The Mystical Whisk

The Mystical Whisk The Mystical Whisk Bakery

These gals are gala ready. 💃🏼Red Velvet with CreamCheese frosting & Chocolate with Peanut Butter Buttercream.
05/09/2026

These gals are gala ready. 💃🏼

Red Velvet with CreamCheese frosting & Chocolate with Peanut Butter Buttercream.

Preorder your Easter Cookie Kit. These are such a fun and delicious DIY. Kits are $12/each. The kits come with: 1 dozen...
03/15/2026

Preorder your Easter Cookie Kit.

These are such a fun and delicious DIY.

Kits are $12/each.

The kits come with:
1 dozen sugar cookies
2 containers of sprinkles
3 pipping bags of buttercream

Kits will be available for pickup on April 3rd, 2026 from 8am -5pm at Story City Locker located at 236 W Broad St in Story City. If you’d like a kit before or after this date please reach out to me.

Kits can be paid for through Venmo or cash before or at the time of pick up.

Please place your order by April 1st to insure I have time to get all orders filled.

Pro-tip, once you’ve ordered your kit set a reminder in your calendar to pick 4/3/2026 before 5pm.

If you ordered a Valentines Cookie Kit stop in to Story City Locker at 236 W Broad St to pick up before 5pm.
02/13/2026

If you ordered a Valentines Cookie Kit stop in to Story City Locker at 236 W Broad St to pick up before 5pm.

Valentine Cookie Kits available for preorder. $12/dozen Each kit contains:1 dozen sugar cookies2 containers of sprinkles...
01/25/2026

Valentine Cookie Kits available for preorder.

$12/dozen

Each kit contains:
1 dozen sugar cookies
2 containers of sprinkles
3 bags of buttercream

Kits are available for pickup February 13th, from 8am-5pm Story City Locker located at 236 W Broad St in Story City, Ia.

If you would like a different pickup date please let me know at least 2 days in advance.

Please have your orders in before February 11th.

For a very special customer 💗
12/20/2025

For a very special customer 💗

Pre order cookie kits are ready for pickup. Pick up Story City Locker before 5pm today.
12/19/2025

Pre order cookie kits are ready for pickup.

Pick up Story City Locker before 5pm today.

Wednesday12/17/25 is the last day to order Christmas Cookie Kits. Each Kit comes with:1 dozen sugar cookies 2 container...
12/16/2025

Wednesday12/17/25 is the last day to order Christmas Cookie Kits.

Each Kit comes with:
1 dozen sugar cookies
2 containers of sprinkles
3 bags of buttercream

Cookie Kits are $12/dozen and will be available for pickup 12/19 at the Story City Locker located at 236 W Broad St. from 8am-5pm.

Thank you to everyone who has already paid, if you want to pay at pick up please have cash, check, or venmo.

Some tips for keeping cookies fresh if not using right away.

Store in an airtight container and freeze until the day of use. Cookies and buttercream can be frozen and will thaw with an hour.

If you have leftover cookies and want them to be soft, place in an airtight container after the buttercream dries a bit.

If your cookies are stored long enough to get a little hard, put a piece of white bread in an airtight container with the cookies over night, the moisture from the bread will soften them back up.

Thank you to all who ordered, I am honoured to be a small part of your Christmas tradition, by sharing one of mine.

♥️

So many cookies to choose from, but my favorite is Brown Butter Caramel… 🤤
12/10/2025

So many cookies to choose from, but my favorite is Brown Butter Caramel… 🤤

These are so cute ♥️💚
12/09/2025

These are so cute ♥️💚

Fireside coffee ♥️☕️This is always a favorite. I slightly altered the recipe that I got from a dear friend. 2 Cups Cocoa...
12/07/2025

Fireside coffee ♥️☕️

This is always a favorite.

I slightly altered the recipe that I got from a dear friend.

2 Cups Cocoa mix
2 Cups dry coffee creamer
1 1/2 Cups sugar
1 Cup instant coffee
2 tsp Cinnamon
Mix well & store in an airtight container.

3Tbsp for a regular size coffee mug is a good start, add until your heart is happy. So good with whipped cream.

3 Cups to a gallon of water for larger amounts.

Enjoy 😘

Address

Story City, IA
50248

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 3pm
Wednesday 9am - 3pm
Thursday 9am - 3pm
Friday 9am - 3pm
Saturday 9am - 1pm

Telephone

+13526300160

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Mystical Whisk posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Mystical Whisk:

Shortcuts

Share

Category