Cute as a Button Cookies

Cute as a Button Cookies Custom cookies by Katie Maurer My sugar cookies are homemade with fresh ingredients (butter, sugar, salt, baking powder, egg, flour and vanilla).

My name is Katie Maurer and I make specialty cookies for any and every occasion ... birthdays, graduations, housewarming, corporate events, holidays, bar mitzvahs, baptisms, sporting events, celebrations and much more. Please contact me if you have any questions about nutritional information or allergies. As of now, I do not offer any vegan, dairy- or gluten-free varieties. Pricing

Boxed cookies:

$42 per dozen
(If a cookie is small, I will include extra so your order is equivalent to one dozen)

Oversized cookies (more than 5") or elaborate detail: $1 extra per cookie

Favors (with cellophane bag and ribbon): Start at $3.50 per favor

Minimum order: 1 dozen

Congratulations on being a first round draft pick for the Chicago Bears! I hope these cookies made your celebration a l...
04/27/2026

Congratulations on being a first round draft pick for the Chicago Bears! I hope these cookies made your celebration a little sweeter! 💙🧡

I am doing Easter cookie this week! I did not set up a pre-sale so if you are interested in ordering, please go to the l...
03/29/2026

I am doing Easter cookie this week! I did not set up a pre-sale so if you are interested in ordering, please go to the link in my bio and click on the “Text Us” button, or simply DM me here.

*Mini packs
*Assorted 1 dozen
*Personalized individual cookies
*Gift boxes with 2 cookies

Pick up is on Saturday in West Carmel. Address will be provided after ordering.

I am taking a few last-minute Valentines orders! If you see this post and are interested in ordering some cookies for ne...
02/04/2026

I am taking a few last-minute Valentines orders! If you see this post and are interested in ordering some cookies for next week, please DM me or check back for my official post when I have everything ready to go in my Square store! Thank you❣️

We’re feeling peachy here in Indiana! If you’re having a watch party or headed to Atlanta next weekend, make your IU foo...
01/02/2026

We’re feeling peachy here in Indiana! If you’re having a watch party or headed to Atlanta next weekend, make your IU football experience a little sweeter with some custom cookies! Order at link in bio and GO HOOSIERS! 🍑❤️🤍

Calling all 2026 grads! 🎓 I am currently accepting orders for May and June. This is the busiest season on my calendar an...
12/30/2025

Calling all 2026 grads! 🎓 I am currently accepting orders for May and June. This is the busiest season on my calendar and this year my schedule is more limited due to having a full-time job. Knowing myself, I will still definitely take on too much, but I am going to be extra disciplined on taking orders!

The link in my bio will take you to my site, where you can find my custom order form.

Thank you and happy new year! xo Katie

Happy Hoosier Holidays! ❤️🤍
12/28/2025

Happy Hoosier Holidays! ❤️🤍

I’m SO close to having Christmas cookies available to order! Technology is standing in my way at the moment and I’m tryi...
12/09/2025

I’m SO close to having Christmas cookies available to order! Technology is standing in my way at the moment and I’m trying to get my square site up and running ASAP! Stay tuned!!

Step 1: Decorate cookiesStep 2: Devour your creations!Cookie decorating kits will be available all next month! These are...
11/17/2025

Step 1: Decorate cookies
Step 2: Devour your creations!

Cookie decorating kits will be available all next month! These are perfect for parties or cozy days at home. It’s an activity and a snack all in one! ❤️💚

I’m so de“lighted” that Christmastime is nearly here! Can’t wait to share some of my favorite festive creations for the ...
11/17/2025

I’m so de“lighted” that Christmastime is nearly here! Can’t wait to share some of my favorite festive creations for the season!
❤️🎄🎅🏻

Address

2422 Burnham Walk
Carmel, IN
46032

Telephone

+13175574257

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cute as a Button Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category