Bethany’s Joy Treatshop

Home
United States
West Plains, MO
Bethany’s Joy Treatshop

A small artisan bakery in the Missouri Ozarks, specializing in cookie sandwiches, delicious brownies, and hot cinnamon rolls.

05/12/2026

Hello West Plains, friends! I have just restocked my famous gourmet oatmeal cream pies at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market! I have brought in fresh, and frozen for whichever you prefer. Time to get out, enjoy the sunshine, and grab you a sweet treat!

218 W Main St, open 10-5 M-F, Sat 10-2 💕

05/09/2026

Good morning West Plains! I am here to announce that it’s highly likely that that the mother in your life wants is to be fed delicious things and - very importantly - to NOT have to clean the kitchen.

And no, telling her “I don’t mind if you wait until tomorrow to clean” doesn’t count and I wouldn’t recommend telling her that.

Anyway… I’ve got half of that covered for you - come on down and grab a pack of fresh gooey cinnamon rolls to serve her for breakfast tomorrow morning. 🤩🤩🤩

They come five big rolls in a pan, pre-iced or with the icing on the side, for $12. I’m at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market at 218 W Main St and I’ll be here until 2 😊

04/30/2026

Happy Thursday yall! I know I forgot to post the other day but there is a new batch of my Oatmeal Creme Pies at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market right now… 😍🤩🥳 217 W Main, open 10-5 m-f and 10-2 Sat

❤️ Bethany

04/26/2026

Would y’all be interested in a hot cinnamon roll popup the day before Mother’s Day?

So… I have scaled back my baking because I really NEED to get my house on the market but I am absolutely itching to do stuff. I will be at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market from 10-2 on that day anyway and I was thinking I could make a big ol batch of cinnamon rolls - either for you to take home with you then or as a “brown and serve” option for breakfast.

I was thinking, original cinnamon of course, biscoff cookie butter, and maybe a lemon blueberry variation. Or banana bread or Oreo or Brownie swirl or so many different ones 🤣🤣🤣

What do you guys think? Is that something the mother in your life would enjoy?

(Pictured: Orange Creamsicle)

04/15/2026

Handmade gourmet Oatmeal Creme pies are restocked at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market! Look for the yellow Bethany’s Joy label 😍

And yes a day late because I had my days confused & completely spaced doing them yesterday 🤣

218 W Main St, M-F 10-5, Sat 10-2. Enjoy!!

03/25/2026

Hey West Plains! I just dropped off a fresh batch of oatmeal Creme pies at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market! M-F 10-5, Sat 10-2 at 218 W Main st. 💕

And just fyi - for the next few months, my menu will be limited to just those… I’ll keep them in stock but not much else cuz I got a lot to do to get my house ready to sell! 🤪

03/17/2026

Hey West Plains! Just letting you all know that I have restocked oatmeal cream pies, some big hefty chunks of Amish friendship bread, and some absolutely freaking amazing soft sugar cookies with lemon icing 🤩🤩🤩

Come get ya some! West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market at 218 W Main st, open M-F 10-5 and Sat 10-2 🥰

03/14/2026

Hey West Plains! Just a heads up tomorrow I am going to be at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market at 10am with fresh hot cinnamon rolls! I'll be bringing my Orange Cream icing (in the video) and my classic vanilla bean icing. And it will be the LAST Saturday I'll be bringing them in for a while because I'm gonna be scaling back a little on my baking while I get my house ready to sell.

SO - I'll be there 10-2 with cinnamon rolls and MAYBE some of my chewy old fashioned blondies if I get them done on time ❤️ It'll be a beautiful day - come out and see me!!

03/06/2026

Hey West Plains! These are the very same carnitas tacos that converted my child from a "I don't like pork!" child to a "Mom can we go get some of Jeff's tacos PLEASEPLEASEPLEASE" child 😋🌮 and the gumbo is my personal favorite so you definitely don't wanna miss that! he'll be set up until 3 or sold out at the old LNG autos lot!

03/03/2026

Hi friends! I’m feeling a bit under the weather today so I won’t be doing a restock today at the West Plains Farmers & Artisans Market. Hopefully tomorrow but I will keep yall posted!

Address

110 Saint Louis St
West Plains, MO
65775

Website

https://bethanysjoy.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bethany’s Joy Treatshop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bethany’s Joy Treatshop:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery in West Plains?