Be Happy Pie Company

Call Directions Website

Be Happy Pie Company Be Happy Pie Company (West Side - Evansville, IN) is a full service bakery specializing in sweet and savory, made from scratch pies and more!

"Always made from scratch" is not just a motto - it is a testament to the purity and authenticity of our craft. At The Be Happy Pie Company, we're committed to using only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients because we believe that the best flavors are born from the best sources.

Huge thank you to Evansville Regional Economic Partnership for the opportunity to present to such an awesome group!
11/13/2026

Huge thank you to Evansville Regional Economic Partnership for the opportunity to present to such an awesome group!

Your Thanksgiving pie could come with a little extra magic! 🎟️🥧When you pre-order your Thanksgiving pies, you’re automat...
11/12/2026

Your Thanksgiving pie could come with a little extra magic! 🎟️🥧

When you pre-order your Thanksgiving pies, you’re automatically entered into our Golden Ticket Giveaway for a chance to WIN a FREE 10” pie!

Pre-orders close November 18th.

11/12/2026

A Thanksgiving table just isn’t complete without pie!🥧

Make room for your Be Happy Pie Company favorites this Thanksgiving and let us bring a little extra joy to your holiday gathering! Don’t forget to pre-order your pies by November 18th at 5 PM to make sure dessert is covered.

Evansville Online Ordering (reminder to double check your pickup location East or West): https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus
Kansas City Online Ordering: https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

📸Styling by: Julie Garcia

West Side, your next pie run is calling! 🥧We’ve been busy baking, and there’s plenty of goodness ready to go in our case...
11/11/2026

West Side, your next pie run is calling! 🥧We’ve been busy baking, and there’s plenty of goodness ready to go in our case.

From sweet treats to savory favorites, full-size pies to 5” pies and pie bites, there’s lots to choose from. Stop in, take a look, and find something delicious to bring home!

And don’t put off those Thanksgiving plans! Pre-orders close November 18th at 5 PM. Get your holiday pies reserved now so you can check dessert off your list!

We’ll see you at the bakery, we are open until 5pm!
📍 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville

Freedom comes with sacrifice, and today we honor those who have given so much in service to our country.🇺🇸From all of us...
11/11/2026

Freedom comes with sacrifice, and today we honor those who have given so much in service to our country.🇺🇸

From all of us at Be Happy Pie Company, thank you to the veterans who have served, sacrificed, and helped protect the freedoms we cherish. We are forever grateful.

It’s a beautiful day in Evansville, and our west side bakery case is FULL! 🥧✨Whether you’re craving something sweet, som...
11/10/2026

It’s a beautiful day in Evansville, and our west side bakery case is FULL! 🥧✨

Whether you’re craving something sweet, something savory, or getting a head start on Thanksgiving, we’ve got something delicious waiting for you.

Stop by for a treat, grab a scratch-made savory pie for dinner, or get those Thanksgiving pre-orders in before the holiday rush!

📍2818 Mt. Vernon Ave, Suite B

WEST EVANSVILLE! As Thanksgiving week approaches, now is the perfect time to stock up on some of your savory Be Happy Pi...
11/10/2026

WEST EVANSVILLE! As Thanksgiving week approaches, now is the perfect time to stock up on some of your savory Be Happy Pie Company favorites!🥧

Our take-and-bake savory pies are fresh, ready to take home DAILY, and perfect for keeping dinner simple as the temperatures drop.❄️
🥧 Chicken Pot Pie
🌮 Fiesta Taco Pie

Both are freezer-friendly for up to 3 months, so you can have a delicious, homemade-tasting meal ready whenever you need it. Just pop it in the oven and enjoy!

Stock up now, thank yourself later!🍒

11/09/2026
11/08/2026

🦃Thanksgiving is coming up fast!🥧

Now is the time to get those Thanksgiving pie pre-orders in with Be Happy Pie Company! Don’t wait until the last minute to secure your holiday favorites.🍒

⏰ Pre-orders close November 18th at 5 PM! Order online or stop by and see us to get your Thanksgiving pies reserved! 🥧

Evansville Online Ordering (reminder to double check your pickup location East or West): https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

Kansas City Online Ordering: https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

🥧West side, A little weekend happiness starts here!Saturday is the perfect excuse to treat yourself to something delicio...
11/07/2026

🥧West side, A little weekend happiness starts here!

Saturday is the perfect excuse to treat yourself to something delicious! Stop in for scratch-made favorites, sweet treats, savory pies, and all the goodness fresh from our bakery. Whether you’re planning a cozy night in or just craving something special, we’ve got you covered!

Come see what’s waiting in the case today!
📍 East Evansville — 6225 E. Virginia St., Suite C
📍 West Evansville — 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B

✨A LITTLE THANKSGIVING MAGIC IS COMING YOUR WAY! 🎟️Our Golden Ticket Giveaway is back! And entering couldn't be easier—A...
11/03/2026

✨A LITTLE THANKSGIVING MAGIC IS COMING YOUR WAY! 🎟️

Our Golden Ticket Giveaway is back! And entering couldn't be easier—All you have to do is pre-order your Thanksgiving pies! 🥧

We'll have TWO lucky Golden Ticket winners in each market — one winner on each of our two Thanksgiving pickup days in Evansville and Kansas City! 🎉

So get those Thanksgiving pie orders in, and you could be taking home a little something extra along with your holiday favorites!

Thank you for making Be Happy Pie Company part of your holiday traditions. We're so grateful for every one of you!

🍒NEWBURGH, IN🍒
11/02/2026

🍒NEWBURGH, IN🍒

The Be Happy Pie Company 5K returns in 2027!

If you are a fan of our events that have sweet treats at the finish, this one is for you!

Unfortunately this race was virtual in 2020 & 2021 but next year it will be back and better than ever. It will take place April 10 at Friedman Park in Newburgh.

Until then, make sure to check out our Tri-State Fitness Races registrations that are currently open at www.tristatefit.com

11.22 Mystery Race presented by OTM Boutique
12.12 Dashing Through the Lights Fun Run/Walk
12.13 The Blazin’ Glazin’ Race presented by Mainstream Fiber Networks
12.31 New Year’s Eve 5K presented by Forefront Therapy
1.17.27 Freakin Freezin’ race presented by Optimize U Evansville

QUESTION: What is your favorite Thanksgiving pie? Comment down below and remember to pre-order your pies this week!🍒 Wes...
11/02/2026

QUESTION: What is your favorite Thanksgiving pie? Comment down below and remember to pre-order your pies this week!

🍒 West Evansville:
📞 812-449-7718
2818 Mount Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–5pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 East Evansville:
📞 812-916-9454
6225 E Virginia St., Suite C, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 Kansas City:
📞 816-384-4745
7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite #200, Gladstone, MO
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 7:30am–2pm

👻Happy Halloween!🍒 Today is your LAST CHANCE to get our October Pie of the Month, the Pumpkin Caramel Praline! 🎃If you’v...
10/31/2026

👻Happy Halloween!🍒 Today is your LAST CHANCE to get our October Pie of the Month, the Pumpkin Caramel Praline! 🎃If you’ve been waiting to try this fall favorite, now’s the time!

Plus, grab some spooky sweetness for your Halloween festivities with our Boo Boxes, filled with festive sugar cookies! 👻🦇🎃Or our Frankenstein pies!

Stop by today for your favorite made-from-scratch pies, sweet treats, and savory goodies before the weekend is over!

📍 East Evansville — 6225 E. Virginia St., Suite C
📍 West Evansville — 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B
📍 Kansas City — 7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite 200, Gladstone, MO

Make your Halloween a little sweeter with Be Happy Pie Company! 🥧

Thanksgiving will be here before you know it!🥧Don’t wait until the last minute to claim your spot at the dessert table! ...
10/30/2026

Thanksgiving will be here before you know it!🥧

Don’t wait until the last minute to claim your spot at the dessert table! Call us or stop by the store to pre-order your favorite made-from-scratch pies for your Thanksgiving festivities.

From our ovens to your holiday table, we’re here to make your Thanksgiving sweeter. Pre-order ASAP so you don’t miss out! We can’t wait to be part of your holiday celebrations.

🍒 West Evansville:
📞 812-449-7718
2818 Mount Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–5pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 East Evansville:
📞 812-916-9454
6225 E Virginia St., Suite C, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 Kansas City:
📞 816-384-4745
7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite #200, Gladstone, MO
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 7:30am–2pm

10/30/2026

That first bite says it ALL!

Our founder, Jenny Lamble, putting yesterday’s freshly baked maple pecan scones to the ultimate taste test… and we think that big “MMMMM” says everything you need to know! 😂🍒

Made from scratch and baked with love, just the way we do it at Be Happy Pie Company. 🥧

🎃👻 THE FINAL DAYS FOR SPOOKY TREATS! 🥧Halloween is almost here! Grab your goodies before they disappear.🥧 FRANKENSTEIN P...
10/29/2026

🎃👻 THE FINAL DAYS FOR SPOOKY TREATS! 🥧

Halloween is almost here! Grab your goodies before they disappear.

🥧 FRANKENSTEIN PIES: Four flavors in one pie! Fruity (Apple, Cherry, Blueberry & Blackberry) OR Nutty (Pecan, Chocolate Pecan, Chocolate Chess & Chess).

👻BOO BOXES: Three spooky sugar cookies in every box: a ghost, pumpkin & bat! Boxed and ready to go.

Stop by TODAY:

🍒 West Evansville:
2818 Mount Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–5pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 East Evansville:
6225 E Virginia St., Suite C, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 Kansas City:
7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite #200, Gladstone, MO
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 7:30am–2pm

👻🥧THE GREAT BE HAPPY BOO-OFF IS ON!🎃The costumes are coming out, and we want to see yours! 👀Thursday through Saturday, s...
10/28/2026

👻🥧THE GREAT BE HAPPY BOO-OFF IS ON!🎃

The costumes are coming out, and we want to see yours! 👀

Thursday through Saturday, stop by Be Happy Pie Company in your Halloween costume, grab a picture with your purchase, and show us what you've got!

📸 Here's how to enter:
🎃 Visit us in costume Thursday, Friday, or Saturday
🥧 Snap a picture with our spooky treats
📲 Post it on Facebook or Instagram and tag Be Happy Pie Company

🏆 One lucky winner from Evansville and one from Kansas City will take home a $25 Be Happy Pie Company gift card!

Funniest costume? Best group costume? Most creative pie pose? We'll be watching! 👀

No tricks here, just a little friendly competition and a whole lot of pie happiness.

Who's joining the BOO-OFF?! 👻

10/27/2026

🥧The FINAL WEEK for our Pumpkin Caramel Praline Pie is here!

Our October Pie of the Month is almost gone, and you don’t want to miss this fall favorite! With pumpkin, caramel, and praline flavors, it’s the perfect way to savor the season.

Stop by Be Happy Pie Company this week and take one home before the month is over!

🍒 West Evansville:
2818 Mount Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–5pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 East Evansville:
6225 E Virginia St., Suite C, Evansville, IN
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 8am–12pm

🍒 Kansas City:
7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite #200, Gladstone, MO
Tuesday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm
Saturday, 7:30am–2pm

🥧SAVORY CRAVINGS? We’ve got you covered!🥧 Looking for an easy lunch or a delicious dinner solution? We have quiche in t...
10/26/2026

🥧SAVORY CRAVINGS? We’ve got you covered!🥧

Looking for an easy lunch or a delicious dinner solution? We have quiche in the case DAILY, ready for you to stop in and enjoy!

And don’t forget our take-and-bake favorites! 🥧 Grab a Chicken Pot Pie or Fiesta Taco Pie to take home and bake whenever you’re ready for a savory, made-from-scratch meal.

Stop in this week and take home a little savory happiness!

🍒West Evansville:
2818 Mount Vernon Ave., Suite B Evansville, IN
Tuesday - Friday, 7:30am - 5:00pm
Saturday, 8am - 12pm

🍒East Evansville:
6225 E Virginia St. Suite C Evansville, IN
Tuesday - Friday, 7:30am - 6:00pm
Saturday, 8am - 12pm

🍒Kansas City:
7506 N. Oak Trafficway Suite #200 Gladstone, MO
Tuesday - Friday, 7:30am - 6:00pm
Saturday, 7:30am - 2pm

Address

2818 Mount Vernon Avenue, Suite B
Evansville, IN
47712

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 5pm
Thursday 7:30am - 5pm
Friday 7:30am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 12pm

Telephone

+18124497718

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Be Happy Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Sponsored

Share

Category

Nearby bakeries