The Sugar Cookie Bakery

The Sugar Cookie Bakery Baker extraordinaire! Welcome to my sweet little shop where I whip up the most delectable cookies you've ever tasted.
(1)

From classic chocolate chip to exotic flavors. Let me satisfy your cookie cravings with my in-home bakery delights! Hi, I'm Mary, the proud baker behind The Sugar Cookie Bakery LLC., a micro bakery nestled in the heart of the Fox Cities in Appleton, WI. My passion for creating gourmet cookies has turned my cozy kitchen into a haven for cookie lovers. Every batch is baked with love, using the fines

t ingredients to ensure that each cookie is a delightful treat. At The Sugar Cookie Bakery, we offer classic flavors to unique creations, there's a perfect cookie waiting just for you. Please note that all orders are preorder only and we do not ship at this time. We're thrilled to announce that you can now preorder our gourmet cookies every week! Sign up with the link in our bio with your cell phone number to receive our weekly cookie drop! 🍪

The Sugar Cookie Bakery cookies are produced in my private home kitchen not subject to state licensing or inspection. I operate under the Wisconsin Cottage Law guidelines. All baked goods may contain the following allergens: wheat, milk, eggs, tree nuts, peanuts or soy. Thank you for supporting our small business. I can't wait to bake something special for you!

01/01/2026

🎉 Happy New Year! 🎉
So grateful for my amazing customers. Thank you for supporting my bakery — here’s to more sweetness in 2026! 🍰✨

12/25/2025

Merry Christmas to all our amazing customers! 🎄
Thank you for your continued support and loyalty — it truly means the world to us. We're so grateful to be part of your celebrations and special moments. Wishing you and your families a joyful, sweet Christmas and a Happy New Year! ❤️💚

🎄❤️

SOLD OUT!🌲🎅🎁And then there was ONE… 🎄🍪Sitting here looking a little lonely, just waiting for someone to claim it.Because...
12/23/2025

SOLD OUT!🌲🎅🎁
And then there was ONE… 🎄🍪
Sitting here looking a little lonely, just waiting for someone to claim it.
Because it’s not Christmas without cookies 🤍
Last gourmet holiday cookie box available — message me! 🎅🏼🎄👍

I have 2 Holiday Gourmet Cookie Boxes left.$25 (6 ct)Gift ready with tissue & bow!❤️💚Message me to reserve and to schedu...
12/23/2025

I have 2 Holiday Gourmet Cookie Boxes left.
$25 (6 ct)
Gift ready with tissue & bow!❤️💚

Message me to reserve and to schedule pickup!✨️🎄🍪

🎄 Holiday Gourmet Cookie Boxes Available! 🎄I have 6 Holiday Cookie Boxes ready for pickup tomorrow, December 23rd — perf...
12/23/2025

🎄 Holiday Gourmet Cookie Boxes Available! 🎄
I have 6 Holiday Cookie Boxes ready for pickup tomorrow, December 23rd — perfect for last-minute gifting or your holiday table!
✨ Each 6-pack includes: $25
Includes 6 full-size treats:
• 2 buttercream-decorated Christmas tree cutout cookies
• Cherry-filled sugar cookie with vanilla buttercream
• Snickerdoodle cookie frosted with buttercream, cinnamon & brown sugar
• German chocolate cookie topped with hot fudge and cherry
• Brownie “Santa Hat” cookie with buttercream
Packaged in a white window gift box with tissue and red ribbon — gift-ready.
🎁 6 boxes available

• Packaged in a white gift box with ribbon and tissue — gift-ready!
💲 $25 per 6-pack
📍 Pickup only — limited quantity available
Message me to claim one — first come, first served!

Holiday Buttercream Cookie Gift Box – $25Includes 6 full-size treats:• 2 buttercream-decorated Christmas tree cutout coo...
12/21/2025

Holiday Buttercream Cookie Gift Box – $25
Includes 6 full-size treats:
• 2 buttercream-decorated Christmas tree cutout cookies
• Cherry-filled sugar cookie with vanilla buttercream
• Snickerdoodle cookie frosted with buttercream, cinnamon & brown sugar
• German chocolate cookie topped with hot fudge and cherry
• Brownie “Santa Hat” cookie with buttercream
Packaged in a white window gift box with tissue and red ribbon — gift-ready.
🎁 12 boxes available

🎄 Individually Wrapped “Double Doozie” Cookies $5 each (or 3 for $12)
Flavors available:
• Brownie Raspberry
• Brownie Oreo (limited)
• Snickerdoodle Double Doozie
• M&M Chocolate Chip with Vanilla Buttercream (very limited)
✅ Perfect for stocking stuffers, gift bags, or a sweet treat for yourself
✅ Individually wrapped for freshness and gifting

🏡 Porch pickup December 23rd (pickup time arranged by message)
Message me to reserve — limited quantity.

Important update ❤️💚Due to a personal emergency, I won’t be able to attend the Christkindl event in Green Bay tonight. I...
12/19/2025

Important update ❤️💚
Due to a personal emergency, I won’t be able to attend the Christkindl event in Green Bay tonight. I’m so sorry to miss everyone.

The good news — these holiday cookie boxes will still be available, and I’ll share details very soon on how to order.

Thank you so much for your understanding and support 🩷

12/18/2025

Christmas is in the air at in Green Bay!✨️🎄

We'll be there tomorrow Friday December 19th from 4-9pm with our Holiday Gournet Cookie boxes tied with ribbon and gift ready for Christmas!

See you there!❤️💚

Address

Appleton, WI
54911, 54912, 54913, 54914, 54915, 54919

Telephone

+19207164106

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Sugar Cookie Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Sugar Cookie Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category