New York Bagel Cafe - Brookside

New York Bagel Cafe - Brookside *formerly Old School Bagel Cafe
(838)

Joe Trizza, along with his brother, Scott, and friend, Paul Sorrentino, have brought back true New York 'boiled and baked' bagels to Tulsa. Please come by and enjoy a quality bagel made the "New York Bagel way", along with our great delicatessen, fresh salads and popular, homemade cookies.

07/30/2026

Balance is everything. 😌🥯

07/28/2026

Good coffee. Fresh bagels. A patio worth sitting on.

Sounds like a pretty good day to us. 😌🥯

07/27/2026

Not everyone is going to come get a bagel from us... And that’s okay.

People make mistakes. 🤷‍♂️🥯

We’ll be here when they’re ready to make better decisions.

Think catering is just sandwiches? Think again. 🥯 From breakfast spreads and boxed lunches to soups, salads, potato bar...
07/24/2026

Think catering is just sandwiches?

Think again. 🥯

From breakfast spreads and boxed lunches to soups, salads, potato bars, sweet treats, deli platters, and more, we’ve got something for every meeting, celebration, and event.

Order online, order through EZCater, or give us a call. We’ll help make feeding your group the easiest part of your day.

07/23/2026

The allegations are true.

Fresh bagels. Great coffee. Even better pastries. 🤷‍♂️

Guess you’ll have to judge for yourself.

07/21/2026

Life gets busy. Luckily, bagels don’t judge. 🥯

We’ll save you a seat.

07/20/2026

Great food doesn’t happen by accident.

It starts with quality ingredients, takes a little time, and ends with something you’ll be thinking about long after the last bite. 👀

Planning your next meeting, office lunch, or event? We’ve made catering easy. 🥯 Order online, order through EZCater, or...
07/17/2026

Planning your next meeting, office lunch, or event? We’ve made catering easy. 🥯

Order online, order through EZCater, or give the shop a call.

However you order, we’ll make sure your crew is well fed. We’ll handle the food—you take the credit.

07/15/2026

Patio season in Tulsa just hits different ☀️🥯

Fresh bagels, iced coffee, good weather, and your favorite people... sounds like a pretty solid plan to us.

Grab a seat and stay awhile—we’ll take care of the rest.

07/14/2026

Ordering catering has never been easier 🥯

Need breakfast for the office? Lunch for a meeting? Food for your next event?

Choose your favorite way to order:
✔️ Order online
✔️ Text us
✔️ Find us on EZCater

Fresh bagels, sandwiches, pastries, coffee, and more—ready when you need them. Now the hardest part is deciding what to order.

Address

3723 S Peoria Avenue
Tulsa, OK
74105

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 3pm
Tuesday 6am - 3pm
Wednesday 6am - 3pm
Thursday 6am - 3pm
Friday 6am - 3pm
Saturday 6am - 3pm
Sunday 7am - 3pm

Telephone

+19187437400

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when New York Bagel Cafe - Brookside posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to New York Bagel Cafe - Brookside:

Shortcuts

Share

Category