Renna Mae's Baking Co.

06/20/2026

📣 A New Chapter🧁🍪🎂

We have been a little quiet lately, but have an update to share.

After the best two years, we are saying goodbye to The Coop commercial kitchen and transitioning our bakery to operate under Wisconsin’s Cottage Food Laws.

Before anything else, we want to say thank you to The Coop for being our home over the last two years. The Coop has been an absolute dream kitchen to work in and the friendships, advice, and memories are something I will always hold dear. I have loved learning from some of the best and getting to live out my bakery dreams. ❤️

This change comes as Karenna has started graduate school! 😅 While I’m not quite ready to retire the bakery just yet, some adjustments are needed to balance family, school, and work.

What does this change mean for you?

While we’ll still be whipping up your favorite treats such as cakes, cookies, cake pops, and more, some items may no longer be available and a few recipes may need to be adjusted to comply with state laws.

Thank you for your continued support for this little business. Looking forward to continuing to serve you. ☺️

*pics from our last bake at The Coop for a wedding 💕

01/12/2026

These weren’t made in the commercial kitchen as they were for a family baby shower, but too cute not to share.

Woodland animal theme shower calls for a sweet stroll through the forest including Hershey’s acorns, paw print cookies, “birch bark” and “moss” chocolate dipped pretzels, and cupcakes with the cutest sugar animals. 🦊 🦨 🐰 🦝

11/24/2025

📢 Last call for pies! Get your orders in by Midnight tonight for a Wednesday pickup! 🦃 🥧

https://www.hotplate.com/rennamaesbakery/fb9cfb79-51a5-4ba4-b176-797e989ac578on

11/18/2025

Just a quick reminder that Thanksgiving orders are due in just under a week!

If you’re planning to bring home our pies, now’s the time to get those orders in. We want to make sure your table is full of all your favorites! 💛🥧

Welcome! I am so glad you are here. My name is Karenna Kelly and I am the main baker here at Renna Mae's. I have been baking for as long as I can remember and have always found joy in serving home baked goods to family, friends, and coworkers. With my husband's encouragement, I took a leap of faith....

11/12/2025

Thanksgiving is almost here, and that means one thing… it’s PIE SEASON, baby! 🦃🍂

Pre order available now through November 24th.

https://www.hotplate.com/rennamaesbakery

10/01/2025

💚🍋 A TINI bit older, and a whole lot sweeter!
This vintage heart-shaped lemon-flavored cake is perfect for a birthday celebration — complete with a martini-inspired garnish 🍸

09/26/2025

Aloha, sweet tooth! 🌺🍓🍫

Chocolate cake + strawberry buttercream + beach vibes + a little mischief

09/20/2025

Look who hopped out of the Poké ball and onto the dessert table! ⚡️

Made with tender vanilla cake topped with coconut cream frosting, this Pikachu cake is sure to be a hit for any kid’s birthday.

Who’s ready to catch a slice? 😉

09/08/2025

This cake contains 0% self control and 100% peanut butter cups. Friendly reminder that birthday calories don’t count. 😉🍫🥜

09/04/2025

Swear I didn’t get lost in the New World, just took a little Facebook hiatus. 😅⚓️

We’re back on deck with this One Piece inspired cake for the anime fans out there! ☠️