https://www.facebook.com/981348372040334/

Third Day Bakery

Home
United States
Sullivan, WI
Third Day Bakery

We specialize in sourdough breads and other baked goods. Every order is custom made. See FAQs under “About” for more information. FAQS

Who are you?

I bake by appointment only and generally your order will be ready in the afternoons M-F. My name is Karen. I've been baking sourdough for over 14 years with the same starter I got directly from San Francisco in 2008. I am a stay at home mom and bake out of my home as a hobby. I started selling bread in 2018 to friends and neighbors once others tasted my handmade bread. Because I make each loaf individually, every loaf is made to order and can be somewhat customized to your desires. Do you have loaves ready to pick up every day? I do everything by custom order, so, no, I do not have loaves ready to pick up. I make a limited number of loaves per week, so I will need to schedule your loaf. Please allow a minimum of 3 days notice for orders. I may be able to get it done sooner, but I cannot guarantee it especially if I am booked with other orders. When you want to order, we will work together to figure out the best day for your schedule and mine. Where are you located? I am in the town of Sullivan, WI. When you place an order, I will give you the address for pick-up. When and where is pick up? Pick up is in the town of Sullivan, usually at or after 4pm M-F. Occasionally I can arrange a Saturday pick up if my family's schedule allows. I do not bake or do pick ups on Sundays because that is our family’s day of worship and rest. How can I place an order? Simply send me a message or email me at [email protected] to order. Do you deliver or do meet-ups? I am not able to deliver or do meet-ups. How can I order cinnamon rolls? At the current time, I am unable to make my coveted cinnamon rolls! I'm sorry for the inconvenience for those of you that have bought and love my rolls. Why is your name Third Day Bakery? I named our bakery Third Day Bakery for a few reasons. First and foremost is because we believe in Jesus Christ who died for our sins and was raised from the dead on the 3rd Day! Secondly, God created plants on the 3rd day of creation, including wheat and other grains. Thirdly, it takes about 3 days to culture, form, and bake a sourdough loaf, so your loaf is ready on the 3rd day. Lastly, we're an adoptive family, and our daughter was born on the 3rd day after we were chosen by her gift family to adopt her. We love talking adoption and telling our story of God's goodness to us through both natural birth and adoption. Do you make gluten free baked goods? I currently do not sell any gluten free options. However, the long fermentation process of sourdough aids in digestion and tolerance of gluten. There are some studies showing that people who are mildly or moderately gluten intolerant can in fact tolerate sourdough baked goods. In light of this, I do have customers who can’t eat commercial or traditional yeast breads who love my bread. However, please do your own research and check with your healthcare professionals if you have known gluten intolerances or allergies before consuming wheat products.

08/01/2026

I’m still here and still baking bread. Let me know if you want me to bake for you!

02/04/2026

Pretty loaves today.

10/30/2025

Sourdough definitely holds benefits for gut microbiomes and those with some gluten sensitivities. I even had one customer tell me recently that she can tolerate my sourdough bread better than others she's tried in the area.
I'm here for the sourdough journey with you! Let me know if I can bake for you.

https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/blog/2025/10/20/is-sourdough-bread-healthy?fbclid=IwY2xjawNwmIdleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBicmlkETFLOW84U1c5Y0FiMzJ6ZldkAR4Em5oJIDGqdQP9fwfxIvpWYnIxwLjfZnqm9PuXzzzX2ANfPc5gJTC2ISLrag_aem_F8ZBTxvkaDTKBCctG_Wtxg

Stories from gluten-free bakers who eat sourdough have led us to wonder: Is sourdough bread “healthier” than other types of bread?

10/27/2025

Patty melts with caramelized onions on sourdough rye. It’s what’s for dinner! My 3 year old loved it so much he ate an entire patty melt!
Message me to order a loaf for some dinner deliciousness this week! $9/loaf made sandwich style.

10/16/2025

I’ll be making classic sourdough for pick up Saturday. Message me to reserve a loaf- I only have a few slots left open! $7/loaf

09/15/2025

Just Sold!!!! Message me to order one soon!

Who wants a Better with Cheddar sourdough loaf tomorrow?! They’re amazing with soup or to make grilled cheese sandwiches with. Or just eat toasted with butter. Add an over easy egg for an extra delicious breakfast. $11.

09/04/2025

I have one extra country loaf available to pick up today, 9/4. $8. Message me asap to reserve it.

08/31/2025

I will have Classic and Italian herb sourdough loaves available for pick up Tuesday afternoon. Message me asap to reserve a loaf. Limited number available.
$7 for Classic
$8 for Italian herb
Pictured below is Italian Herb sourdough

08/25/2025

Updated: SOLD!!!! Message me if you’d like a loaf another day this week !

I still have 1 classic loaf available this afternoon for $7. Message me asap to reserve it! It’s almost tomato soup weather. Make some grilled cheese tonight too!

Address

Rome-Sullivan
Sullivan, WI
53178

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Third Day Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Third Day Bakery:

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Sullivan?