Cath's Crumb and Crust

10/13/2026

Busy Tuesday!

Thank you Colleen, Ashley, Tammy, Suzanne, and Ashley K.!

10/13/2026

Autumnal Apples for Jess! 🍎 🍏 🍎

Thank you! 😘

Custom cookies start at $20/doz! Message to order. (:

10/12/2026

Jam packed Sunday yesterday baking for Andy, Shelly, Leann, Carol and my momma!!

Thank you everyone! 🥰

10/10/2026

Bread bowls for Jaime!

Plain 2/$10!

10/09/2026

All the cozy fall spices and colors flood this week specials!

Live for ordering now on the website!

10/08/2026

“Never again. Never again would she be weak. Never again would she be at someone’s mercy. Never again would she fail. Never again, never again, never again.”

Choosing to dream - announcing that my Sarah J. Maas Themed menu in preparation for A Court of Splintered Harmony's release later this month is NOW LIVE FOR ORDERING on the website!

Order some sourdough made with so much love and travel back to Velaris with me

10/08/2026

Need Halloween Treaties? I gotchu! Send me a message to order

“The end of the summer is not the end of the world. Here’s to October…”

Trying something a little bit different with Halloween pre-sale - It IS NOT on the website. Order by commenting below or sending a message to me here at Cath's Crumb and Crust.

10/07/2026

Hey Cuties! Time to address something.

After MANY inquiries - I have decided to make a post updating folks on what's going on with my menu. You guys are missing your jalapeno cheddar bread.. and I miss making it!

Early September, the DATCP received a complaint from another local baker regarding my jalapeno cheddar bread and my buttercream frosting. Cath's Crumb and Crust follows Wisconsin's Cottage Bakery Law. My bakery must fall within a certain hydration level in order to be considered "non-hazardous," and able to be sold from a home kitchen. The way DATCP determines if your recipes are "non-hazardous," is by sampling each dough.

The recipes I was following for my jalapeno cheddar bread and my buttercreams were recipes other trusted home bakers in Wisconsin submitted to DATCP, got approved, and then shared with the rest of the Wisconsin Cottage Bakery Community so they could also safely sell these products.

With the complaint came a cease and desist for any bakery containing fresh produce, cheese, or bakery topped with buttercream frosting. Until I submit and pay to have samples of each of my products containing these items, I am unable to legally sell them. Unfortunately, as a small business with no huge overhead, I am not able to eat the cost of testing every dough made with cheese/produce.

You will see A LOT of other bakers out there offering bakery with these inclusions - they are not doing anything wrong - they just haven't tripped someone's trigger into reporting them.

I removed over half my menu. I have spent weeks recipe testing and building my menu back up to where it is and will continue to come back bigger and better than I was before. They can take my buttercream and my cheese, but they can't take my love for baking for yall.

Send a message to learn more

10/07/2026

Bread bowls and focaccia for Taylor! Thank you!!

Plain Jane bread bowls are 2/$10 at cathscrumbandcrust.com!

10/07/2026

New specials will drop Friday, don't miss out on the current flavors, order by Thursday evening!

October Week 2 specials are live on the website just in time for the last day to pre-order for Tuesday/Wednesday pick up at Earth + Iron!

If the website ever gives you a hard time, please just message me what you'd like!