Specialty Cookies by Sarah

Specialty Cookies by Sarah *Custom Cookie Policies and more

Let’s go over a few things to make your cookie order truly a Specialty Cookie order! If you miss this date a fee will incur.

Permanently closed.

Ordering and Payments:
Cookies orders are not final until the invoice is paid. Any changes made to the order after payment will incur a fee. Payment is due in full 24 hours after receiving an invoice. Custom cookies are made special just for you because of this we do not accept returns. If an error was made please email and we will work with you to fix the issue. Pickups:
All cookies must be picke

d up on the arranged date. If by any reason you missed the pickup date another date will be arranged. Shipping:
When ordering your cookies please give the date of event. I use USPS priority mail which offers 1-3 day delivery. I am not responsible for the package of cookies once it is shipped. Any delays on shipping or damaged cookies will be on the post office and out of my control. Designs:
Creative freedom is granted to design the cookie sets according to theme and colors provided. Inspiration photos and/or invitations for event are highly encouraged.

03/14/2026

With much consideration I have decided to stop taking orders for cookies.

I am so thankful for everyone that has been a part of my cookie business ❤️

Hatsune Miku themed custom birthday cookies! Another fun order!
02/02/2026

Hatsune Miku themed custom birthday cookies!
Another fun order!

Customized stockings with names! A fun personal touch for a cookie gift!
12/19/2025

Customized stockings with names! A fun personal touch for a cookie gift!

Christmas cookies ☃️❄️☕️
12/18/2025

Christmas cookies ☃️❄️☕️

Time to bag and heat seal some cookies ❄️❄️❄️
12/11/2025

Time to bag and heat seal some cookies ❄️❄️❄️

I was making snowflake cookies today and one broke… oh no I guess I’ll have to eat it. Happy little accident 😁
12/09/2025

I was making snowflake cookies today and one broke… oh no I guess I’ll have to eat it. Happy little accident 😁

Another cute custom birthday set! 🚜🐷🐴🐮
12/01/2025

Another cute custom birthday set! 🚜🐷🐴🐮

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!
11/27/2025

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

I’m feeling Thankful for all that ordered from my Thanksgiving presale! I’m so grateful for all my customers this year ❤...
11/24/2025

I’m feeling Thankful for all that ordered from my Thanksgiving presale!
I’m so grateful for all my customers this year ❤️

Special Delivery on the way! I loved this pizza themed baby shower! 🍕
11/10/2025

Special Delivery on the way! I loved this pizza themed baby shower! 🍕

If you could only keep ONE pie for your Thanksgiving dessert which would it be?Pumpkin, Pecan, Chocolate or Apple??
11/09/2025

If you could only keep ONE pie for your Thanksgiving dessert which would it be?
Pumpkin, Pecan, Chocolate or Apple??

Address

Whitefield, ME
04353

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Specialty Cookies by Sarah posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Specialty Cookies by Sarah:

Shortcuts

Share

Category