Sugar 'n Spice Cheesecakes & Coffee

Call Directions Website

Sugar 'n Spice Cheesecakes & Coffee Sugar 'n Spice Cheesecakes & Coffee Everything we create is artfully prepared, and made from scratch, using the finest, tastiest ingredients.

Sugar ‘n Spice Cheesecakes, LLC is central Wisconsin's premier provider of freshly made, beautifully designed, delicious cheesecakes.

I learned something new this week and it’s that - haters gonna hate. 😡😤The amount of disdain we have received because ou...
10/17/2026

I learned something new this week and it’s that - haters gonna hate. 😡😤

The amount of disdain we have received because our drinking the month is written on a post it note and stuck to the register is bonkers. 🤣🤣🤣

Enough so that I’m tempted to double down on the sticky note menus and just leave it. 😆😜

We’re featuring the jumbo cheesecakes today:
~ triple chocolate
~ salted caramel
~ chocolate pb
~ French silk
~ chunky fudge brownie
~ lemon bar
~ snickers
~ white chocolate raspberry
~ vanilla bean
~ pistachio

Here just til three today proud that at least our sign isn’t made by AI. 🤖 🤣🤣🤣

Out of these three - who do you think watched at least 170 games this year, knows every single player’s nick name and ha...
10/16/2026

Out of these three - who do you think watched at least 170 games this year, knows every single player’s nick name and hair style, has contemplated a second home in Milwaukee for retirement, can tell when those abs challenges will be used (any time El Gary is at the plate), has favorite announcers (and it's not the guy who says 'in all of baseball' just about in every sentence..., and why Megill always spikes the ball off the mound to the dug out ~ because that ball is all out of strikes (obviously).

And who just wanted to wear anything but a work shirt today… 🤣🤣🤣

"They may have a bunch of Hall of Famers, but we have a bunch of gamers”

Slice line up for today:
- apple crisp
- turtle
- pb chipper
- vanilla bean
- apple sundae

Here til six today and off to see if I can trade a kidney for a World Series tix. Problem is I already have away one kidney 🫘… so my options are quite limited. 🤣🤣🤣

If cheesecake slices had a homecoming dance, this would be the proud mama photo I posted of my handsome young men. 👔 (pl...
10/15/2026

If cheesecake slices had a homecoming dance, this would be the proud mama photo I posted of my handsome young men. 👔 (please note that in this analogy all of my cheesecake children none of them are going with a date 💃😬)

Slice line up includes:
- pumpkin
- French silk
- peanut butter ripple

Cream puffs are still in the making but will be available as soon as I make up my mind on what flavor to make them… 🙄

Here til six tonight wondering why my core is so sore. Never mind. I know why. I went to the dentist this morning (which is not my fav) and I realized after the fact that I planked so hard the entirety of the appt that my cheeks 🍑 never touched the back of the chair. 🤣 Free work out I guess.

What a fun night of weaving! Six students wove their Garden & Gather baskets last night at Sugar ‘n Spice, and every one...
10/15/2026

What a fun night of weaving! Six students wove their Garden & Gather baskets last night at Sugar ‘n Spice, and every one of them did a great job. 🙌 Cheesecake , good company, and the Brewers game on in the background made it a perfect evening. Thank you to everyone who came! 💛

Are ‘sports bakeries’ like a thing? Like a sports bar but for bake shoppes like mine?Cuz if not, I think I’m going to ma...
10/15/2026

Are ‘sports bakeries’ like a thing? Like a sports bar but for bake shoppes like mine?

Cuz if not, I think I’m going to make it happen.

🧹🧹🧹❔🤨

And here I said I’d never use ai… but to be fair the original photo they was sent to me to use in today’s post may or ma...
10/14/2026

And here I said I’d never use ai… but to be fair the original photo they was sent to me to use in today’s post may or may not have included a large chef knife 🔪 🙄🤣😬 and the magic 🪄 wand seems a little less aggressive.

Layered cakes for the day include:
- chocolate with blueberry 🫐 cheesecake
- vanilla with strawberry cheesecake
- chocolate with Oreo cheesecake

I’ll be here today until six tonight and then we’re off to weave the gathering basket 🧺. (You’ll be able to find me hiding in the back screaming at the tv though. ⚾️🏟️🧢

-

Big orders don’t scare us - not even last minute ones. What does scare me though - bleach stains on my favorite jeans, e...
10/13/2026

Big orders don’t scare us - not even last minute ones.

What does scare me though - bleach stains on my favorite jeans, espresso dripped into my high tops, answering the phone, slippery sidewalks, Friday or Sunday weddings, property taxes, and centipedes. Centipedes are ranked #1 on the fear factor scale.

Slices for the day include:

- making his grand debut- pumpkin 🎃 cinnamon roll with cream cheese frosting 🧁

- creamy hot chocolate

- turtle

- wild berry

Here til six tonight trying to relax since there are no brewers games.

Take a guess what our new fall favorite is going to be. Never mind I’ll tell you: pumpkin cinnamon roll (It’s for those ...
10/12/2026

Take a guess what our new fall favorite is going to be.

Never mind I’ll tell you: pumpkin cinnamon roll

(It’s for those of us who want to pretend we love all things fall and pumpkin but actually don’t 😬🤣🤣)

Oh shoot. It totally broke on accident (probably) 🙄Guess I gotta eat it now. Come get your smoothies and iced lattes sin...
10/10/2026

Oh shoot. It totally broke on accident (probably) 🙄

Guess I gotta eat it now.

Come get your smoothies and iced lattes since it’s summer again!

Slice and jumbo line up includes:
- white chocolate raspberry
- turtle mudslide
- Oreo avalanche
- cherry
- chocolate peanut butter
- caramel apple
- snickers
- chocolate birthday cake

Here til three today setting up interviews for the upcoming busy holiday season. Feel free to send me an email for an application. Looking for barista and baking help. 😉 I know I’m a tad bit biased but if you’re going to have to be at work anyway, free espresso and all the broken cookies you could ever need seems like not the worst option.

Address

108 S. 2nd Avenue
Wausau, WI
54401

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 6pm
Wednesday 9am - 6pm
Thursday 9am - 6pm
Friday 9am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

+17159077672

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar 'n Spice Cheesecakes & Coffee posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share