What are the opening hours?

Tuesday 10am - 8pm Wednesday 10am - 8pm Thursday 10am - 8pm Friday 10am - 8pm Saturday 10am - 8pm Sunday 12pm - 6pm

My Sugar Pie

Directions Website

My Sugar Pie sells homemade pies sold whole and by the slice. We also offer tea, coffee, soft drinks, ice cream, and kitchen goods.

11/03/2026

Sorry we SOLD OUT for Wednesday before Thanksgiving! Pick Tuesday or Thursday Thanksgiving Day at www.mysugarpie.com!

11/03/2026

Pick up a Sweet Slice of Indiana!

10/24/2026

Hey Pie Peeps! Can’t find the calendar button on our website for ordering your Thanksgiving Pies??? See the pink calendar button. Click it and it will open up the November dates that you need. www.mysugarpie.com
Btw Wednesday is closed for orders. Pick Tuesday or Thursday
#2026 #𝘖𝘳𝘥𝘦𝘳𝙊𝙣𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙚𝘕𝘰𝘸

10/23/2026

Dutch Apple, Dutch Cherry, Dutch Peach Blueberry…pies…yummy.

10/20/2026

Thanksgiving Pie Menu

Dutch Apple
Apple Lattice
Dutch Cherry
Cherry Lattice
Hoosier Sugar Cream
Pecan
Pumpkin

Don't see your favorite fruit flavor? Pick it up and freeze before Thanksgiving Week.

Pie Pick up Schedule for Thanksgiving Week:

Sunday, November 22nd, 12-4pm
Monday, November 23rd, 12-4pm
Tuesday, November 24th, 12-4pm Wednesday, November 25th, 12-4pm
Thanksgiving, Thursday, November 26th, 11am-1pm

Order Online on our website mysugarpie.com (http://www.mysugarpie.com) !

Click here for an update from My Sugar Pie!

10/14/2026

Thanksgiving Pie Menu: Dutch Apple, Apple Lattice, Dutch Cherry, Cherry Lattice, Pecan, Pumpkin and Hoosier Sugar Cream pies! Pick your family favorites and Order tomorrow, October 15th on our website www.mysugarpie.com!

10/12/2026

Thank you Indy Star! Mom’s Original Dutch Apple is definitely a year-round winner!

There might be nothing more American than this originally European dish. Good thing it tastes so nice at My Sugar Pie. See link below ⬇️

📸 Provided photo

10/09/2026

Call to order your Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Pie! 🎃 🎃

10/09/2026

October is your last chance to try our Delicious Apple Dumplings! An entire apple baked with cinnamon, sugar, and butter wrapped in my Mom’s crust!
🔥

10/09/2026

3 Slices for $18 Slice Special! Chippy Pumpkin, Pumpkin, Pumpkin Praline, Dutch Apple, Pecan, My Kentucky Pie, Blueberry, Cherry, Hoosier Sugar Cream…..and more flavors!

Address

Greenwood Park Mall, 1251 US Highway 31N
Greenwood, IN
46142

Opening Hours

Tuesday	10am - 8pm
Wednesday	10am - 8pm
Thursday	10am - 8pm
Friday	10am - 8pm
Saturday	10am - 8pm
Sunday	12pm - 6pm

Website

http://www.mysugarpie.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sugar Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.