08/09/2025
Presenting his Royal Highness, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, the King of Cookies 🥜🍫👑
I think we can all agree that in the hierarchy of dessert flavors this one takes first place almost every time.
Made by combining our popular peanut butter dough and our all chocolate (Quintuplet) dough and topped with peanut butter and chocolate chips, His Highness will bless your tastebuds with a marvelous blend of flavor and a surprise buttercup stuffed center. We declare this, out of all our Magpie Cookies, to be the hardest NOT to eat in one sitting.
I will warn you, we will only be selling this cookie flavor till the last Saturday of August and, believe me, they sell out FAST (usually before Noon) so be sure to stop by our tent next week and snag one while you still can!