Mama's Custom Cookies

Mama's Custom Cookies Mama's Custom Cookies hand creates delicious, personalized, custom cookies for any occasion. Please note: Availability is subject to change.

We ask for at least two weeks lead time for order, but are happy to accept an order if we have availability. We highly recommend booking your date as soon as possible. Orders placed less than 14 days lead time will incur a rush order fee. Payment for orders is due 14 days before the scheduled pick up/ shipping date. If payment is not received the order will be canceled. We are unable to send remin

ders for payment. Cancelations within the 14 days to the scheduled pick up/ shipping date are non refundable. Rush orders may incur a rush order fee and we do ask for payment in full.

Graduation Inspo🎓Swipe for ideas! ➡️🍪
03/26/2026

Graduation Inspo🎓

Swipe for ideas! ➡️🍪

Truckin' into 2! 😉🚚❤🍪Happy Birthday Thomas🎉
03/25/2026

Truckin' into 2! 😉🚚❤🍪
Happy Birthday Thomas🎉

One Silly Goose! 🦆🎈🍪
03/25/2026

One Silly Goose! 🦆🎈🍪

It's Paw-ty Time! 🐾 Celebrating ONE with the whole rescue crew💜🍪
03/25/2026

It's Paw-ty Time! 🐾 Celebrating ONE with the whole rescue crew💜🍪

⛪Religious Cookie Inspo✝️Swipe for ideas! ➡️🍪
03/25/2026

⛪Religious Cookie Inspo✝️

Swipe for ideas! ➡️🍪

CAUTION⚠️: May cause a sugar rush!😉🍪
03/25/2026

CAUTION⚠️: May cause a sugar rush!😉🍪

Once upon a time...👑🍪🐉
03/24/2026

Once upon a time...👑🍪🐉

Soft florals & teacups for a sweet baby girl🌸🍵👶
03/24/2026

Soft florals & teacups for a sweet baby girl🌸🍵👶

It's Fun to be One! 🎈🎉🍪
03/23/2026

It's Fun to be One! 🎈🎉🍪

🏒🎈🧡
03/23/2026

🏒🎈🧡

Address

3335A Park Avenue
Wantagh, NY
11793

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 1pm

Telephone

+15166702768

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mama's Custom Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category