My Sugar Pie

My Sugar Pie My Sugar Pie sells homemade pies sold whole and by the slice. We also offer tea, coffee, soft drinks, ice cream, and kitchen goods.

06/04/2026

S’more Pie is Back! Order for pickup!
🍫🔥

05/30/2026

Slicing up Sugar Cream Pies for your Saturday Morning! Find slices at the pie shop in Zionsville or the Carmel Farmers Market!

Hoosier Sugar Cream Slices ready for pick up at Zionsville and at Carmel Farmers Market!
05/30/2026

Hoosier Sugar Cream Slices ready for pick up at Zionsville and at Carmel Farmers Market!

05/29/2026

Let’s Roll Pinwheels! Everything at My Sugar Pie is Handmade!

Sweet Strawberry Shortcake with Fresh Whipped Cream! shortcake 🍓 🍓🍓🍓
05/29/2026

Sweet Strawberry Shortcake with Fresh Whipped Cream! shortcake 🍓 🍓🍓🍓

Thanks again to Fox and Friends in the Morning for featuring My Sugar Pie along with our new friends from C.R. Heroes Re...
05/26/2026

Thanks again to Fox and Friends in the Morning for featuring My Sugar Pie along with our new friends from C.R. Heroes Restaurant and Market Square Popcorn! Also Lieutenant Governor Micah Beckwith! &Friends

Remembering the Fallen Heroes, Great Americans. Thank you!
05/25/2026

Remembering the Fallen Heroes, Great Americans. Thank you!

My Sugar Pie is at the track and ready for Fox and Friends!
05/23/2026

My Sugar Pie is at the track and ready for Fox and Friends!

05/22/2026

Dessert Champion! Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie!

05/27/2020

5/27 slice selection: apple, blueberry, cherry, mixed berry, strawberry rhubarb, sugar cream, coconut, lemon, peanut butter, and key lime!!

Join us for an afternoon of fun in Greenwood at one of our afternoon tea events on Sunday, February 16th and 23rd. We ha...
01/27/2020

Join us for an afternoon of fun in Greenwood at one of our afternoon tea events on Sunday, February 16th and 23rd. We have tables available from 3-4 and 4-5 on each date. This event will feature finger sandwiches, pinwheels, tea, and a variety of other brunch favorites for the low cost of $20. Reserve your seat in store or give us a call at 317-893-5355 as spots are limited. See you there!

Address

Greenwood Park Mall, 1251 US Highway 31N
Greenwood, IN
46142

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 12pm - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sugar Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category