Not Your Average Batch

Not Your Average Batch Hi, I’m Hayley! 🍪 ✨ I’m a licensed cottage baker located out of Shepherdsville, KY.

I specialize in custom decorated sugar cookies and cookie cakes that are perfect for any occasion—birthdays, weddings, holidays, or just because!
📩Email or DM to order!

07/26/2025

I have cookies leftover from the farmers market this morning. $2 each or 1 dozen for $20.

I have the following flavors:
“Not your birthday cookies”- sprinkle sugar cookies w/ white chocolate chips
“Talk PB to me”- peanut butter chocolate chip
“Don’t fluff with me”- marshmallow crispy cookies
“Oat of control”- oatmeal chocolate chip

DM for address!

07/21/2025

🍪 Farmer’s Market Spotlight: Hayley Beeler! 🍪

While you're shopping the Shepherdsville Farmers Market this Saturday, make sure to stop by and say hello to our spotlight vendor — Hayley Beeler, the talented cottage baker and owner of Not Your Average Batch!

Hayley specializes in custom-decorated sugar cookies and cookie cakes that are as beautiful as they are delicious. She also offers rotating flavors of drop cookies you won’t want to miss!

Come support local and treat yourself to something sweet! 💛

July 26th, 9AM-NOON
170 W. Joe B. Hall Avenue

Last minute Easter goodies available for pickup. “Bunny Bait” bags (3) $18Individual cookies (5) $3Paint-your-own Easter...
04/19/2025

Last minute Easter goodies available for pickup.

“Bunny Bait” bags (3) $18
Individual cookies (5) $3
Paint-your-own Easter egg cookie kits (9) $12
Half-dozen Easter themed cookie decorating kit (1) $15
Mini cookie cakes (12) $6 (flavors: browned butter chocolate chip, M&M, sugar cookie sprinkle, chocolate chocolate chip)

Get your mini lucky charm cookie bags for $20. They’re magically delicious 🍀🌈😋. DM to place an order!
03/10/2025

Get your mini lucky charm cookie bags for $20. They’re magically delicious 🍀🌈😋. DM to place an order!

💕Some sweet sets for Valentine’s Day 😍 💌 Check out my highlights tab for more V-day go...
01/27/2025

💕Some sweet sets for Valentine’s Day 😍

💌 Check out my highlights tab for more V-day goodies and ordering options!








Sugar cookie sprinkle cookie cake 😍 pairs well with a glass (or two) of Chardonnay 🍷 Perfect for that special someone. O...
01/20/2025

Sugar cookie sprinkle cookie cake 😍 pairs well with a glass (or two) of Chardonnay 🍷 Perfect for that special someone. Order with the link below!

https://form.jotform.com/250156190026145

⏰ Just a reminder to place your orders for cookie kits before the 22nd! Half Dozen ($15): • 6 sugar cookies with 2 diffe...
12/15/2024

⏰ Just a reminder to place your orders for cookie kits before the 22nd!

Half Dozen ($15):
• 6 sugar cookies with 2 different shapes
• 2 bags of royal icing
• 1 side of sprinkles

Dozen ($25):
• 12 sugar cookie with 4 different shapes
• 4 bags of royal icing
• 2 sides of sprinkles

📩 DM or comment below to place your order.

🎄✨ It’s the most wonderful time of the year! ✨ ••••
12/13/2024

🎄✨ It’s the most wonderful time of the year! ✨
•
•
•
•

Address

Shepherdsville, KY
40165

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Not Your Average Batch posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Not Your Average Batch:

Shortcuts

Share

Category