Cookie Comfort

Home
United States
Woodmere, NY
Cookie Comfort

Welcome to the land of Cookie Comfort, a place that can transport you to a simpler cookie & milk era, where chocolate chips were the best currency available.

Is there anything more comforting than cookies and milk? Founded in 2004, Cookie Comfort was born of the desire to share the tastes and smells of my childhood with my children. From that desire, the dream of sharing these homemade bites from the past was made. At Cookie Comfort, we bake a little nostalgia into every bite. Each memorable cookie is a ticket to simpler times, and summers on the front

porch. Our selection of cookies and bakes, ranging from chocolate chip and oatmeal cranberry to hamentashen and babka doughnuts, and comfort eats from brownies to cinnamon buns and chocolate babka, will satisfy any craving any time of the year. Baked fresh to order, Cookie Comfort is the place to turn for old and new classic cookies. All of our products are dairy-free. Some products are vegan. And all are baked with strictly Kosher ingredients.

~ Amy

05/07/2026

😂

Over the years, there has been swag. Mugs, clocks, magnets...but other than one magnet, I haven't kept any for myself. Until this.

Last year, very graciously made this jacket for me. Since I have a collection of jackets (🤫 I know) it was put in the back of a closet.

The last few weeks, the weather has been a little unpredictable here in New York, and I have a blocn against leaving the house wearing a jacket. So now, it lives in my car. To always be there if and when I need a jacket.

While you are here, now would be a great time to see what makes Cookie Comfort cookies and retro bakes different from everyone else.

05/05/2026

10 things to be before ordering your new favorite dessert....call us. We'll take care of the rest.

02/20/2026

Behold, the official . Is it babka? Hamentashen? If you missed out, then know that they will be back next year...mark your calendars. starts February 8, 2027.

02/18/2026

מי שנכנס אדר מרבים בשמחה!

If its Adar, that means that is just aound the corner.

Thanks for the song!

02/04/2026

Today, I asked to create a picture of the . It did not disappoint.

Swipe to see the original, then click to order the hottest flavor of the year.

01/19/2026

Well, here it is. The belated announcement that are now officially open for the .

I'm sorry. With the wedding and everything, it just slipped my mind. So. Get to it!

01/13/2026

Well, really did it this time. For the last 3 days, I have been trying to launch the on my . I am getting error messages in red and error messages in yellow and no help from support except for "delete your products and then add them again."

An of the highest level, as this is my biggest season and your favorite product.

Unfortunately this means that if you are an Etsy customer, you will not be able to purchase hamentashen there this year.

01/12/2026

And with that, the Purim 2026 season starts.

open tonight.

Orders close February 12th.

Orders ship February 17th.

I wouldn't sleep on this one. Especially on our brand new chocolate babka hamentashen. They are a limited edition and as soon as they're sold out, they are sold out and will not be back until next year.

01/06/2026

There is a time where you will arrive at a . It is important to . That is the road that will bring you Joy.

01/04/2026

I know, I know. It's too early for . But, it's not really.

Due to a wedding in the family, orders are starting and ending 2 weeks early.

will open on January 11th and close February 12th. Unfortunately, we will be unable to accept orders after February 12th.

Orders will ship the week of February 17th unless otherwise specified.

Watch your emails and this space for updates and .

Address

Howard Avenue
Woodmere, NY
11598

Telephone

+15165151237

Website

http://cookiecomfortshop.etsy.com/, Https://www.cookiecomfort.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Comfort posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Comfort:

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in Woodmere?