Sheila's Sugar

01/23/2026

01/14/2026

I wanted to take a moment to share an update with you all from the heart.

At this time, I am on a self-imposed break from custom cookie orders as I focus on my health and, most importantly, my family. This wasn’t an easy decision, but it’s one that I know is necessary right now.

While I won’t be taking custom orders, Sheila’s Sugar isn’t gone. I may still offer cookies for select holidays through pre-sales or occasional porch pop-ups, when my health and schedule allow. I’ll always share those opportunities here first.

Decorating cookies has truly been a labor of love for me. What started as a small creative outlet grew into something so much bigger, and that’s because of you. I am incredibly grateful to be part of the Chesapeake community and beyond. Many of you have supported me from the very beginning—over ten years ago—and have watched me grow, learn, and find my style as a professional cookie decorator. Your encouragement, loyalty, and kindness have meant more to me than I can ever properly express.

Please know that I miss creating, I miss connecting, and I sincerely hope that this is just a pause and not a goodbye. My heart is still very much in cookies, and I hope to return more fully when the time is right.

Thank you for your understanding, your continued support, and for allowing me the grace to take care of myself and my family. I appreciate each and every one of you more than you know. 💕

With love and gratitude,
Sheila
Sheila’s Sugar 🍪

12/13/2025

If you ordered an elf baking set this is a reminder that pickup is today after 2pm. If you need to schedule pickup at another time or date please let me know.

11/24/2025

Someone got caught with their hand in the cookie jar!

Don't forget that pickup is today after 5PM or anytime tomorrow before 8PM.

***This was a preorder item and is no longer available to order.***

11/11/2025

It’s cookie time! 🎄✨
Elf Cookie Baking Sets are now available for preorder and will be ready for pickup on December 13th.

Each set includes:
• Two cookies
• A jar of sprinkles
• A mini rolling pin
• Packaged in a festive kraft gift box

Cost is $15 per set.
Send me a message to reserve yours—these make the Sweetest holiday gifts from your very own elf 🎄

11/09/2025

It’s almost that time again… our favorite little elf is getting ready to make his return! 🎄
I’m offering large, personalized elf cookies that can include a name or the message “I’m Back!” You can also choose from three skin tones: white, tan, and brown.

Each cookie is $8 and comes packaged in a kraft box with a few festive candies.
If you’d like to place an order, just send me a message and I’ll share the payment link. Pickup will be the 24th and 25th. Orders will be limited and the last day to order is the 17th.

I’d be happy to make something special for your family’s holiday tradition! ✨

11/06/2025

I adore this sorority's colors! What really stands out is the chapter's commitment to staying connected and having fun together. I love that they recently celebrated 40 years with a cruise, it sounds like an unforgettable bonding experience. Not having sororities in my college days didn't stop me from appreciating the lifelong bonds they create - support, community, and love are truly invaluable. 💕

11/05/2025

Loved doing these cookies and I have a clear favorite among the set! Congratulations Spencer and Halley on the spooky adventure of marital bliss!

10/21/2025

New owner at Kitty Kat cafe! Come out and support this non-profit by grabbing a cup of coffee and a treat! Best party everyone you get to sit in a room full of kitties begging for pets 💕