Extraordinary Cupcakes

05/19/2024

Congratulations Anthony & Abena!

05/19/2024

02/10/2024

Place your order today!

02/09/2024

Come and get your Love

an Extraordinary Valentine's Day Cake!

08/20/2023

Swing into Illy Caffe and grab a brand new Strawberry Shortcake Push Up!

A delicious way to beat the summer heat!!!

08/11/2023

Another Extraordinary birthday!

07/01/2023

We know some of you are having trouble locating us since we moved from our location of 11 + years.

We no longer have a storefront but you can still get our extraordinary cupcakes Tuesday - Saturday.

Order for today online then pick up at our kiosk inside Illy Caffe or have them delivered. You can also schedule your order in advance for the day you will need them and tell us what time you would like to pick them up or have them delivered.

We also now have a 3 day advance order option for cakes!

Want to customize an order? Email us at [email protected].

Need to speak with us? Email us your contact info or call us 757-645-2122.

We look forward to making your day extraordinary!

Dyana McGlothlin Steely
Owner

"Helping others escape the ordinary - one cupcake at a time!"

04/13/2023

Delivery is now available!

Thank you all for your patience. Our online ordering system is now in place and delivery is available.

Why the wait time? We bake your order as soon as you place it. As we get a feel for what the numbers will be for the day, we will go back to baking in small batches throughout the day and the preparation time of your order will go back to being what you are used to in our previous location.

We are doing our best to continue to provide you with the cupcakes and cakes you love. Thank you for your continued support and loyalty.

Please visit our website for more information - www.extraordinarycupcakes.com

Dyana McGlothlin Steely
Owner, Extraordinary Cupcakes

Celebrating 11 years.
Helping you escape the ordinary, one cupcake at a time.

04/11/2023

Online ordering is now available! Click here www.extraordinarycupcakes.com for the link on our home page
or scan the QR code below to order, then pick up at our new, brightly lit kiosk inside Illy Caffe.

04/01/2023

It's official! We are currently enjoying our new location at 435 W Duke of Gloucester Street, inside Illy Caffe Williamsburg.

In addition to a new location, our ordering process is also new. We have gone digital! To order your beloved cupcakes, simply email us at [email protected] then pick it up in our staging area inside Illy caffe.

Our new online ordering will be in place soon. When it is, you will be able to see what is currently available, set a time and day for pick up, pay, and even have them delivered.