The Chocolate Lady

The Chocolate Lady Welcome to The Chocolate Lady! My name is Susanna Haynes, and I make Mud Pies! Mud Pies are trays of fudge set up in pie pans.

There are two sizes of pans and four main varieties of Mud Pies. INGREDIENTS:

Chocolate Mud Pies:
Sugar; milk; chocolate; cocoa butter; milkfat; soy lecithin; vanilla bean extractives in water; alcohol; natural flavors

Chocolate Mud Pies with Walnuts:
Sugar; milk; chocolate; cocoa buttet; milkfat; walnuts; soy lecithin; vanilla bean extractives in water; alcohol; natural flavors

Peanut Butter M

ud Pies:
Partially defatted peanuts; sugar; milk; hydrogenated vegetable oil (palm kernel oil, soybean oil); corn syrup solids; dextrose; reduced protein whey (milk); contains 2% or less of: palm kernel oil, salt, vanillin, artificial flavor, lecithin (soy); vanilla bean extractives in water; alcohol

Cow Pie:
Sugar; milk; chocolate; cocoa butter; milkfat; pecans; high fructose corn syrup; corn syrup; sweetened condensed skim milk (skim milk, sugar); water; coconut; soy lecithin; contains 2% or less of: modified cornstarch, disodium phosphate, natural flavor and artificial flavor, sodium citrate, mono and di-glycerides, salt, carrageenan, caramel color, artificial color (Yellow 6, Yellow 5); vanilla bean extractives in water; alcohol. Strawberry Chocolate Chip Cookies:
Flour; chocolate chips; sugar; butter; instant vanilla pudding; eggs; gelatin; vanilla extract; baking soda; baking powder; almond extract; salt; natural and artificial flavoring; yellow 5; yellow 6; red 40. Lemon White Chocolate Chip Cookies:
Flour; white chocolate chip cookies; sugar; butter; instant lemon pudding; eggs; gelatin; lemon juice; vanilla extract; baking soda; baking powder; almond extract; salt; natural and artificial flavoring; yellow 5; yellow 6. Chocolate Sheet Cake:
Flour; sugar; water; butter; cream; eggs; cocoa powder; white vinegar; baking soda; vanilla extract; salt. Icing: powdered sugar; butter; milk; cocoa powder. Peanut Butter Sheet Cake:
Flour; sugar; water; butter; buttermilk; peanut butter; eggs; vanilla extract; baking soda. Icing: powdered sugar; butter; milk; peanut butter; vanilla extract. JUMBO Chocolate Chip Cookies:
Flour; chocolate chips; sugar; butter; eggs; vanilla extract; baking soda; salt. JUMBO Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies:
Flour; peanut butter chips; sugar; butter; cocoa powder; eggs; vanilla extract; baking soda; salt. Italian Loaf:
Flour; milk; pepperoni; ham; salami; sugar; Italian dressing; salt; yeast; seasonings. No Bake Cookies
Whole grain rolled oats; sugar; natural cocoa; milk; pasteurized cream; roasted peanuts; contains 2% or less than of: molasses, fully hydrogenated vegetable oils (rapeseed, cottonseed, soybean); vanilla bean extractives in water; alcohol; salt

Pepperoni Rolls:
Flour; milk; pepperoni; sugar; salt; yeast; seasonings

Pepper Jack Pepperoni Rolls
Flour; milk; pepperoni; sugar; jalapeno peppers; salt; yeast; seasonings

03/23/2026
If you've been wondering where you can find me, here I am!We accept outside valid prescriptions and several vision plans...
02/25/2026

If you've been wondering where you can find me, here I am!

We accept outside valid prescriptions and several vision plans. Our frames start at $10, and we have lots of name brands.

Call or stop in to see how well we can help you see!

Pence Springs Flea Market

With the holiday baking season fast approaching, don't forget the recipes for your favorite treats are available! πŸ₯°
10/28/2025

With the holiday baking season fast approaching, don't forget the recipes for your favorite treats are available! πŸ₯°

Celebrate accordingly 😊
10/28/2025

Celebrate accordingly 😊

09/26/2025

Thank you for your purchase, Elizabeth Kirby!

If y'all miss seeing me at Pence Springs Flea Market, here's your opportunity to make some of my goodies for yourself!Wo...
09/25/2025

If y'all miss seeing me at Pence Springs Flea Market, here's your opportunity to make some of my goodies for yourself!

Works on smart phones, computers and tablets... Get yours today!

🀷🏽🀣
09/21/2025

🀷🏽🀣

09/21/2025

Thank you for your order, Chastity Boyd Via! I hope your daughter had a wonderful birthday 😊

09/18/2025

Thank you for your purchase, Sarah Jane Po***ck ❀️

It's finished! My cookbook is complete! 😁It's available in 2 formats: digital recipe cards or a PDF file. I've saved the...
09/17/2025

It's finished! My cookbook is complete! 😁

It's available in 2 formats: digital recipe cards or a PDF file.

I've saved the recipe cards in one folder called "The Chocolate Lady's Recipe Box. It's a collection of 26 recipes on 25 digital recipe cards. There's a picture of the dish, all the ingredients and their measurements, a preparation guide and tips to take your dish from "good" to "great!"

If you elect for the PDF file, instead of a digital recipe card box, you'll get a 49-page digital cookbook. It includes all the features of the cards, but in an easy-to-read book format.

The choice is yours!

Send me $10 through CashApp, send me a message on Messenger telling me you sent the payment, and I'll send you the link to the recipe collection of your choice πŸ™‚

I know I've been quiet, but I've been busy. I'm about halfway there, now...Here's a little sample 😊
09/12/2025

I know I've been quiet, but I've been busy. I'm about halfway there, now...

Here's a little sample 😊

Hold on tight! This one's going to be a long one...I knew last weekend that it could be my final set-up as The Chocolate...
09/06/2025

Hold on tight! This one's going to be a long one...

I knew last weekend that it could be my final set-up as The Chocolate Lady, but I didn't want to say anything till I was sure.

I'm sure, now.

I started The Chocolate Lady a little over three years ago to supplement my insufficient income. My full-time job was as an optician. At the end of June, I left that job to pursue baking full-time.

It's been a lot of fun and a lot of work. I've met a lot of remarkable people in the time I've spent at Pence Springs Flea Market. I told my neighbor, Barbara (the retired Marine) that if I didn't see her on Sunday it's because I got a new job. She said, "If that's what you want, I pray you'll get it."😊

If you've never tried her breads, doughnuts, cookies or pies, you should. She's a very talented baker, and she's thinking of retiring at the end of the season, so be sure to grab something before she's gone.

I heartily appreciate y'all's patronage and support πŸ’—

I'll still be available for special orders, but my set-up days are done. I may create a digital cookbook of all the recipes of all the things I've made over the years (if anyone would be interested πŸ‘€)

Till then, here's a picture of the Cookies & Cream Cupcakes I made today for one of my nieces. She told me they were "Yummy" πŸ˜‹

I told her she couldn't eat them all at once, then I asked if she was going to share them with her twin sister.

She said, "Only if she gives me 50 cents" 🀣

Like aunt, like niece 🀷🏽

Address

White Sulphur Springs, WV
24986

Telephone

+17546666761

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Chocolate Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Chocolate Lady:

Share

Category