Shay Butter Bakery

03/01/2026

NEWEST ADDITION!

The Matcha Mini Loaf - made with organic matcha and topped with our homemade matcha frosting ✨

02/07/2026

How cute are these mini loaves for your next event!

-Baby Showers
-Bridal Showers
-Birthdays
-Work event
-Brunch / Tea parties

Whatever the occassion, our mini loaves make the perfect addition to any gathering 💗

Email us at [email protected]

01/24/2026

Come visit us tomorrow!

PEWAUKEE SUNDAY MARKET: We’ve got a massive list of vendors including Pewaukee Pierogi Co, Never Judge a Book, Kelly's Pot Pies, and White House Lidz. Whether you’re looking for lunch, a new accessory, or a gift, we’ve got you covered.

📍 Brewfinity Brewing Co. | 203 W Wisconsin Ave, Pewaukee

01/22/2026

Who's ready for the Indoor Winter Market at Brewfinity Brewing Co. on Sunday?!

Last weekend we completely sold out of Red Velvet and Maple Pecan and were two loaves away from selling out of our signature Roasted Chocolate Chip Banana Bread 😋

If you haven't heard, our Red Velvet is made with organic beets - we even add the puree to the frosting to give it that pretty color! It is available now through February!

Stay tuned for our next mini loaf drop 👀

Pre-order by sending us a DM or emailing us at [email protected] ❣️

01/14/2026

JUMBO COOKIES!

Soft and chewy vanilla iced oatmeal and chocolate chip cookies 🍪

These cookies are 100% SHAREABLE (or not, we won’t tell 😉😅)

01/13/2026

Whether you are planning a brunch with the girlies, a baby shower, bridal shower or work event - we got you covered!

How cute are these mini loaves! Super easy to share, perfect bite size pieces!

📧 [email protected] for requests!

01/10/2026

Looking forward to Sundays market at Pewaukee’s Brewfinity Brewing Co.

We are a small-batch bakery that specializes in mini loaves!

Come try our ✨ BEST SELLER ✨ the Roasted Choclate Chip Banana mini loaf.

We will also be featuring our other core loafs:
-Maple Pecan
-Cinnamon Crumble

and current seasonal favorite: The Red Velvet (available now thru Feb 15th) ❤️

Local pick-up available.
DM for details.

01/10/2026

Our at-home bakery specializes in mini loaves, but we do offer a few select cookies.

Our jumbo soft and chewy oatmeal cookies topped with a vanilla icing is THE PERFECT treat with your morning coffee.

Did we say, JUMBO? These chin ls are perfect for sharing or break in half and save it for another day 😅

01/05/2026

We had a GREAT first day turn out at Brewfinity Brewing Co. Winter Farmers Market on Sunday!

Our signature mini loaf, the roasted chocolate chip banana bread completely sold out 😇

All of our mini loafs are backed in small-batches and we focus on select ingredients like honey, our farm fresh eggs, and partnering with local farmers for organic dairy and flour.

Looking forward to seeing everyone at the taproom next Sunday!

https://www.shaybutterbakery.shop

01/03/2026

We can’t believe it’s 2026! Hope everyone had a great holiday season - we are back at the Waukesha Winters Farmers Market with Chef Pams Kitchen 1st and 3rd Saturday of each month through March.

So nice seeing so many returning faces 🫶🏽 see you on the 17th ✨