

Curried Pumpkin Lentil Soup (Vegan)
(Green Lentils, Onions, Garlic, Pumpkin, Ginger, Vegetable Stock, Coconut Milk, Curry)

Classic Beef Chili
(Beef, Vegetable Stock, Onions, Garlic, Green & Jalapeno Peppers, Cumin, Chili powder, Secret Ingredient #1)

French Bistro Cabbage Soup with Caraway Seed
(Cabbage, Chicken Stock, Onions, Leeks, Carrots, Garlic, Potatoes)

Butternut Squash Soup (Vegan)
(Butternut Squash, Vegetable Stock, Onions, Rosemary, Sage, Ginger)

09/07/2026

Thank you, Everyone, for a wonderful and adventurous summer! Many businesses are closed today--but STICKY FINGERS DELECTABLES is open from 1:00 - 7:00 PM. Swing on by and let your taste buds dance with Sullivan County's very best ice creams and sorbets. --

08/27/2026

This coming Sunday, August 30th my friend and New York actor extraordinaire Joe Forbrich will be doing a live read of his new play, "Water Always Wins" at the Club at Smallwood! Joe is an absolute gem, an astounding talent and unique creative. He is also one heck of a carpenter (I can highly recommend his services). Please come out and attend what promises to be a great evening in Smallwood, New York!

Address

10 Horseshoe Lake Road
Bethel, NY
12749

Opening Hours

Friday	2pm - 7:30pm
Saturday	12pm - 7:30pm
Sunday	12pm - 5:30pm

Website

https://stickyfingersicecreamsanddelec.godaddysites.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sticky Fingers Delectables posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Bethel?