Eggs and Butter Cookie Co.

Eggs and Butter Cookie Co. 🍪Making it a butter place with eggscellent cookies!
🍪Serving Wesley Chapel, Fl and surrounding areas!
🍪Now taking orders for March!

Allow me to introduce myself—I’m Jessica, the baker and creative spirit behind Eggs and Butter Cookie Co. Operating from my home kitchen as a cottage baker, I specialize in personalized sugar cookies that add a custom touch to life’s sweetest moments. While my heart belongs to my wonderful husband and our little ones, the rest of my passion goes straight into the mixer—where every batch is crafted

with care, creativity, and a whole lot of love. Eggs and Butter is continually growing, with exciting plans to expand the menu and offer even more delicious options. Let’s create something sweet together—one cookie at a time.

A sweet little pastel set for a very special 9 year old girl 🥹💜🎂Homeschooling has definitely been keeping my hands full ...
05/16/2026

A sweet little pastel set for a very special 9 year old girl 🥹💜🎂

Homeschooling has definitely been keeping my hands full lately, but wow have I missed this part of me. Getting my footing back in icing again has been equal parts exciting and humbling 😂🍪

Also… apparently my cookie business is now a scammer hotspot because WHY have I gotten 9 scam order messages in 3 days😭 Sir, I’m just trying to decorate cookies, not get scammed over imaginary overpayment checks 😂

More happy teachers being spoiled this Teacher Appreciation Week🥹🍪A huge thank you to Jersey College School of Nursing f...
05/07/2026

More happy teachers being spoiled this Teacher Appreciation Week🥹🍪

A huge thank you to Jersey College School of Nursing for pouring so much love, patience, caffeine, and knowledge into the future rockstars that take care of all of us👏🏼 Seriously… nurses deserve trophies, naps, AND cookies😂

And a little extra shoutout to my girls’ bonus mama who’s working so hard toward graduation right now🥹 We are SO proud of you and cheering you on every step of the way🤍

I had the absolute honor of baking a tonnn of cookies for the amazing teachers at Centennial Elementary School!! Happy T...
05/06/2026

I had the absolute honor of baking a tonnn of cookies for the amazing teachers at Centennial Elementary School!! Happy Teacher Appreciation Week winners!! 🥹🍪

The love, patience, and heart you pour into your students every single day does not go unnoticed. You shape little minds, build confidence, and make such a lasting impact.

I’m so incredibly grateful I got to play even a small part in celebrating YOU this week. Being able to spoil some of these hardworking teachers with cookies was truly the sweetest feeling. 💛

You deserve it all… and then some. 🍪✨

The past month has brought some big, meaningful changes for our family. We’ve made the personal decision to bring our gi...
02/03/2026

The past month has brought some big, meaningful changes for our family. We’ve made the personal decision to bring our girls home to homeschool, and my husband has an upcoming surgery this month that’s approaching quickly. Both have required a lot of thought, prayer, and heart and we feel at peace with the path we’re on.

I want to be very clear that my appreciation for teachers remains incredibly strong. Teachers pour so much into their students every single day, and this decision was simply what felt right for our family.

As we prepare for my husband’s surgery, we are deeply grateful for the love, encouragement, and support from our friends and family. We would truly appreciate any prayers for a smooth procedure and a successful recovery.

Because of these changes, I’ll be stepping back for a while as we get settled and focus on family and have had to rearrange our February schedule. I currently have two orders scheduled for March and will, of course, be fulfilling our Teacher Appreciation Giveaway in May. Aside from those commitments, I won’t be accepting new orders for the foreseeable future.

Thank you for always being so kind, understanding, and supportive. Wishing each of you a beautiful 2026 filled with happiness, health, and many blessings. 🤍

— Jessica
Eggs & Butter Cookie Co. 🍪

🎉🍪 CONGRATULATIONS, Centennial Elementary School! 🍪🎉You did it!! I’m so excited to celebrate the amazing teachers at Cen...
01/31/2026

🎉🍪 CONGRATULATIONS, Centennial Elementary School! 🍪🎉

You did it!! I’m so excited to celebrate the amazing teachers at Centennial Elementary School, one of our awesome Pasco County schools. Your hard work, heart, and school spirit seriously showed UP! 💪✨

I’ll be reaching out soon to the wonderful human who submitted Centennial, Rebecca G., to touch base! I cannot wait to shower these teachers with some well-deserved treats and cookie love 🥰

Thank you to everyone who participated, voted, shared, and rallied behind your schools. The school spirit was LOUD and I loved every second of it. 💛🍎

It’s the LAST day to vote!! 🎉 Get those votes in by tonight! The winning school gets its cookie crown tomorrow 👑🍪 I’m so...
01/30/2026

It’s the LAST day to vote!! 🎉 Get those votes in by tonight! The winning school gets its cookie crown tomorrow 👑🍪 I’m so excited to make Teacher Appreciation Week a little sweeter for one amazing school. Trust me, I wish I could spoil them all because every teacher out there deserves ALL the love! 💕

So excited for all the schools participating in the giveaway — teachers, you are AMAZING. If I could win free groceries ...
01/21/2026

So excited for all the schools participating in the giveaway — teachers, you are AMAZING. If I could win free groceries for life and clone myself a few times to spoil you all, I would 😅💛 Don’t worry though… there will be more chances to love on our teachers throughout the year!

I’m also so excited to start working on the donation order for the Pasco County Fair 🐄🍪 The kids in the Livestock Show have worked incredibly hard, and my family can’t wait to sweeten their day. Be sure to go out, cheer them on, and show them some love — our youth is doing big things!

As for custom orders ✨ my availability will be very limited for a bit as my family walks through some big moments and changes. Family over sweets always 🤍 That said, you’ll still see me baking here and there because it’s a true passion — and there will likely be more giveaways and fun flash sales popping up. Please don’t hesitate to reach out… I still love being part of your special moments and getting creative with cookies 🫶🍪

✨ BOOKED & SO GRATEFUL ✨January and February are officially FULL 🤍 I only opened a few February spots with my husband’s ...
01/18/2026

✨ BOOKED & SO GRATEFUL ✨

January and February are officially FULL 🤍 I only opened a few February spots with my husband’s upcoming surgery (please keep him in your prayers 🙏) and a big, fun donation order for the amazing kiddos working their tails off for the Pasco County Fair Livestock Show 🐄✨

I may sneak in some lovable grab-and-go Valentine’s goodies if time allows 💕

💌 March is OPEN and booking now — let’s get your special day on the calendar!
Thank you endlessly for the love and support 🖤🍪

🍎✨ Teacher Appreciation Week GIVEAWAY Update! ✨🍎Entries close TONIGHT, so make sure you’re tagging, texting, nudging, an...
01/17/2026

🍎✨ Teacher Appreciation Week GIVEAWAY Update! ✨🍎

Entries close TONIGHT, so make sure you’re tagging, texting, nudging, and politely reminding your favorite school staff members to fill out their entry form before the day ends! 👀📋

I’m SO excited because voting opens Monday and we’ll have 9 amazing schools so far going up for the community to vote on! 🎉🗳️
Make sure you’re checking in, sharing, and casting those votes all week long!

I seriously cannot wait to spoil some incredible teachers and school staff this May — they deserve ALL the cookies 💛🍪

Let the appreciation begin! 💫

Entry Form!

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfLDtbRq3mLn1PKlS5imY_yjUhBvsqx3TNOEbd2zajZ2yotTw/viewform

Huge thank you to the sweetest mama for trusting me to make cookies for her son’s birthday! Getting to be part of these ...
01/16/2026

Huge thank you to the sweetest mama for trusting me to make cookies for her son’s birthday! Getting to be part of these big kid celebrations is such a fun part of what I do.

Hope his birthday is a total end-zone celebration with plenty of cheese-head approval 🧀🏈✨

Address

Wesley Chapel, FL

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 7pm
Tuesday 9am - 7:01pm
Wednesday 9am - 7pm
Thursday 9am - 7pm
Friday 9am - 7pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

+18133125645

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Eggs and Butter Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Eggs and Butter Cookie Co.:

Share

Category