The Cake Lady

The Cake Lady Custom desserts for every occasion! At least 2-week notice is required. Last-minute orders are based on availability. Desserts for all occasions!!

Order anytime at thecakeladyonline.net ✨

Thank you,
Sarah Haverstock-Owner Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Brownies, Strawberries, Cakes, Shooter Cups and lot more!!

If you need bbq today this is it!! Im addicted!! Juicy , tender, perfect 👌 Uppercut Prime Meats And Grilling Supplies o...
05/30/2026

If you need bbq today this is it!! Im addicted!! Juicy , tender, perfect 👌 Uppercut Prime Meats And Grilling Supplies open til 4pm!!

Hey friends!! 💕The Cottage will be closed this week while we finish up landscaping and a few other projects to get every...
05/27/2026

Hey friends!! 💕
The Cottage will be closed this week while we finish up landscaping and a few other projects to get everything ready for summer!

While we’re working, I’d love your input!
✨ What are your favorite days to shop?
✨ What are your favorite things to get from The Cottage?
I can’t wait to hear what everyone loves most! 🩷

Also, my husband was able to work on the landscape before he leaves for Seattle!! Thank you everyone for your landscaper suggestions!

SOLD OUT!! WOW!! What a day!! 🥰 Friday open til sold out!Just a few dozen cupcake packs left!! Decorated in red, white, ...
05/22/2026

SOLD OUT!! WOW!! What a day!! 🥰 Friday open til sold out!
Just a few dozen cupcake packs left!! Decorated in red, white, and blue!

Thursday SOLD OUT!! REOPEN Friday at 11am!! Memorial day cupcake packs- vanilla and chocolate onlyCookies- sugar with sp...
05/21/2026

Thursday SOLD OUT!! REOPEN Friday at 11am!!
Memorial day cupcake packs
- vanilla and chocolate only
Cookies
- sugar with sprinkles
Cheesecake slices
And more!

SOLD OUT Thursday!! The Cottage is open!! Thursday and Friday 11am-8pm OR sold out!!Bundt cakes👌Dubai❤️Red velvet 🫐Lemon...
05/21/2026

SOLD OUT Thursday!! The Cottage is open!! Thursday and Friday 11am-8pm OR sold out!!
Bundt cakes
👌Dubai
❤️Red velvet
🫐Lemon Blueberry
🍋Lemon
🔥Raspberry lemon
🤩White reeses
💓Oreo
😋Biscoff
🥜Oreo peanut butter
🍫Triple chocolate
🥜Chocolate peanut butter

Tres leches
🍓Strawberry
🥰Oreo

Cheesecake cups- (no bake Cheesecake)
🥰Oreo
🍓Strawberry
🍋Lime
🫐Blueberry
👌Dubai
🥜Peanut butter
😍Biscoff

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
👌Mint chip
🍫Ganache

Cookies
🥳Sugar
🍪Pecan chocolate chip
🍪M&M

And lots of chocolate dipped items!!

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road
💲Cash, cards, venmo, paypal, cash app

Surprise!! This week we will be open on Thursday AND Friday!!! 11am-8pm. Thursday is bundt cake day plus all the other f...
05/19/2026

Surprise!! This week we will be open on Thursday AND Friday!!! 11am-8pm.
Thursday is bundt cake day plus all the other favorites!! I haven't had a bundt cake day in a while so I will be making lots!!
Friday is cupcake day plus all the other favorites!!
🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💲Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

Looking for recommendations on landscapers to finish The Cottage landscape! Would love to use a local small business!! W...
05/17/2026

Looking for recommendations on landscapers to finish The Cottage landscape! Would love to use a local small business!! Would like something similar to the pic below.

3pm Saturday update!! We still have🧁cupcakes👌cheesecakes, ❤️mini cheesecake packs, 🍭 Cakesicles🍪cookies left!! Open lat...
05/16/2026

3pm Saturday update!!
We still have
🧁cupcakes
👌cheesecakes,
❤️mini cheesecake packs,
🍭 Cakesicles
🍪cookies left!!
Open late tonight!! 🤩
We will be closed tomorrow and next weekend!
💲Cash, cards, venmo, cashapp, paypal

3pm update!! We're restocked!!We're open!! Saturday 11am-8pm or sold out. We have plenty of desserts today!Cheesecake sl...
05/16/2026

3pm update!! We're restocked!!
We're open!! Saturday 11am-8pm or sold out. We have plenty of desserts today!
Cheesecake slices
Tres leches
Cupcake packs
Loaded brownies
Cookies
Mini Cheesecake packs
And more!

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw

💲Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

05/14/2026

Hey friends! 💕
I’ve been getting a lot of questions about how to place orders, so I wanted to clear a few things up!
Something changed on my page recently, and now every time someone comments on a post, it automatically sends that comment to me as a message. I’ve tried changing the settings and even contacting Facebook, but I haven’t been able to fix it yet. Because of that, there are some days where I end up with hundreds of Facebook messages alone.
So to keep things simpler and more organized, my website is now the best way to place an order or inquiry.
On the inquiry tab of my website, you can:
• See my availability calendar
• Choose your date and pickup time
• Include what you’d like to order in the message box
You can also find base pricing on there!

Having everything go through one place helps me stay organized, respond faster, and makes it much easier if anything needs changed later on. 💕

We are also currently building a brand new website that will make ordering even easier for everyone! So getting everyone used to ordering through the website now will really help once the new one is ready too!

I hope this clears some things up, and as always, thank you all so much for your support, patience, and kindness! ❤️

Address

2475 E. Pierceton Road
Warsaw, IN
46580

Telephone

+15742532705

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cake Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cake Lady:

Shortcuts

Share

Category