Betty Kaye Bakery

Betty Kaye Bakery We offer a variety of items ranging from homemade breads, cookies, cupcakes, and our famous brownies. We are Carroll County's oldest and finest bakery.

Father’s Day weekend features- mini and 9” coconut cream pies, tractor, baseball, and firetruck cutouts, white, chocolat...
06/19/2026

Father’s Day weekend features- mini and 9” coconut cream pies, tractor, baseball, and firetruck cutouts, white, chocolate, lemon, and strawberry mini cakes, original and Peanut butter cake rolls, assorted donuts and cream sticks, lemon, lemon raspberry, cookies n cream, red velvet, and On Your Mark (bourbon iced) brownies, sour dough, multi grain, and assorted buns and breads for all of your grilling needs

Wednesday features- Baklava, raspberry filled donuts, and raspberry jacks
06/17/2026

Wednesday features- Baklava, raspberry filled donuts, and raspberry jacks

Weekend features- mini strawberry, lemon, white and chocolate cakes, mini pineapple upside down cakes, red velvet cupcak...
06/12/2026

Weekend features- mini strawberry, lemon, white and chocolate cakes, mini pineapple upside down cakes, red velvet cupcakes, nut logs, breakfast cups, old fashioned cinnamon or maple rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, peanut butter cream sticks with either peanut butter or chocolate icing, and raspberry filled donuts. Come see us, we are here from 7:30-5

Thursday features- Flipovers, cream horns, and kitty cat, rainbow, and baseball cutouts. We are open from 7:30-5, stop i...
06/11/2026

Thursday features- Flipovers, cream horns, and kitty cat, rainbow, and baseball cutouts. We are open from 7:30-5, stop in and see us

Thank you for all of the well wishes, our daughter’s wedding was perfect and we have gained the most wonderful son-in-la...
06/10/2026

Thank you for all of the well wishes, our daughter’s wedding was perfect and we have gained the most wonderful son-in-law. Having said that- WE’RE BACK!!! Today’s features- chocolate cake rolls, mini cream horns, and white cake with raspberry filling and mock cream icing. We are open from 7:30-5

We will be closed NEXT WEEK June 2nd-June 9th to celebrate the wedding of our daughter and granddaughter Abbygail and he...
05/26/2026

We will be closed NEXT WEEK June 2nd-June 9th to celebrate the wedding of our daughter and granddaughter Abbygail and her fiancé Blayne. We will reopen on Wednesday, June 10th. We will be making extra bread and goodies so everyone can stock up

Memorial Day specials- assorted patriotic cakes, cookies, and cupcakes, white cake with either red raspberry or black r...
05/22/2026

Memorial Day specials- assorted patriotic cakes, cookies, and cupcakes, white cake with either red raspberry or black raspberry filling, custard, red raspberry, and lemon filled donuts, peanut butter filled cream sticks, nut logs, old fashioned cinnamon or maple, giant cinnamon rolls, breakfast cups, fresh strawberry, fresh strawberries and cream and coconut cream pies, lots of hot dog, sandwich, bbq, slider, party, and hoagie buns, and a strawberry and blueberry mixed cake roll. Stop in and see us and get prepared for the holiday weekend

They’re back!!! Lemon bars with cream cheese icing!! We also have baklava and small cherry, peach, and blueberry pies ...
05/19/2026

They’re back!!! Lemon bars with cream cheese icing!! We also have baklava and small cherry, peach, and blueberry pies

Weekends features- patriotic cutouts, strawberry peaks, white cake with strawberry filling and mock cream icing, raspber...
05/15/2026

Weekends features- patriotic cutouts, strawberry peaks, white cake with strawberry filling and mock cream icing, raspberry, custard, and LEMON, filled donuts, peanut butter cream sticks, old fashioned maple or cinnamon rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, small cherry, blueberry, and strawberry rhubarb pies, and assorted decorated cookies

Thursday features- white cake with strawberry filling and mock cream icing and marble cake, as well as cheese filled and...
05/14/2026

Thursday features- white cake with strawberry filling and mock cream icing and marble cake, as well as cheese filled and nut filled cookies

Address

72 West Main Street
Carrollton, OH
44615

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Betty Kaye Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Betty Kaye Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share