Butter Me Up Cookie & More

Butter Me Up Cookie & More 🍪 WV Cottage Baker
💛 Spreading joy, sugar, and unhinged baking energy
✝️ Baking with faith, butter, and a thankful heart
(2)

Confession time… 😂I had the HARDEST time decorating these monster truck cookies because once my brain decided what I was...
06/04/2026

Confession time… 😂

I had the HARDEST time decorating these monster truck cookies because once my brain decided what I was looking at, I couldn’t unsee it. 🚛👀

Now I need to know… what do YOU see? 🤣

Drop your answer in the comments because I can’t be the only one whose brain plays tricks on them. 😂👇

Many of you have asked about the donated gift cards and local items collected to support Rylin and her family.Because Ry...
06/03/2026

Many of you have asked about the donated gift cards and local items collected to support Rylin and her family.

Because Rylin’s treatment will require an extended stay in NYC, many of the donated items are for local businesses the family may not be able to use right now. To best support them, these items will now be used in a Chinese raffle at the Lemonade Stand Benefit on June 12.

All proceeds from the raffle will go directly to Rylin’s family to help with medical and travel expenses during this difficult time.

If you’ve already spoken with me about donating, please know donations are still very much needed and deeply appreciated—everything is still in full swing, and every item will make a real impact.

Thank you to everyone who has donated, shared, prayed, and supported this family. ❤️

Sometimes the simplest designs take the most work. 🎾These tennis ball cookies may look straightforward, but getting that...
06/03/2026

Sometimes the simplest designs take the most work. 🎾

These tennis ball cookies may look straightforward, but getting that fuzzy tennis ball effect just right took way longer than you’d think. Every little detail matters, and sometimes it’s those extra steps that make all the difference.

Seeing them come together exactly how I imagined? Totally worth it. 💚

That’s one of my favorite parts of this job—turning a simple idea into something that makes people stop and look twice.

Who knew a tennis ball could be so much work? 😅🎾

If I’m nothing else, I’m committed to trying every trend that pops up on my feed. 😂☕️So naturally, I had to jump on the ...
06/03/2026

If I’m nothing else, I’m committed to trying every trend that pops up on my feed. 😂☕️

So naturally, I had to jump on the viral DOT iced latte train. Is it delicious? Absolutely. Did I need another thing to obsess over during the busiest season of the year? Probably not. 🤣

Right now it’s pedal to the metal around here, and I couldn’t be more thankful for every order, every share, every recommendation, and every one of you supporting my little business. ❤️

With graduation season wrapping up and summer celebrations in full swing, July is filling up FAST! If you’ve been thinking about cookies for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, or just because… now is the time to get on the calendar.

Also, I need to plan a vacation week before I accidentally schedule cookies for 365 days straight. 😂✈️🍪

Message me to reserve your July date before my calendar fills up!



:::

📚✨ Booked for June & orders are filling up fast for July! ✨📚If you have a summer birthday, graduation, bridal shower, ba...
06/02/2026

📚✨ Booked for June & orders are filling up fast for July! ✨📚

If you have a summer birthday, graduation, bridal shower, baby shower, or special event coming up, now is the time to get your order on the calendar before spots are gone!

🎓 The hassle is worth the tassel! 🎓

Celebrating Kaitlyn and all the hard work, late nights, early mornings, and determination that led to this moment. Graduation season is one of my favorite times of year because every set tells a story of dedication, growth, and a bright future ahead.

Congratulations to this JMHS graduate! Wishing you all the success and happiness as you begin your next chapter. 💙✨

🎓🍪✨

🚨 THEY’RE HERE!!! 🚨Table 304The VIRAL Dot Cakes just landed… but we didn’t stop there. 👀 We turned the trend into COOKIE...
06/01/2026

🚨 THEY’RE HERE!!! 🚨Table 304

The VIRAL Dot Cakes just landed… but we didn’t stop there. 👀 We turned the trend into COOKIES too! 🤯

If you’ve been scrolling TikTok lately, you’ve probably seen these everywhere. Tiny crunchy candy dots covering a soft, fluffy cake for the ultimate sensory experience. The combination of the soft cake and that satisfying CRUNCH is exactly why the internet is obsessed right now. ✨

And yes… the cookies have that same fun dot-covered look everyone is talking about! 🎉

That crackly crunch. That colorful pop. That ASMR-worthy bite. 😍

Whether you’re team Dot Cake or team Dot Cookie, these are one of those treats you just have to try for yourself.

📍Freshly dropped off and ready to grab while they last!

⚠️ Fair warning: these have been selling out everywhere they’re offered, so don’t wait too long.

Crunch. Snap. Smile. Repeat. 💕🍪🍰



:

There’s nothing quite like the excitement of Monster Jam through the eyes of a 4-year-old! 🏁🔥This custom birthday cookie...
05/31/2026

There’s nothing quite like the excitement of Monster Jam through the eyes of a 4-year-old! 🏁🔥

This custom birthday cookie set for Hutsyn was packed with big tires, roaring engines, and monster truck fun. From dirt-slinging jumps to crushing birthday celebrations, these cookies were made for one little truck-loving birthday boy! 🚛💨

Happy 4th Birthday, Hutsyn! Hope your day was filled with monster-sized fun, cake, and plenty of “WOW!” moments. 🎉

☕️ Hidden Gem Alert ✨If you find yourself in Steubenville, do yourself a favor and stop by Mindful Mug. Tucked inside Fi...
05/30/2026

☕️ Hidden Gem Alert ✨

If you find yourself in Steubenville, do yourself a favor and stop by Mindful Mug. Tucked inside First Westminster Presbyterian Church, this cozy little coffee spot is the kind of place that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. The coffee shop recently opened on the church’s second floor, creating a welcoming space for coffee, conversation, and community.

I tried the iced blueberry latte, and it was absolutely worth the trip. 🫐🤎 Smooth coffee, the perfect hint of blueberry, and one of those drinks you’ll be thinking about long after the last sip.

There’s just something special about discovering a place that’s a little off the beaten path. Great coffee, a warm atmosphere, and a reminder that sometimes the best spots are the ones you stumble across unexpectedly.

🕔 Mon–Fri: 7 AM–2 PM
🕗 Sat: 8 AM–2 PM

☕️🫐🤎

🚨 TREND ALERT 🚨The Viral Dot Cakes have officially been transformed into COOKIES… and trust me, you’re going to want the...
05/30/2026

🚨 TREND ALERT 🚨

The Viral Dot Cakes have officially been transformed into COOKIES… and trust me, you’re going to want these. 🤤🍪

That glossy shell. That satisfying CRUNCH. That melt-in-your-mouth center. The ASMR is next-level and every bite is pure cookie magic. ✨

These beauties will be available starting MONDAY at Table 304 and Public Market, and I have a feeling they won’t stay on the shelves for long. If you’ve been seeing these all over your feed, now is your chance to see what the hype is about!

Crisp. Crunchy. Colorful. Completely addictive.
👀🍪

Address

322 Mount Olivet Road
Wheeling, WV
26003

Telephone

+13046398777

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butter Me Up Cookie & More posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Butter Me Up Cookie & More:

Shortcuts

Share