The Cake Lady

Call Directions Website Contact the business

The Cake Lady Custom desserts for every occasion! At least 2-week notice is required. Last-minute orders are based on availability. Desserts for all occasions!!

Order anytime at thecakeladyonline.net ✨

Thank you,
Sarah Haverstock-Owner Cheesecakes, Cupcakes, Cookies, Brownies, Strawberries, Cakes, Shooter Cups and lot more!!

Happy Sunday!! We are open today with a small stock! 11am-sold out!Sugared riot still has fudge available also! If you ...
10/18/2026

Happy Sunday!! We are open today with a small stock! 11am-sold out!
Sugared riot still has fudge available also! If you stopped by and didn't have cash yesterday you're in luck! She can now accept venmo and cash app!! Stop by and pick up some yummy treats!! Buy a box of fudge and get a $10 square FREE!!

🎂Bundt cakes
🍫Brownies
🥜Pb buckeyes
✨️Cheesecake
🍫Fudge
📍2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw

6pm Saturday update!! We have bundt cakes, mini cheesecakes, Sugared Riot Fudge, and a few other things left! We will...
10/17/2026

6pm Saturday update!! We have bundt cakes, mini cheesecakes, Sugared Riot Fudge, and a few other things left! We will stay open until 8pm!

Saturday 3pm update!! Lots of treats left!
10/17/2026

Saturday 3pm update!! Lots of treats left!

3pm update!! Lots of goodies left!! Happy Saturday! The Cottage is open 12pm-8pm or sold out. Another fully stocked day!...
10/17/2026

3pm update!! Lots of goodies left!! Happy Saturday! The Cottage is open 12pm-8pm or sold out. Another fully stocked day!! Sugared Riot is also here with lots of fudge!

Bundt cakes
🤎Pumpkin Spice
🫐Lemon Blueberry
🍋Lemon
🔥Vanilla
🤩White reeses
💓Oreo
😋Apple C***r
🍫Triple chocolate
🥜Chocolate peanut butter
🎂Funfetti
🍪Chocolate chip
🍫Chocolate
✋️White reeses

Tres leches
🍓Strawberry
🥰Dulce De Leche
🍭Fruity Pebbles

Cheesecake Slices
🤎Turtle
✨️Biscoff
🍓Strawberry
🍫Double chocolate
🥜Peanut butter
🍪Cookie dough
❤️Raspberry swirl
😋Salted Caramel
🍎Apple streusel
🫐Blueberry

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
👌Mint chip
🍫Pecan Pie

Cookies
🥳Sugar
🍪 chocolate chip
🤎Snickerdoodle

🧁Assorted cupcake packs- NEW FLAVORS!! APPLE C***R AND CINNAMON MAPLE BUTTER PECAN

🧁Vanilla and chocolate only cupcake packs

🎂Whole 6 inch cakes

🥜🍫Peanut Butter Buckeyes🍫🥜

🚨🚨Sugared Riot Fudge is cash only. She has $10 boxes, $12 boxes, and $18 boxes. Please pay for her items separately in the cash box on her table.

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road

💲Cash, cards, venmo, paypal, cash app. (The Cottage treats only)

10/16/2026

The Cottage is open!! October 16th&17th! Friday and Saturday 12pm-7pm or sold out. We're fully Loaded!!

Bundt cakes
🤎Pumpkin Spice
🫐Lemon Blueberry
🍋Lemon
🔥Vanilla
🤩White reeses
💓Oreo
😋Biscoff
🍫Triple chocolate
🥜Chocolate peanut butter
🎂Funfetti
🍪Chocolate chip
🍫Chocolate
✋️White reeses

Tres leches
🍓Strawberry
🥰Dulce De Leche

Cheesecake Slices
🤎Turtle
✨️Biscoff
🍓Strawberry
🍫Double chocolate
🥜Peanut butter
🍪Cookie dough
❤️Raspberry swirl
😋Salted Caramel
🍎Apple streusel
🫐Blueberry

Brownies
🥜Peanut butter
👌Mint chip
🍫Ganache

Cookies
🥳Sugar
🍪 chocolate chip
🤎Snickerdoodle

🧁Assorted cupcake packs

🧁Vanilla and chocolate only cupcake packs

🎂Whole 6 inch cakes

🏡2475 E. Pierceton Road
💲Cash, cards, venmo, paypal, cash app

Hey friends!! 🩷The Cottage will be open Friday and Saturday from 12pm–8pm or until sold out!!😍😋Menu😋 🍰 BUNDT CAKES ARE C...
10/13/2026

Hey friends!! 🩷
The Cottage will be open Friday and Saturday from 12pm–8pm or until sold out!!😍

😋Menu😋
🍰 BUNDT CAKES ARE COMING BACK!
🎂Whole 6 inch cakes
🍰 Cheesecake slices
🧁 Cupcake packs- Assorted and plain
🍫 Loaded brownies
🍪 Cookies
🍰 Mini cheesecake packs
🤎Pumpkin Roll slices
🌟Tres Leches
And maybe more if time allows!

Don't forget, Sugared Riot will be joining us on Saturday with a table full of delicious fudge!! 🤎

Just a reminder, her fudge will be cash only. There will be a separate cash box on her table. Payments will need to be made separately from The Cottage purchases!

Can't wait to see everyone this weekend!! 🥰
📍2475 E. Pierceton Road Warsaw
💵Cash, cards, venmo, cash app, paypal

📸 sheet cake from last weekend!! ❤️😍🦢

Hey friends!! ❤️ We've been keeping a secret!! 🤫I've been wanting to do this for a while now, and I'm finally ready to m...
10/12/2026

Hey friends!! ❤️ We've been keeping a secret!! 🤫

I've been wanting to do this for a while now, and I'm finally ready to make it happen!!

I'm so excited to announce that I'll be offering FREE vendor spots inside The Cottage!! 🏡❤️
Don't worry, all my usual goodies will still be available!! This is just an extra treat!

My idea is to feature a different small business each week, or rotate between a few, to help get their names and products out there! The Cottage has received so much love and support from our community, and I would love to share some of that support with other small businesses!

And our first guest is.... Sugared Riot!! 🎉

A couple weeks ago she brought me some samples and they were great! I cant wait for you guys to try them.

She will have LOADED FUDGE available in The Cottage this Saturday!! 🤤❤️

Please note that all fudge payments need to go directly to Sugared Riot, not The Cottage! Payment options will be listed.

I'm so excited to see where this goes and hopefully help some other small businesses grow along the way!!

More information on future vendor opportunities coming soon!! ❤️ PLUS a few more surprises for the holidays!! 🎅🎄📸

Address

2475 E. Pierceton Road
Warsaw, IN
46580

Telephone

+15742532705

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cake Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cake Lady:

Shortcuts

Share

Category